Discussion Player X v Y v Z - 2017

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Sep 3, 2005
Posts
26,113
Likes
62,953
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Coast Eagles
I dead set had to fetch a scotch before replying to all these.

Witts (R2) + Beams (M7) + Nank (F4)

vs

Goldy (R1) + O'Meara (M7) + Turner (F4)
Goldy (R1) + O'Meara (M7) + Turner (F4)

Jaeger (m7) + Steele (f4) + jones (d4)

V

Jelwood (m3) + rookie under 160k (d5) + florant (f6)

Thoughts?????
Jelwood (m3) + rookie under 160k (d5) + florant (f6)

Don't like the look of 3 rookies in the backline but it seems like the way to go this year, so..

Tuohy and fwd rookie (Florent) vs Marchbank and Roughead?
Marchbank and Roughead?

Jaeger bombs vs steele.
Obviously depends on Steeles role. Thinking of starting steele and if he's not playing mid make an early trade to jaeger. Thoughts?
JOM based on pure ability

Two from Cripps, Bontempelli, Gray.

Thinking Gray and Cripps ATM, mainly cos I already have Dahl, Macrae and JJ.
Bont and super POD Gray

I'm worrying about Pendles' fitness and thinking about switching him to Treloar - thoughts?
No but it wouldn't ruin your season

Doch and S.Martin v 2E and Treloar?
Swinging nankervis
2E and Treloar

T Mitchell vs Cripps
Tmitch

Ryder + Florent VS Nank + Taranto.
Ryder + Florent

Shaw + Nank + 50k to bank or spend elsewhere

Or

N. Riewoldt + Tuohy
Shaw + Nank + 50k to bank

Currently have:
DEF: Shaw, Laird, Howe
MID: Danger, Treloar, Jelwood, Fyfe, Titch
FWD: NRoo, Dahl, Lynch (GC), Nank, Steele

Howe + Titch + Lynch
vs
Docherty + Pendles + Roughead

Seems kinda silly now I've spelled it out but anyway...
Umm umm. How bout Howe + Tich + Macrae or the other option

Docherty + Pendles + Roughead

Gawn, Roughy & Barrett (M8)
Vs.
Rocky, Nank & Witts (R2)
Gawn, Roughy & Barrett

Laird + Nank +50k
or
Tuohy + Mcrae
Laird + Nank +50k

Currently have Zac Merrett, can't decide whether to keep or swap to Parker or Rockliff
Keep Merrett

Steele, Roughy, Nankervis... Pick 2
If you need ruck cover Nank and Rough if not Rough and Steele

Doch vs Shaw

I think they'll both go 105-110
I am confident I'll end up with both

Has anybody done any research on their first half of the season opponents and how they score or anything like that?

Atm I'm picking Shaw only because he's $20k cheaper and I am hustling for any cash I can get
Shaw, proven to go 100 for more than a year. Team will win more games.

The outcome of this will likely depend on team selections (ie, whether or not Spencer and Lobbe are named), but I am currently grappling with:

1. J Watson (M5), Gawn (R1), Franklin (F2)

2. Pendles (M2), Ryder (R1/F3), Reiwoldt (F1)

Anyone willing to give me a push in one particular direction?
2. Pendles (M2), Ryder (R1/F3), Reiwoldt (F1)


JOM & Oliver
vs
Jobe & Taranto
JOM & Oliver

Rance + Ward or Titch
vs
Shaw + Titch
Shaw + Titch

Riewoldt & Titch vs Buddy & JPK/Hanners?
Buddy & JPK

Bowes v Taranto v WHE
Taranto for points
WHE for cash gen

Sam Docherty and David Swallow

Vs

Zac Jones and Tom Mitchell
Sam Docherty and David Swallow

The one and only question still in my team. Sandi is at R2.

Nank or Roughie?
Nank or Roughie? Are you ******* serious you arse clown.
Only thing I can recommend is delete team you spud.
 

_M_16_

Club Legend
Joined
Nov 26, 2009
Posts
2,737
Likes
3,014
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Liv FC, LA Rams, Pitt Pen, Michigan
I have a couple or so, before I finalize my Supercoach Team, all are pretty close


1. Kennedy or Hannebery? Kennedy is historically most consistent, but Hanners looked better in JLT
2. Bontempelli or T. Mitchell?
3. Macrae or T. Lynch?


Thanks :)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Red Syrah

Club Legend
Joined
May 21, 2014
Posts
1,081
Likes
676
AFL Club
St Kilda
I have a couple or so, before I finalize my Supercoach Team, all are pretty close


1. Kennedy or Hannebery? Kennedy is historically most consistent, but Hanners looked better in JLT
2. Bontempelli or T. Mitchell?
3. Macrae or T. Lynch?


Thanks :)
Talk about lineball - its toss a coin....
Hanners
Titch
MAcrae
 

DraftPunk

Club Legend
Joined
Feb 9, 2016
Posts
1,521
Likes
1,263
AFL Club
St Kilda
Sam Docherty and David Swallow

Vs

Zac Jones and Tom Mitchell
Jones & Tmitch

I have a couple or so, before I finalize my Supercoach Team, all are pretty close


1. Kennedy or Hannebery? Kennedy is historically most consistent, but Hanners looked better in JLT
2. Bontempelli or T. Mitchell?
3. Macrae or T. Lynch?


Thanks :)
Kennedy, Bont, Macrae

F6: Florent v Turner v Simpkin??

Cheers
Turner
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom