Player comparison thread

[Modra93]

Any chance mick will play him off half back if Shaw is being dragged deep and taken out of the action? Or hasnt trained with the backline at all..?

 

[Jay-Z]

I'm trying to decide between Lachie Hansen and Gavin Urquhart for my 7th back... opinions please?

 

[Biggy_Boy]

So who is better to start with, Bartel or Ablett?

I'm thinking it's probably best to start with at least one of these guys in the mids, but it's hard to split the two. They're both around the same price.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

I'm trying to decide between Lachie Hansen and Gavin Urquhart for my 7th back... opinions please?

Tom Collier?

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

So who is better to start with, Bartel or Ablett?

I'm thinking it's probably best to start with at least one of these guys in the mids, but it's hard to split the two. They're both around the same price.

I havent got one of them, they are too expensive.
I would say free up some cash and get Swan/Thompson.

 

[Jay-Z]

Tom Collier?

Nope, both Hansen and Urqs will outscore Collier.

 

[DaVe86]

Any chance mick will play him off half back if Shaw is being dragged deep and taken out of the action? Or hasnt trained with the backline at all..?

no indication that he has trained backline. However he did spend a lot of time there in the TAC cup just racking up the stats.

I got no doubt he'll spend much time in the back half as well...but i think to start they'll ease him in as a forward flanker probably rotating with guys like Thomas/Didak/Davis etc.

Don't think we'll see a lot of him right in the guts. Probably Stanley will start in this position. Spewing Stanley's price went up 50K on what fanfooty had predicted because he was a real smokie but now is too high.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

David Myers vs Xavier Ellis vs Ricky Petterd?

 

[Athomas]

David Myers vs Xavier Ellis vs Ricky Petterd?

Was thinking Myers, with mroe gametime will be a gun.

If Petterd is named and Pre-Season signs look good then that is very tempting as well.

Not interested in Ellis personally.

 

[DaVe86]

David Myers vs Xavier Ellis vs Ricky Petterd?

most 1 sided post i've see so far. Obviously just trying to get praise for your Essendon boy.


Ellis is out half the year...petterd is not even guarenteed a spot and is cheaper than the rest.

Obviously Myers by a country mile. If Ellis were fit for r1 then we'd have a proper convo.

 

[samwise]

David Myers vs Xavier Ellis vs Ricky Petterd?

1. Ellis
2. Myers / Petterd
but dont make these decisions until after the nab cup. all you should be doing now is sorting out your structure and collecting those types of questions for your different priced players in your team structure. Just play around with things like:
if i have a rookie starting in the forward line then i can have ablett but if i have lucas instead of a rookie then i can have boak as well for example.

 

[whichone]

Swan or Thomspon for the premium mid?? Or maybe go the cheaper option in a Selwood/Pendelbury type.

 

[Athomas]

Ablett vs Bartel.


No-one seems on Ablett, he could be very unique (for the elite anyway). Thoughts? Can Ablett keep injury free?

 

[aaronm46]

Is it really neccessary asking about Ablett and Bartel, I mean there both absolute guns.

not trying to be mean.

 

[GeeCats07]

Houli vs Malceski vs R. Houlihan

Will probably end up with two of these guys, but which two do you think?

 

[SteeleBeams]

Jude Bolton vs Pendlebury - I currently have Bolton, but after seeing pendles last night, i am thinking twice about swapping Bolton for Pendles. Someone to PM me what they think.

 

[Lakey91]

Now i havent seen the game yet as it was on late last night here (1am) so i taped it, but the thing that worries me a little about pendlebury (just going from the stats), is that although he got 31 possesions, he still only got 93 DT points.

 

[gdogga]

Hodge and Firrito vs Birchall and Houli/Ellis

 

[Longy13]

Sam Fisher v Heath Scotland?

 

[swansational05]

Would you have mattner in your side. Im pondering between Mattner and H Shaw

IMO, if H Shaw gets tagged he'll go really bad.
( happened to me last year)

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Hodge and Firrito vs Birchall and Houli/Ellis

2nd once easily.

 

[force65]

Hodge and Firrito vs Birchall and Houli/Ellis

isnt ellis injured?

 

[bigburger]

Sam Fisher v Heath Scotland?

Fish easily. Very consistant and younger.

 

[bigburger]

OK heres a good one

Ibbotson

vs

Masten

???

 

[force65]

OK heres a good one

Ibbotson

vs

Masten

???

masten by a long way