Player Form Thread

[BeornJ]

I figure we've got a thread to keep track of players injuries but how about one for their form.

Good way to keep track of who needs to lift and who is in career best form.


As of Rd 17

Ryan 5-6
LeCras inj- 7
Gaff 10
Sheed 5-6
Sheppard 9
Yeo 9-8
Masten 7
Redden 9-10
Naitanui 8- inj
Brander 4
O. Allen 5
Shuey 8
Duggan 7
Cripps 7
MacKenzie inj
Kennedy inj
Venables 4 - 6
Vardy 3
McGovern 6 - 8
Petruccelle ?
Brayshaw ?
Jetta 7 - 8
Partington ?
Hurn 10
Darling inj- 8
Cole 7
Lycett 7 - 8
Nelson ?
Schofield 6 - 5
Ainsworth 6
Hutchings 8
Rotham ?
Barrass inj
Mutimer ?
Karpany inj
Ah Chee 4
M. Allen ?
Rioli 6 - 8
Waterman 5 - 7

 

[Balls In]

Nicnat too high. Jetta too high. Schofield too low. Cripps too high. Redden too high. Not a bad effort

 

[avishka5]

This doesn't bode well for Muzza.

 

[Ok Boomer]

Mutimer 10

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Mutimer 10

Mutimer 7000000

 

[kerrazy]

Noticed there's no Edwards. Must be because he is off the scale.

 

[Eaglespur]

Bit rough on Oscar.. considering he's played one game and did his job is that a 10?

 

[BeornJ]

Bit rough on Oscar.. considering he's played one game and did his job is that a 10?

Fair enough. By 10 I mean a player has reached their potential and is maintaining amazing career best form ie Gaff and Hurn

 

[FKASC]

I will only consume this data in Excel format

 

[WCFaithful]

Jetta deserves nothing more than a 5. He has the potential to be a game breaker but is playing like a lazy pea heart

 

[BeornJ]

I will only consume this data in Excel format

here's what you do...


find the data, pick up a permanent marker, draw a box around the data on your screen.

Better?

 

[BeornJ]

Jetta deserves nothing more than a 5. He has the potential to be a game breaker but is playing like a lazy pea heart

Nah. He is filling his role pretty well

 

[Eaglespur]

Jetta deserves nothing more than a 5. He has the potential to be a game breaker but is playing like a lazy pea heart

I'd have dropped him

 

[Ok Boomer]

His kicking is too good to drop.

 

[fidstar]

Form is a hard one. Is it how they are traveling over the season, or immediate form (so say the last 4 weeks)?

I probably lean towards the latter.

And it seems that a 10 is career best form, so would that make guys like Rioli a 10?

Nic Nat is way over. He'd be a 5 at best.
Shuey the same.
McGovern is probably a 5 as well.

Though overall you've done a good job. But super-subjective.

 

[BeornJ]

Form is a hard one. Is it how they are traveling over the season, or immediate form (so say the last 4 weeks)?

I probably lean towards the latter.

And it seems that a 10 is career best form, so would that make guys like Rioli a 10?

Nic Nat is way over. He'd be a 5 at best.
Shuey the same.
McGovern is probably a 5 as well.

Though overall you've done a good job. But super-subjective.

hmm I guess 10 is more about reaching full potential and maintaining for at least the past 4 weeks.

It's harder with the younger players to predict what they could be capable of. For example Duggan and Cole are playing solid footy, playing their role every week, getting the job done, but I reckon they can reach greater heights.

Yeah NN should be lower, McGovern too.

I would be interested to keep track of this every week. In the next few rounds the key is to win a couple of tough away games, lock in the top 4 spot, then it's all about form and fitness.

The midfield is looking very healthy at the moment. Gaff is CB (Career best), same with Redden. Yeo has become the complete mid we all hoped he could become and Shuey is regaining form. Masten's form has dipped but it was CB earlier in the year. If Sheed and NN can regain form and the other mids and part timers can keep playing good footy then the midfield is looking great.

Defense. Once McGovern gets sent back it looks f#@king Great. Hurn and Shep both CB. Cole and Duggan are going great. Jetts has his haters but I think he is vital to the way WC play. Schoey and Barrass should fight for the last spot.

Forward line. Well Darling was in CB earlier in the year so hopefully he can regain that. Lecras wasnt too far off at the start of the year. And Joshy has been in CB for the past 5 years. Cripps has been solid and Rioli has shown what he is capable of. Hopefully the last spot can be settled over the next few weeks. I have a feeling Ryan wont get back to his best this year so it will probably be either VB or Waterman

Very exciting times

 

[Luuuc]

I will only consume this data in Excel format

Gaff, Shep, Yeo, Redden, Shuey, Nic Nat & Hurn all excel. The remainder do not. Cole is too slow. Masten is quite quick but is microsoft.
Word.

 

[BeornJ]

OP modified to take recent game into account

 

[ioppolo]

Cole a 9 & Schofield a 7