Player or Dud?

[lids2004roar]

Excellent thread RT, so far it's my vote for thread of the year


Roughead could still be a superstar.

Tambling could still be a superstar.



Lay off these kids as you never know where they are headed.

 

[_RT_]

The best thing about this thread is even after I gave away who the player was people are still voting him as a DUD.

 

[HBK619]

If you actually think about it, Barry Hall wasn't a great player before he left the Saints, he was always getting reported he was angry and just wasn't good enough.

He then moved to Sydney and realised his potential, but I guess what it really does say is that you cant judge a player by his first few years, as many people are doing with so many players nowadays, not just with Tambling either.

BTW can you do some more of these, they are fun!!!