player review rd12

Remove this Banner Ad

Pneldebury - the effort was there as usual but bugger all impact this time in
Frost - probably did as well as he could under the circumstances but fmd he fumbles just about everything he lays his hands on
Maynard - good aggression and skills mixed with horrible decision making but didn't drop his bundle, we're in for a bumpy ride but it will be worth it in the end
Sidebottom - bright start but totally obliterated by Bugg after 1/4 time, not ******* good enough
Treloar - great third quarter but was rather ineffective otherwise
Cox - bordering on liability for most of the game despite having few scoring opportunities
Grundy - looked very cumbersome and tired once again, still the best of our rucks
De Goey - he was alright, battled hard but unlike to ever be the player we're all hoping for
White - probably our best forward which shows our sad state of affairs, no slight on him though
Reid - just didn't look right at all
Marsh - very nervous game, tries to do way too much, decent third quarter but
Williams - the zest for contest was there as usual but didn't look much fit, obvious improver
Witts - absolutely deplorable until the game was completely over, it's a travesty we didn't trade him last year just because he refused...
Cripps - shocking game, he's much better than that
Greenwood - nice start but very poor otherwise, should have been on Jones from the get go
Phillips - the game was too quick for him, hopefully he can adjust with time
Smith - hardly knew he was on, will be serviceable at times but very limited and not the answer going forward
Crocker - genuinely thought he was injured last week, has some good traits but fitness nowhere near it
Blair - absolute garbage as 90% of his miraculous carrer has been, ibeing played in Clokey's position just to make it more hilarious
Sinclair - hasn't done much wrong or right, business as pretty much usual
Howe - started on fire but was shut down after 1/4 time
Varcoe - glimpses of getting best to his best but tperformed the Houdini act after half time
 
I can't be bothered with a player review to be honest.

All i'll say is it's so disheartening to watch the Pies at the moment.

Not one player was good today for mine. That is all that needs to be stated for the record.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Pneldebury - the effort was there as usual but bugger all impact this time in
Frost - probably did as well as he could under the circumstances but fmd he fumbles just about everything he lays his hands on
Maynard - good aggression and skills mixed with horrible decision making but didn't drop his bundle, we're in for a bumpy ride but it will be worth it in the end
Sidebottom - bright start but totally obliterated by Bugg after 1/4 time, not ******* good enough
Treloar - great third quarter but was rather ineffective otherwise
Cox - bordering on liability for most of the game despite having few scoring opportunities
Grundy - looked very cumbersome and tired once again, still the best of our rucks
De Goey - he was alright, battled hard but unlike to ever be the player we're all hoping for
White - probably our best forward which shows our sad state of affairs, no slight on him though
Reid - just didn't look right at all
Marsh - very nervous game, tries to do way too much, decent third quarter but
Williams - the zest for contest was there as usual but didn't look much fit, obvious improver
Witts - absolutely deplorable until the game was completely over, it's a travesty we didn't trade him last year just because he refused...
Cripps - shocking game, he's much better than that
Greenwood - nice start but very poor otherwise, should have been on Jones from the get go
Phillips - the game was too quick for him, hopefully he can adjust with time
Smith - hardly knew he was on, will be serviceable at times but very limited and not the answer going forward
Crocker - genuinely thought he was injured last week, has some good traits but fitness nowhere near it
Blair - absolute garbage as 90% of his miraculous carrer has been, ibeing played in Clokey's position just to make it more hilarious
Sinclair - hasn't done much wrong or right, business as pretty much usual
Howe - started on fire but was shut down after 1/4 time
Varcoe - glimpses of getting best to his best but tperformed the Houdini act after half time

If only Cripps was playing for us. If only.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Too many players with sub-standard skills, you can carry a few, but it's painful to watch at present.

Maynard is a bright spot though.
 
Smith is no good. High disposal numbers but does sfa with it. Compare him to Jeremy Howe, even a 20 metre kick is damaging from that bloke, mostly because he nails it on our players chest despite them being inbetween 2 of the oppositions players.

Marleys already back, but once Adams and Ramsay are back we can start playing more competitive footy in our backline.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top