Player X vs Player Y Thread

[GotTheGoodes]

...

Mine is:
Goodes vs Pav

Gamble vs Duncan

Dangerfield vs Yarren

Currently my FWD Line stands at:

Roo, Buddy, Goodes, Yarren, Duncan, Krakour, Matera/

I had Pav. Gamble, Danger in but moved them out, still having second thoughts. Also worried about Yarren being used as Sub....

Goodes vs Pav
I'll admit my bias straight out & say you have to go Goodes. He had a poor year last year and should do better this year. I know we'd all rather him in the midfield but I don't think his scores will be as bad as last year even when he goes FWD this year.

Gamble vs Duncan
I'd take a punt on Duncan as opposed to a gamble on Gamble.

Dangerfield vs Yarren
Tough, Dangerfield has been set for a breakout for a year now and burnt the crap outta me last year... And I do like Yarrens new role outta DEF.

I'm having a fun time trying to stop myself from selecting both Cotchin & Foley in the midfield.... Foley is great value IF he stays fit. And Cotchin had a massive preseason (his NAB Cup scores were sensational). Hrmmm...

 

[ManWithNoName]

Prestia v D Swallow

Yes Swallow may end up averaging more, but with Mzungu out Prestia gives me a cheap mid/fwd who'll play most games. Plus it gives me a difference over other teams and saves me $40k.

 

[Luigi]

Prestia v D Swallow

Yes Swallow may end up averaging more, but with Mzungu out Prestia gives me a cheap mid/fwd who'll play most games. Plus it gives me a difference over other teams and saves me $40k.

Personally I've wanted to take Swallow out of my team to be different a few times, but just cant bring myself to do it.

Has anybody at all considered Barry Hall?
Im trying to think of somebody to get out of him Lecras, J.Riewoldt and Sylvia

 

[Blueboys11]

Boak + Yarran

Vs

Cross + Knights.

Doing my head in!!

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Personally I've wanted to take Swallow out of my team to be different a few times, but just cant bring myself to do it.

Has anybody at all considered Barry Hall?
Im trying to think of somebody to get out of him Lecras, J.Riewoldt and Sylvia

If you must, Sylvia. MPP and best of those consistently

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Boak + Yarran

Vs

Cross + Knights.

Doing my head in!!

Cross and Knights.

 

[Axel.]

Walker (Adelaide) v Yarran

 

[Blueboys11]

Cross and Knights.

Yeah, im feeling that.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Yeah, im feeling that.

If Knights can get into it early, he should avg around 90. Absolute gun imo.

Cheap as chips too

 

[StGradey]

Boyd Vs A.Swallow Vs Hayes

 

[skilfulgun]

Been tossing up over this one for a while now!

C.Judd & M.Boyd

Vs.

S.Pendlebury & D.Cross?

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Been tossing up over this one for a while now!

C.Judd & M.Boyd

Vs.

S.Pendlebury & D.Cross?

C Judd and M Boyd, reckon Murphy will get more of a tag this year than Judd.

 

[Ed D]

Boyd Vs A.Swallow Vs Hayes

Boyd is the safest option IMO.

 

[MIGHTY DONS]

Gilbee v Duffield

Harvey v Pav

Franklin v Riewoldt

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Gilbee v Duffield

Harvey v Pav

Franklin v Riewoldt

Duffield
Pav, just
Both of them should be in your side.

 

[shanejet]

dilemma: Foley or Vince or Higgins or Kennedy

I am undecided who to choose from these four in the midfield.
They are all around the same price and all have positives.

Just wondering people's opinions?

Or should I put another rookie in the midfield (bringing the total to 2 on the field) and upgrade a backline position player?

mmmm... dilemma!!

 

[Headless]

Re: dilemma: Foley or Vince or Higgins or Kennedy

I think you should use the designated thread, personally.

 

[Axe]

Re: dilemma: Foley or Vince or Higgins or Kennedy

I think you should use the designated thread, personally.

I concur. Merged.

 

[RevDog]

Re: dilemma: Foley or Vince or Higgins or Kennedy

Didak vs. A Swallow in the midfield.

Having Didak gives me the MMP with forwards if I need it but I am a bit unsure as I already have 3 other Collingwood players in the squad including Swan in the midfield.

EDIT: Dangerfield vs. Knights?

I know they are differently priced but I could use the extra cash later in the season I guess.

EDIT II: Smith vs. Matera?

As a emergency on the forward line, Smith gives me MMP with the midfield.

Thoughts?

 

[MIGHTY DONS]

Thanks Shakesphere

Thoughts on Otten v Heppel

 

[RevDog]

Thanks Shakesphere

Thoughts on Otten v Heppel

I've read Otten might be prime for the sub rule, so that could throw a spanner in the works. As it stands I have Otten and Heppell in the midfield. If it is for the backline, I'd look possibly toward Heppell.

 

[peter_ford]

Knights. I think Walker will be hot/cold where Knights will be a bit more consistent. Avearging around 70 - 80.

C. Ward and D. Cox

or

D. Cross and D. Petrie

Ward is impressing with his hardness and finishing; ave 114 over NAB. Cox is a supercoach hero and will only be derailed by injury; he is effective an extra midfielder. Both had very impressive preseason's.

Cross is a supercoach specialist but Ward will do the same job with 300k in your pocket and Petrie will miss a few weeks earlier though Petrie should eventually make his way into your team as a backup ruck or starting forward...

mine is: Pavlich vs. Rioli?

 

[fr_303]

mine is: Pavlich vs. Rioli?

I went with PAV - To many so so game from Cyril

Mine is P. Veszpremi or R Gamble
for my last starting spot in the forward line. Who's more likely to play RD1

 

[shanejet]

Re: dilemma: Foley or Vince or Higgins or Kennedy

I think you should use the designated thread, personally.

yes, so do I.
Forgot about this thread

 

[MightyTiger]

Higgins vs Mitch Morton