Player X v Y v Z - 2017

[Unique Name]

Sexy Robbie Gray
vs
The Bont

 

[Daniel McL]

Sexy Robbie Gray
vs
The Bont

Beautiful Bont

 

[gutsroy]

If it could only be one or the other, Macrae or Dahlhaus?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

If it could only be one or the other, Macrae or Dahlhaus?

Dahl.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

 

[Daniel McL]

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

T Mitch for me.
Beams if you want to take the risk.

 

[adammania9]

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

I'm leaning towards both TMitch and Beams, but if one, TMitch doesn't have as much injury worries; he also has a lot of space to roam and win points in Hawthorn's midfield.

Murphy is a decent prospect but I think he's a $520k at best mid from here. The other two have higher ceilings.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

Heppell and the cash. Treloar is a nice POD but a tad overpriced IMO.

 

[toxic]

Sexy Robbie Gray
vs
The Bont

Gray

If it could only be one or the other, Macrae or Dahlhaus?

Outhouse easy

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

MMurphy (none of)

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

treROAR

 

[Moustachio]

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

Underwhelmed by Heppell prospect, unlikely to hit 110 (keeper) after a year off, so that's an extra trade used at some point.

Treloar is a sex machine and pretty likely to end as a top 10 mid (slight bias).

 

[gutsroy]

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

Only looked at Beams vs Murphy, 2012-2016: Beams bigger potential reward and solid VC option. Durability the elephant in the room.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Only looked at Beams vs Murphy, 2012-2016: Beams bigger potential reward and solid VC option. Durability the elephant in the room.
View attachment 317199

Hmmm where are these tables from?

 

[kenneje]

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

Treloar for me. No idea how the Bomber boys are going to go (especially early on) so I'm sticking well clear of the lot of them.

Brett Deledio v Toby Greene?

 

[Glenn Barclay]

danger v Jwood + 110300

 

[toxic]

Treloar for me. No idea how the Bomber boys are going to go (especially early on) so I'm sticking well clear of the lot of them.

Brett Deledio v Toby Greene?

Lids...he's elite

Hibberd v Hartlett

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Treloar for me. No idea how the Bomber boys are going to go (especially early on) so I'm sticking well clear of the lot of them.

Brett Deledio v Toby Greene?

Lids

danger v Jwood + 110300

Danger easily

Lids...he's elite

Hibberd v Hartlett

Hibberd. I think.

 

[kenneje]

Lids...he's elite

Hibberd v Hartlett

Hartlett for the same reason I'd go Treloar over Heppell, I just don't know how the Bombers are going to go early next season.

Also, Hartlett has a track record of being able to go 100+ which is close to what you'll need for a DEF keeper this year.

 

[Kadog]

Lids...he's elite

Hibberd v Hartlett

Pig Hibberd. 30p 90pts most weeks.

 

[Kadog]

Sexy Robbie Gray
vs
The Bont

I'd say Bont. Scores heavily with less touches. Poor Robbie was getting robbed last year. Recall a few games where he looked like 150+ but got dudded with 110s. Both solid options though.

If it could only be one or the other, Macrae or Dahlhaus?

Dahlhouse.

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

Beams

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

Treloar. Absolute gun who'll go around 115avg mark

Brett Deledio v Toby Greene?

Lids

danger v Jwood + 110300

Danger must be number pick in any serious side. Period.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Sexy Robbie Gray
vs
The Bont

Smexy Robbie (just)

Macrae or Dahlhaus?

Dahl by the length of the field

Beams v Murphy v Tmitch

Titch > Beams > Murphy

Treloar v Heppell + 90k

Treloar

Brett Deledio v Toby Greene?

Greene on the basis Deledio wont get on the park much in 2017.

danger v Jwood + 110300

Dangerwood

Hibberd v Hartlett

Hammer by the length of his contract!

 

[Super Hans]

Hannebery vs Selwood vs Treloar

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Hannebery vs Selwood vs Treloar

Treloar
Hanners
Selwood

 

[Flandersss]

Mid price options:

Hibberd v KK

Heeney v Touk-Touk

Bennell v Brayshaw

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Mid price options:

Hibberd v KK

Heeney v Touk-Touk

Bennell v Brayshaw

Hibberd

Heeney

Bennell