Player X vs Player Y Thread

[Griff19]

Knights. No contest.

Cheers for that.. One more

Gibbs Vs Deledio

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Cheers for that.. One more

Gibbs Vs Deledio

Gibbs looks more consistent and a more solid scorer.

I've got both in my side, as their MPP is helpful for byes etc

 

[beev]

Polec v Gaff v Conca

 

[Amers]

Cheers for that.. One more

Gibbs Vs Deledio

It's a close call, I have both, but I would go Gibbs, Likely to play in more winning teams, he's moving into the midfield where he may even start to kick a few goals !! I may also be a bit biased !!

1 of B.Harvey, Pav, Goodes, R.O'Keefe ???

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Polec v Gaff v Conca

Conca looks likely to get games. Gaff looks small and not ready, and Polec seems to be behind Lester and Bewick.

All three will become good earners though.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

1 of B.Harvey, Pav, Goodes, R.O'Keefe ???

Goodes, Harvey, Pav, Okeefe.

I've got one.

Foley vs Anthony vs Higgins

 

[Main Man]

It's a close call, I have both, but I would go Gibbs, Likely to play in more winning teams, he's moving into the midfield where he may even start to kick a few goals !! I may also be a bit biased !!

1 of B.Harvey, Pav, Goodes, R.O'Keefe ???

Goodes in my opinion.

For midfield bench spots?

Conca + Irons

or

Bewick + Curnow

Thoughts?

 

[Faz 2000]

1 of B.Harvey, Pav, Goodes, R.O'Keefe ???

All the former must-haves.

I feel Goodes as one more massive year in him, but I might be well and truly wrong.

OK, risk-time:

Higgins and Knights vs Sylvia and Gamble?

 

[w00dy]

Re: Player X vs Y thread

Montanga/Selwood & Ward

Vs

Boak & Cotchin

leaning towards option one...

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

For midfield bench spots?

Conca + Irons

or

Bewick + Curnow

Thoughts?

Conca and Irons, easily.

OK, risk-time:

Higgins and Knights vs Sylvia and Gamble?

LOL higgins and knights easily. Gamble is a steer clear option

Montanga/Selwood & Ward

Vs

Boak & Cotchin

leaning towards option one...

tough one.

i'd risk option 2 tbh.

 

[w00dy]

tough one.

i'd risk option 2 tbh.

yeah, one definite premium and one upgrade vs two possible but uncertain premiums, who look like they could dominate...

 

[Main Man]

Goodes, Harvey, Pav, Okeefe.

I've got one.

Foley vs Anthony vs Higgins

All potential injury risk and all have the potential to average around 100, maybe Higgins as he probably has the most upside and potential for some huge scores.

 

[CaTTer4Eva]

Cotchin vs Boak ?

 

[Badga]

Otten, D. Swallow and McKernan vs Puopolo, Irons/Liba and Higgins

 

[peteshep]

Cotchin vs Boak ?

Boak for mine. But not really sold on both TBH.

Montagna vs Cross

Had Joey all pre-season, then decided on Cross last night, now having second thoughts and thinking of going back to Joey after reading about the scoring changes for kicks to advantage. Joey averages 8 or 9 according to TooSerious which hypothetically could mean an extra 15-20 ppg?

 

[smidla]

higgins vs ziebell. ziebell about 60k cheaper.
is zieball ready to fire......so sick off putting faith in higgins

 

[smidla]

Boak for mine. But not really sold on both TBH.

Montagna vs Cross

Had Joey all pre-season, then decided on Cross last night, now having second thoughts and thinking of going back to Joey after reading about the scoring changes for kicks to advantage. Joey averages 8 or 9 according to TooSerious which hypothetically could mean an extra 15-20 ppg?

joey for sure....watching the bloke week in week out my thoughts are he is a must for supercoach teams.

 

[Badga]

Boak for mine. But not really sold on both TBH.

Montagna vs Cross

Had Joey all pre-season, then decided on Cross last night, now having second thoughts and thinking of going back to Joey after reading about the scoring changes for kicks to advantage. Joey averages 8 or 9 according to TooSerious which hypothetically could mean an extra 15-20 ppg?

I'm a big Montagna fan but with Roo and Goddard I've decided to go in another direction. If you have both of them go Cross

 

[SJ]

I'm a big Montagna fan but with Roo and Goddard I've decided to go in another direction. If you have both of them go Cross

Cross has a bye with the Saints anyway.

 

[Badga]

Cross has a bye with the Saints anyway.

Hmm that is true, out of the 2 I would go Montagna then...

 

[pezz]

Pav Vs Boomer

Battle of the geriatrics

 

[mds00]

Pav Vs Boomer

Battle of the geriatrics

This has been troubling me also but mine is 2 out of:

Pav vs Boomer vs Green.


Can't make my mind up

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Boomer will avg another 100+ this year.

Green is a good option imo

 

[Antimatter]

OK a couple of late head scratchers...

Rioli vs Goodes (already have Buddy)

Chris Newman vs Grundy

And one from...
B Matera vs Tapscott vs Darling vs McKernan (could use as MPP if coupled with Grundy in the backline)

 

[mclovin32]

OK a couple of late head scratchers...

Rioli vs Goodes (already have Buddy)

Chris Newman vs Grundy

And one from...
B Matera vs Tapscott vs Darling vs McKernan (could use as MPP if coupled with Grundy in the backline)

Goodes for the first one, dont think rioli will get much run in the midfield seeing hawks keep bringing in new midfielders, also goodes can play CHF score a heap and run up the midfield.

Grundy, great preseason, newmans getting old IMO

B matera, absolute star



heres mine

Broughton, Conca, Sandilands +89k

Vs

Duffield, Cotchin, Mumford +11k

advice would be appreciated!