Player X or Player Y

[thomas_m18]

Leigh Montagna and Adam Cooney

OR

Ryan O'Keefe and Sam Mitchell

(I have Ablett, Swan, Martin and Barlow in my mids)

 

[russea]

Leigh Montagna and Adam Cooney

OR

Ryan O'Keefe and Sam Mitchell

(I have Ablett, Swan, Martin and Barlow in my mids)

hmm really a toss up montagnas avg wont improve IMO. but cooneys could, Rok should do well and mitchell im not sure about i dont know to keep him or dump him???
so montagna and coons for me

 

[russea]

At the moment iv got mitchell but not sure about him any ideas on who i could get around that price???

bty iv got 8k in the bank

bty again my current midfield is Ablett, Pendles, Selwood,Mitchell(?) Martin, barlow

 

[Kanga_01]

Trying to sort out the backline and have been torn on these guys for a while:

Duffield vs Hurn vs S.Fisher vs Hargrave (already have Hodge & Enright)

&

As the 7th back Waters vs Schoenmakers

Cheers guys

 

[russea]

Trying to sort out the backline and have been torn on these guys for a while:

Duffield vs Hurn vs S.Fisher vs Hargrave (already have Hodge & Enright)

&

As the 7th back Waters vs Schoenmakers

Cheers guys

For me out of those 4 dufffield by a mile very underrated outside of W.A and is a gun or Hurn if u want some extra cash

Second one i'ld go schoemakers not confident with waters(even though hes in my team cant find a way to upgrade him) so yea schoenmakers for me

 

[thomas_m18]

At the moment iv got mitchell but dont no about him any ideas on who i should get around that price

bty iv got 8k in the bank

bty again my current midfield is Ablett, Pendles, Selwood,Mitchell(?) Martin, barlow

You could buy ROK, or Bryce Gibbs. Don't see much else around that price.

Mitchell should be alright.


Alright, here's my question.

Hille, Montagna and Cooney or Naitanui, Selwood and Gibbs?

 

[Kanga_01]

Cheers Russea.

You nailed the two i have in there at the moment! I just can't get over the line and pick Waters even though i think he should be good value as the 7th this year. Looks like i'm holding onto Duffield at the moment, unles someone else can convinence me otherwise....

 

[russea]

You could buy ROK, or Bryce Gibbs. Don't see much else around that price.

Mitchell should be alright.


Alright, here's my question.

Hille, Montagna and Cooney or Naitanui, Selwood and Gibbs?

For me the second option alot more balance in it

just back to my question Rok i donno will he score more than mitchell???

 

[thomas_m18]

For me the second option alot more balance in it

just back to my question Rok i donno will he score more than mitchell???

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/players/profile.php?firstname=Ryan&surname=O'Keefe

look at his average after round 7. i'm not sure who is better, but those stats suggest ROK is pretty good value.

 

[IDIG]

Probably done a few times but

Ballantyne v Mayne

Ladson v Greenwood

 

[russea]

Probably done a few times but

Ballantyne v Mayne

Ladson v Greenwood

For me mayne and greenwood but not by much

 

[thomas_m18]

Ladson and Gibbs vs Greenwood and O'Keefe

 

[marshie_blues]

ROK vs Pendles vs Mitchell

Ballantyne vs Mayne vs Burton

Lecras vs knights, vs Gia

 

[Judd_Magic]

Probably done a few times but

Ballantyne v Mayne

Ladson v Greenwood

First one is so hard cause I reckon Ballantyne wont have to score as many goals this year to get high points compared to Mayne as Ballantyne all the sudden seems like a tackling machine! LOL!

Um, I'm almost tempted to say Ballantyne but maybe Mayne has more upside.

Greenwood over Ladson I reckon. Is younger, has more upside and less injury prone. He should do well under Scott with more midfield time this year and his pre season form scores have been impressive despite the limited game time.

 

[Hot Tiges]

Quick one here.. Vince Trengrove + 38k vs Dal Santo Barlow and 6k mind you, Barlow would give me 4 dockers - Pavlich, Sandilands and Ballantyne/Mayne!! Although I could drop Pavlich for Boomer..

 

[Judd_Magic]

Quick one here.. Vince Trengrove + 38k vs Dal Santo Barlow and 6k mind you, Barlow would give me 4 dockers - Pavlich, Sandilands and Ballantyne/Mayne!! Although I could drop Pavlich for Boomer..

Dal Santo and Barlow mate will give you more points so go for that option. Still not that convinced about Trengrove yet although will be a great player.

 

[MattyC]

Dal Santo is more relaible, but wait and see if Barlow gets promoted. He should. Few questions for me:

Mitch Clark vs Hamish McIntosh

Pavlich vs Buddy Franklin

Hunt vs Ladson vs Greenwood

These decisions have been racking my brain!

 

[Footbrawler]

Clarke beats McIntosh for his ability to rack up cheap possessions in the back half.

Pavlich beats Franklin for consistency but Franklin is nicely priced. Also Franklin will miss r1. So Pav edges him slightly.

Hunt is generally less injury prone than Ladson but is coming off a reco. Greenwood is a lot less experienced and established than those two so is a greater overall risk IMO.


Mine:

Reiwoldt vs ROK.

 

[Main Man]

Dal Santo is more relaible, but wait and see if Barlow gets promoted. He should. Few questions for me:

Mitch Clark vs Hamish McIntosh

Pavlich vs Buddy Franklin

Hunt vs Ladson vs Greenwood

These decisions have been racking my brain!

Mitch Clark in for another big year I feel, just so mobile for a ruckman, next Dean Cox..

Pavlich and Buddy is a tough one, if Buddy is back to his best I would take him no doubt but maybe Pavlich is a safer option..

If both Ladson and Hunt get back to there best form they are capable of scoring much higher than Greenwood, Id favour Ladson if he gets back to his best but it is too hard to tell at this stage so maybe Greenwood is the safe bet..

Hurn or Grimes?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Roo...... Just for consistency. But only just. I took them both.....

Sandi & McEvoy Vs Clarke & Goldstein

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Mitch Clark in for another big year I feel, just so mobile for a ruckman, next Dean Cox..

Pavlich and Buddy is a tough one, if Buddy is back to his best I would take him no doubt but maybe Pavlich is a safer option..

If both Ladson and Hunt get back to there best form they are capable of scoring much higher than Greenwood, Id favour Ladson if he gets back to his best but it is too hard to tell at this stage so maybe Greenwood is the safe bet..

Hurn or Grimes?

Has to be Hurn doesn't it? Grimes has only played 12 games and while he seems to have the genuine super-star look about him, it's only 12 games... Priced so high too.

 

[TheOutsider]

Roo...... Just for consistency. But only just. I took them both.....

Sandi & McEvoy Vs Clarke & Goldstein

Sandi & McEvoy for mine. I think with King and Gardner a year older McEvoy will play a lot and Sandi didn't shrink over the pre season.


Hall & Brown VS Tippett & Gia

 

[takeiteasy]

tayte pears or tadgh kennelly?

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

tayte pears or tadgh kennelly?

Kannelly... But only because Pears is more of a "stopper" rather than a running back like Kennelly. Happy to be corrected if someone thinks otherwise.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Sandi & McEvoy for mine. I think with King and Gardner a year older McEvoy will play a lot and Sandi didn't shrink over the pre season.


Hall & Brown VS Tippett & Gia

Ouch.... Tough call.....

IF Hall keeps his head, Hall & Brown. But that's a big if. Otherwise, Tippet & Gia.