Review Player review vs Cats

[Copeland]

im not going to be upset if we lose cloke

Imagine Cloke in AA form this year, we would be near unbeatable.

 

[blaze036]

Buckley was reported as having a migraine in the game.. so cut him some slack

 

[handy point]

Just from memory at the moment and ill have some more concise opinions when i see the game again

Dawes - thought he worked really well and was involved in the game throughout. That set shot goal must do wonders for his confidence and finishing with 2 for the night should give him some satisfaction and a platform to build on. Was better than Cloke imo

Cloke - Really poor i felt and was really towelled up by Lonergan

Taz - Really good early on, probably shouldve finished with more than 2 but provided a real option. I think that this might just work. Even though we look pretty tall up front, Taz and the Sack provide a lot of versatility as talls and apply a great deal of pressure. Just might work

Swan - Worked really hard but disposal was a little sloppy at times. Werent great conditions, which wouldve attributed to some of his errors though. Gotta love him though

Pendles - Picked up right where he left off. Best mid in the comp imo

Brown - Hawkins did a number on him tonight. Seemed to always be caught a couple of meters behind and seemed unsure how to go about defending the big man. Had Hawk kicked a little straighter it wouldve looked a lot worse for young browny

Shaw - Love the guy, love his work rate, his attack at the contest and his leadership... but gee he can make some really terrible decisions by foot at times. He provided us with a lot of run tonight however and is easily in the best 5 players on ground

Buckley - in a word, poor

Pretty happy with the result overall, though i kinda wish we'd put the foot down and made a really big statement.

Really?

 

[SuperSub17]

Intersting how Swan got 0 coaches votes; neither Bucks nor Chris Scott had him in the best 5 players on the ground.

 

[jonbe54]

Imagine Cloke in AA form this year, we would be near unbeatable.

Imagine Cloke in any sort of form this year

 

[the mighty T]

Really?

Really really

 

[Copeland]

Imagine Cloke in any sort of form this year

I agree, he's had some very poor games recently, I also hate what's going on with him but I dont want him gone, just sign the contract and find form for the finals.