Player X vs Player Y Thread

[Antimatter]

Goodes for the first one, dont think rioli will get much run in the midfield seeing hawks keep bringing in new midfielders, also goodes can play CHF score a heap and run up the midfield.

Grundy, great preseason, newmans getting old IMO

B matera, absolute star



heres mine

Broughton, Conca, Sandilands +89k

Vs

Duffield, Cotchin, Mumford +11k

advice would be appreciated!

Thanks for the feedback

If it were me I'd go for your 1st option...Broughton is points in the bank each week whereas Duffield struggles away from home. Cotchin's preseason form has been eye catching, but I remember a similar scenario with Chris Masten last year and that was all a furphy...Mummy is on the rise, but Sandilnads is still king of the rucks...plus you pocket the extra cash!

And one more from me, who would you choose from:

Tapscott vs Darling?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

tapscott

Judd or Murphy?

the uniqueness of murph + the potential to jump over judd has me baffled

 

[Badga]

Otten, D. Swallow and McKernan vs Puopolo, Liba and Higgins

Any thoughts on this one? Or I could just trade Yarren to Higgins??

 

[StGradey]

Judd or Murphy?

i've gone with judd.

Hayes & R.Tarrant Vs Foley & any Defender under 346k

 

[celtic67]

Paul Puopolo v Nick Lower

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Any thoughts on this one? Or I could just trade Yarren to Higgins??

get higgins. try to get yarran another way

i've gone with judd.

Hayes & R.Tarrant Vs Foley & any Defender under 346k

hayes and taz, for they will play all year. Foley to get injured and lack of <346ers (everitt maybe) makes it tough

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Paul Puopolo v Nick Lower

Lower defo

paul won't play much imo

 

[Badga]

Paul Puopolo v Nick Lower

Lower.

 

[silent butcher]

rioli v goodes v pav

 

[Hencho]

rioli v goodes v pav

I've got all three in my current side. If i had to choose one I'd say Cyril if you're a gambler, Goodes if you consider preseason form as a good indicator, Pavlich for a solid result week in week out..


Josh Kennedy (syd) or Callan Ward

 

[silent butcher]

rioli v goodes v pav

I've got all three in my current side. If i had to choose one I'd say Cyril if you're a gambler, Goodes if you consider preseason form as a good indicator, Pavlich for a solid result week in week out..


Josh Kennedy (syd) or Callan Ward

ive got franklin in my fwd so dont want two hawks players when i have the bye.

id go ward going to step it up this year

 

[mclovin32]

Boak v Murphy v Cross v anyone else below 560k

 

[richomania]

kennedy for mine,
ward has competition from lots of other elite mids in his side..

 

[Corazon]

Grundy v Le Cras?

Kennedy > Ward IMO.

 

[Hencho]

Boak v Murphy v Cross v anyone else below 560k

If you have the money to spend then murphy. I'd only go boak ahead of those if you needed the money you save from getting him somewhere else.

Boak burnt me last year. Cross is an in and under so he'll always do well. Murphy is solid.

 

[GotTheGoodes]

kennedy for mine,
ward has competition from lots of other elite mids in his side..

Yeah Kennedy's just got Jack, Hanners, Goodes, McGlynn, RoK, Bolton & McVeigh..... No I see your point, and agree, Ward has Cooney, Boyd, Cross, Gilbee, Griffen & Higgins.

 

[fr_303]

Veszpremi or Gamble for F7 spot who do u guys think

 

[Badga]

Veszpremi or Gamble for F7 spot who do u guys think

Out of the 2 I would go Vesz but at F7 you could prob just play a rookie and spend the cash elsewhere

Now this is doing my head in at the moment

Boak and Goodes vs Montagna and Higgins vs Swan and Yarran

*note I already have 2 saints and Pendles in the mids

 

[rhaz]

Veszpremi or Gamble for F7 spot who do u guys think

How much cash you got? Take a look at Maric.


edit: If you can afford Vesz you can afford Maz.

 

[Colson]

Foley v cotchin? Can't decide between the 2. Both have potential for a breakout

 

[fr_303]

How much cash you got? Take a look at Maric.


edit: If you can afford Vesz you can afford Maz.

MARIC is $3500 more then Vesz just cant fit him.

I have Petrie and Matera on the bench this week so actually this is for F5 for the rest of the season

 

[Lets Roar like '44]

If anyone can be bothered I have this dilemma...

Fyfe v Martin v Vince v Foley v L. Anthony

 

[lids2richo]

Broughton+Foley+Prestia ($11,000) V R.Tarrant+A.Swallow+C.Knights ($64,000)

Have changed these three so many times it's not funny...

Please help!

 

[jimmy5]

^^^^^^

Id go first option.

Know the feeling, mine is Gamble & Duffield or Yarran & Adcock.

 

[jimmy5]

If anyone can be bothered I have this dilemma...

Fyfe v Martin v Vince v Foley v L. Anthony

I think Anthony just, however I think Fyfe could be a great unique pick and with Morabito out think he will spend more time up the ground.His pre season numbers are good also. Really like the way he plays reminds me of Caracella.