Player X or Player Y

[peteshep]

for me, ROK. Only as he is a midfielder But maybe even none? Both haven't done a whole lot in the NAB cup. Then again, it is only the NAB cup.

Speaking of forwards. Who (after Roo) would be everyones number choice? Would you believe it- I'm having trouble deciding my premium forwards!!

 

[Mr Mosquito]

J. Brown.....ability to play the lead up forward and his strength in the contested mark category, as well as his goal kicking power makes him a lock for me.


Tippett and Jay Nash OR Ziebell and Kennelly

 

[thomas_m18]

J. Brown.....ability to play the lead up forward and his strength in the contested mark category, as well as his goal kicking power makes him a lock for me.


Tippett and Jay Nash OR Ziebell and Kennelly

Hmmmm, this one's sorta sketchy for me. I'm going Tippett and Nash, by a little margin.

My turn.

Michael Barlow, Ryan Bastinac and Nic Naitanui

OR

Luke Shuey, Mitchell Banner and David Hille?


Second Question:

Lobbe or Skipper (I do not have Tippett, if that changes anything)

 

[Mr Mosquito]

Option A.

Barlow will be very handy....his elevation is almost assured. However Id rather hille than nic nat

 

[thomas_m18]

Hille and Dennis Lane or Naitanui and Rockliff?

Lobbe or Skipper on the bench (don't have Tippett)

 

[russea]

Hille and Dennis Lane or Naitanui and Rockliff?

Lobbe or Skipper on the bench (don't have Tippett)

Hmmm not sure DL after all this hype didnt get a game for syd in nab will he play over 15 games? i say no. So I'ld go nic nat and the rock
and secondly lobbe over skip

 

[thomas_m18]

Hmmm not sure DL after all this hype didnt get a game for syd in nab will he play over 15 games? i say no. So I'ld go nic nat and the rock
and secondly lobbe over skip

I heard TDL didn't play because of a sore knee

http://sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/new-swans-to-adapt-86560

By the way, Lobbe has been very, very underwhelming

 

[russea]

I heard TDL didn't play because of a sore knee

http://sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/new-swans-to-adapt-86560

By the way, Lobbe has been very, very underwhelming

Hmmm i still stand with the 1st option
Underwhelming.....

 

[thomas_m18]

In other words, a lot of the reserve ruckman suck. Only Warnock is really a shoe-in at the moment

 

[Windas_Magic]

Dal Santo Vs Sewell Vs Mitchell Vs Bartel

Thanks guys

 

[russea]

In other words, a lot of the reserve ruckman suck. Only Warnock is really a shoe-in at the moment

well port dont have much in there ruck stocks so i would still go lobbe at 100k???

 

[russea]

Dal Santo Vs Sewell Vs Mitchell Vs Bartel

Thanks guys

4 really good players i think sewell is the weakest link out of the 4. so left with 3 any1 will do dependes how much $$$ u want to upgrade if u need 2

 

[Syd Dynamite]

Dal Santo Vs Sewell Vs Mitchell Vs Bartel

Thanks guys

Dal santo for me

Brad sheppard or beau waters?

 

[thomas_m18]

well port dont have much in there ruck stocks so i would still go lobbe at 100k???

Well, Port do have Cam Cloke, who they could play over Lobbe. Let's see what happens

 

[russea]

Dal santo for me

Brad sheppard or beau waters?

If i had to choose start with waters and then see who gets pick rd1 if sheppard gets picked just trade b4 lockout

 

[russea]

My question
Malcheski or greenwood+45k???

 

[thomas_m18]

My question
Malcheski or greenwood+45k???

I have to say Malceski, I personally think he has more upside, and I dunno how many points Greenwood will get in his tag role (at least I think it's a tag role).

My question - Barlow or Trengove? (this one is making me thing quite a bit, not as simple as "Trengove is better" to me anymore, Barlow has looked terrific.)

 

[jakee]

'malcheski' has being a constant disspointment imo. He's one of those players that looks like there gunna explode each season but never do. Greenwood probably has more potential to grow in price and to gain higher scores this year. ITs really a gamble though, maybe '10 is malceski's year.

Armitage vs. Peake..... Can't decide who will get more game time this year, neither are really guarenteed a starting spot in the 22 yet. Im leaning more towards amirtage at the moment.

 

[Impromptu]

My question
Malcheski or greenwood+45k???

Greenwood

......
My question - Barlow or Trengove? (this one is making me thing quite a bit, not as simple as "Trengove is better" to me anymore, Barlow has looked terrific.)

Barlow (but you need cover), otherwise Trengrove

 

[russea]

'malcheski' has being a constant disspointment imo. He's one of those players that looks like there gunna explode each season but never do. Greenwood probably has more potential to grow in price and to gain higher scores this year. ITs really a gamble though, maybe '10 is malceski's year.

Armitage vs. Peake..... Can't decide who will get more game time this year, neither are really guarenteed a starting spot in the 22 yet. Im leaning more towards amirtage at the moment.

Yea i hope 2010 is the year mal fires and i have to agree armitage for me

 

[chokewood1]

Tossing these two up
Swan V Hayes

Goodes V O'Keefe

 

[thomas_m18]

Tossing these two up
Swan V Hayes

Goodes V O'Keefe

Ablett.

Seriously though, I'd say Swan and O'Keefe.

I think the other 2 may slide a little, although I'm probably wrong.

My Question

Joel Macdonald and Levi Greenwood

OR

Heath Shaw and Beau Waters

First one looks miles ahead, but just making sure.

 

[russea]

Tossing these two up
Swan V Hayes

Goodes V O'Keefe

Um yea swan and Rok for me. I think Rok will improve his average this year if he plays midfield more than in the forwardline like he did last seaon

 

[russea]

Ablett.

Seriously though, I'd say Swan and O'Keefe.

I think the other 2 may slide a little, although I'm probably wrong.

My Question

Joel Macdonald and Levi Greenwood

OR

Heath Shaw and Beau Waters

First one looks miles ahead, but just making sure.

Yea think ur right Macca and Levi 4 me

 

[russea]

One quick question
Barlow or Lewis Jetta???