Player X vs Player Y Thread

[Zeno The Great]

That is really tough i think they are about even fyfe has the added benefit of MPP though

Mine is i can have Harris and m Duncan or Bewick and Yarran

 

[The Passenger]

probably Fyfe but there is nothing in it.

combo player's

Gibbs, Duffield, Kennedy (Swans), Franklin - 1.865 million

v

Deledio, Scotland, Dale Thomas, Rioli - 1.875million

 

[Zeno The Great]

Gibbs, Duffield, Kennedy (Swans), Franklin for me

Not sure about scotland, and Buddy and Gibbs should burn.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Swan vs Pendlebury

 

[The Passenger]

Gibbs, Duffield, Kennedy (Swans), Franklin for me

Not sure about scotland, and Buddy and Gibbs should burn.

yeah have leant that way at the moment. scotland was a big question mark as was deledio injury and he should be a good upgrade target around round 5 to 6 i'd reckon... really reckon thomas could shoot up, but so should JK....

on yours i'd go harris and duncan because harris should be great value at 120k or whatever he is... but i'd also be looking to try and upgrade duncan into yarran because yarran has torn it up in the pre season from all reports.

 

[Carlton freak!]

Gaff Vs Polec

and

S Atley Vs J Polec vs M Wallis

and

Knights Vs Petrie

 

[The Passenger]

dont know enough about polec....

but i don't think gaff will be a big scorer. think he will be more prolific in DT where his tank should allow him to rack up some cheap touches.... could also be eased in as a sub a fair bit.

i would see him as a 50 to 55ppg player.

stuck on grundy v grimes. grimes is a gun no doubt but missed a fair bit through injury last year and melbourne are going through an injury crisis at the moment.... doesn't necessarilly mean grimes will get injured again but these things tend to follow a club around

 

[BangersAndMash]

I think Gibbs is good for 10PPG more than Bruce and Gibbs is one of the most durable players in the league. Plus his byes are singular and by round 23 you should have a solid 8th back to cover Gibbs for a round.

Mine is Tapscott vs McKernan

Just after some outside opinion so I don't let my own bias cloud my vision

This ^^

I'm unsure too. Have gone with Tapscott for now... Anyone, anyone...?

 

[Norfolk & Clew]

Atley V Libba??

 

[jayfaux]

stuck on grundy v grimes. grimes is a gun no doubt but missed a fair bit through injury last year and melbourne are going through an injury crisis at the moment.... doesn't necessarilly mean grimes will get injured again but these things tend to follow a club around

This, big time. Grundy seems like the safe choice though..

This ^^


I'm unsure too. Have gone with Tapscott for now... Anyone, anyone...?

And this. Although with the above, maybe it makes sense to go Grundy/McKernan (who can DEF/FWD with each other)?

 

[trix17]

midfield of swan/judd/pendles/watson/bartel and dids in the forward line
or
Swan/Judd/Selwood/Montagna/ward and buddy in the forward line

which option?

 

[peteshep]

Atley V Libba??

This.

It's got me scratching my noggin that's for sure

 

[MattBrads14]

This.

It's got me scratching my noggin that's for sure

Me too, but ill make it harder and add curnow and bewick to atley and libba

also as with a few im tossing up between tapscott, mckernan and darling

We Need Someone With answers, weve all got questions!

 

[Bulldog Breed]

Boyd/Petrie + 72k left (cop a donut from Petrie in rd 1)
or
Ward/Cox + 102k left

Can also put in Foley instead of Ward, but I'll only have about 12k left.

 

[chriso1088]

polec not named so conca in??

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Don't forget the GC players. Everyone i know just filling their side up with players playing this week

 

[Jack4814]

Boyd/Petrie + 72k left (cop a donut from Petrie in rd 1)
or
Ward/Cox + 102k left

Can also put in Foley instead of Ward, but I'll only have about 12k left.

Foley/Cox, no point in copping a donut and foley will definitely outscore ward. Seems a lot of questions recently without much advice....

Tarrant vs Otten?????

 

[RevDog]

Keep Hibberd or go with Bewick from Brisbane?

 

[Flameboy]

This.

It's got me scratching my noggin that's for sure

Atley defs i reckon. Dogs have a lot more depth/qualtiy = harder to get a game.

also as with a few im tossing up between tapscott, mckernan and darling

We Need Someone With answers, weve all got questions!

I have both Tapscott and McKernan. McKernan should play week in week out.

One from me: Chris Newman, Gilbert, Sam Fisher, Duffield or Grimes? Leaning towards Gilbert.

 

[Flameboy]

Keep Hibberd or go with Bewick from Brisbane?

Keep Hibberd. He'll play.

Bewick, if he fails to impress early, won't. Polec should come in for him.

 

[DwayneBrightside]

Travis Boak or Tom Rockliff?

 

[lids2richo]

A lot of ppl are trying to decide between Foley/Cotchin, but has anyone given L.Anthony much thought?

 

[JHF1870]

Travis Boak or Tom Rockliff?

Boak.

130 odd tackles last year, gets a lot of the ball, 17 brownlow votes. should definitely rise above 100 average this year.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Dawes and Yarran v Hurley and Garlett????

 

[Flameboy]

Travis Boak or Tom Rockliff?

If it was DT id say Rockliff. SC Boak probably JUST has the edge.

Dawes and Yarran v Hurley and Garlett????