Player X vs Player Y (Part II)

[dlanod]

Who to play in Rob Murphy's place?

Mzungu (vs West Coast), Heppell (vs Carlton), Pedersen (vs Brisbane) or I. Smith (vs Melbourne, possible out)?

Tempted to go Pedersen but that's a hell of a gamble over Mzungu or Heppell.

 

[liam_13]

Can go:
B: Adcock
M: Goddard
F: Chapman (NRiewoldt)
or
B: Goddard (Adcock)
M: Chapman
F: Riewoldt

So Adcock vs NRiewoldt?

 

[toxic]

Can go:
B: Adcock
M: Goddard
F: Chapman (NRiewoldt)
or
B: Goddard (Adcock)
M: Chapman
F: Riewoldt

So Adcock vs NRiewoldt?

Nic Roo (surely he has to come good eventually)

 

[Propagandhi]

Can't decide whether to start Jack Riewoldt or Zac Smith.

I have the same problem except with NRoo instead of Jroo... Leaning towards Nick over Zac...

I think I'd play Zac over Jack if I had to choose between those two though...

 

[Deleted member 98541]

midfield upgrade. Hodge or Mitchell?? cheers.

 

[Main Man]

Mitchell is more consistent but Hodge will score more than him from now until seasons end. I'd go Hodge, has the potential to be the highest scoring player in the league for the remaining 7 rounds given his recent form and Hawthorns run home.

 

[kickballfoot]

yarran, krak or mzungi?

 

[timbo3195]

Who to play, I have no idea..?

Pedersen, Heppell or Puopolo?

Cheers in advance

 

[Kopout]

Who to play, I have no idea..?

Pedersen, Heppell or Puopolo?

Cheers in advance

Pedersen. Should see plenty of it against Brisbane.

I Smith or Mzungu?

 

[smidla]

Pedersen. Should see plenty of it against Brisbane.

I Smith or Mzungu?

mzungu for sure.

should i bring in fisher or delidio

 

[Kopout]

should i bring in fisher or delidio

Fisher will get 50 touches roaming across Adelaide's half back line unaccounted for tonight.

Hurley vs Duffield vs Lower

 

[Pedsy]

Really slim pickings to replace Shaw with. Looks like it is between the Hawk boys Suckling and Birchall. Which one should I go for? Seems like coin toss sort of stuff to me, unless some of you that have seen a bit more of the hawks than me this year can give me a few reasons to go one way or the other.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Johncock will be dirt cheap this week

 

[J Squad]

Johncock will be dirt cheap this week

Mmmm picked him up 2 weeks ago and has dropped $70k, now @ $386k

 

[Ed D]

It'll be interesting to see how a new coach at the Crows will effect the team and players. Players given different roles, new players coming in, a change in game style, perhaps a few wins?

 

[timbo3195]

Adcock or Ellis?

I know they both seem like terrible options but I have my reasons.
Although in saying that they were both impressive on the weekend.

 

[yummy6]

Adcock or Ellis?

I know they both seem like terrible options but I have my reasons.
Although in saying that they were both impressive on the weekend.

I've had Adcock all year in the D6/7 position. If that's the position I would go with him mate. He's been solid.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Otten or Stanley on field this week?

 

[Philzsay]

I Smith or Mzungu?

Have the same decision, been chopping and changing, think I will play Smith on the basis that surely he won't be sub two weeks in a row, especially on the open spaces at Subi.

 

[Philzsay]

Have the same decision, been chopping and changing, think I will play Smith on the basis that surely he won't be sub two weeks in a row, especially on the open spaces at Subi.

4 minutes later have changed my mind again!!! Going Mzungu, home team.

 

[celtic67]

Looking to upgrade Mzungu this week for either Chapman or Rioli but I cannot split them! Can anyone help me out? I'd then have Petrie as F8 so Geelong's bye not an issue.

 

[toxic]

One midfield spot too fill.. Priddis, Fyfe, selwood, Thompson or rok???

 

[tripple1zero]

One midfield spot too fill.. Priddis, Fyfe, selwood, Thompson or rok???

Priddis has a favorable run home and has been pretty consistant, but I would have to say selwood unless you care about the bye during league finals. ROK also a good pick for his MPP, as with Fyfe, who is my personnel favorite, but there is a bit of bias there. Freo have a tough run home, and although Fyfe seems to be able to just keep going, I think there is a bit more of a risk with picking him.
So to answer your question. Selwood if you don't care about league, Priddis if you do.

I am in a must win situation in my league. Got two trades left and need to upgrade Lobbe to a ruck. I want to trade in a ruck (as opposed to a forward) so I can cover Petrie in 2 weeks time. Already got Cox and Petrie, Sandi wont play and Goldstien has the bye in finals so I would prefer to avoid that.

Who do I go for? Mumford, McEvoy or who?

 

[celtic67]

Priddis has a favorable run home and has been pretty consistant, but I would have to say selwood unless you care about the bye during league finals. ROK also a good pick for his MPP, as with Fyfe, who is my personnel favorite, but there is a bit of bias there. Freo have a tough run home, and although Fyfe seems to be able to just keep going, I think there is a bit more of a risk with picking him.
So to answer your question. Selwood if you don't care about league, Priddis if you do.

I am in a must win situation in my league. Got two trades left and need to upgrade Lobbe to a ruck. I want to trade in a ruck (as opposed to a forward) so I can cover Petrie in 2 weeks time. Already got Cox and Petrie, Sandi wont play and Goldstien has the bye in finals so I would prefer to avoid that.

Who do I go for? Mumford, McEvoy or who?

Definitely McEvoy mate. Mumford has scored 100 6/12 times this season and the other 6 matches have been poor. Compared to McEvoy's 9/16 and a further 4 of those he scored in the 90's. Just to convince you even more: of St. Kilda's 5 remaining opponents he scored more than 100 against all of them except Cartlon where he scored 98! I was gonna cop a donut in week 1 of the finals so I could then trade Sandi > Goldstein but I reckon I might just bring in McEvoy after doing that research.

 

[toxic]

Priddis has a favorable run home and has been pretty consistant, but I would have to say selwood unless you care about the bye during league finals. ROK also a good pick for his MPP, as with Fyfe, who is my personnel favorite, but there is a bit of bias there. Freo have a tough run home, and although Fyfe seems to be able to just keep going, I think there is a bit more of a risk with picking him.
So to answer your question. Selwood if you don't care about league, Priddis if you do.

I am in a must win situation in my league. Got two trades left and need to upgrade Lobbe to a ruck. I want to trade in a ruck (as opposed to a forward) so I can cover Petrie in 2 weeks time. Already got Cox and Petrie, Sandi wont play and Goldstien has the bye in finals so I would prefer to avoid that.

Who do I go for? Mumford, McEvoy or who?

Personally id go mummy, gardiner and Kosi will both be given more time approaching finals