Player X vs Player Y Thread

[JHF1870]

This ^^

I'm unsure too. Have gone with Tapscott for now... Anyone, anyone...?

I went Tappa, Mckernan will take big marks, and kick goals, but can't see him doing more than what Tippett did. I'd like more run from Tappa, his sort should be 50-60. minimum.

 

[maxrm]

Need 1 rookie forward, already have Mckernan and Matera.

Should I go Richardson, Tapscott or Darling. All have been named to play!

 

[smidla]

looking at taking ziebell over higgins...thoughts PLEASE!

 

[DwayneBrightside]

Boak.

130 odd tackles last year, gets a lot of the ball, 17 brownlow votes. should definitely rise above 100 average this year.

Thank you!

One more:

Andrejs Everitt or Jed Adcock or James Gwilt

 

[JHF1870]

Thank you!

One more:

Andrejs Everitt or Jed Adcock or James Gwilt

Personally I wouldn't go any for tha price. Adcock though for those 3.

I reckon you will get as much out of a rookie/First year player like Duigan personally.

Other options in this range are

Danny Menzel -(FWD)
Hurley (FWD)
Jackson Trengove could be a risk. Pretty versatile player.
Nathan Krakouer.

I think the value for the players you are in ? over are not worth the investement. IMO

 

[dlanod]

Keep Hibberd. He'll play.

Bewick, if he fails to impress early, won't. Polec should come in for him.

Really? Bewick's looks pretty solid in our preseason games and we prelisted him (via GC) as a mature ager which seems a bit strange if we weren't planning on playing him. I'd back Bewick in to play the rest of the year, but think Polec will only play half the season at best.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

If it was DT id say Rockliff. SC Boak probably JUST has the edge.

Yeah I picked the Hurley/Gartlett combo just after i posted but thanks aswell.

Higher risk but higher reward maybe.

 

[shqip]

Whats with almost every team selecting Deledio? Is there something I have forgotten?

 

[shqip]

P.S. Deledio+Hurley or Everitt+Rioli?

 

[MIGHTY DONS]

Heppel v Otten for backline

Driving me insane

 

[lids2richo]

Ok one last decision ~ Boak or A.Swallow?

 

[thenighthawk]

I need a defender, two midfielder and a forward.
My options are:
Ryan Lester, Callan Ward, Tom Liberatore and Charlie Dixon
Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Daniel Harris and Dion Prestia (who greatly helps my mpp structure)
or
Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Shaun Atley and Ryan Gamble

Not sure if the extra I'll get out of ward is worth weakening the other positions. Ward is in at the moment, and without him either swallow, heppel or polec will start.

 

[Mick_15]

I need a defender, two midfielder and a forward.
My options are:
Ryan Lester, Callan Ward, Tom Liberatore and Charlie Dixon
Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Daniel Harris and Dion Prestia (who greatly helps my mpp structure)
or
Michael Coad, Jared Polec, Shaun Atley and Ryan Gamble

Not sure if the extra I'll get out of ward is worth weakening the other positions. Ward is in at the moment, and without him either swallow, heppel or polec will start.

I like the option with Harris, and maybe change polec to bewick.


Boyd v Jack
Going for league win.

 

[weagles]

I like the option with Harris, and maybe change polec to bewick.


Boyd v Jack
Going for league win.

Boyd definitely

Duffield v Broughton?

 

[jbomb3000]

Boyd definitely

Duffield v Broughton?

Broughton for mine

Broughton v Grimes thoughts?

 

[Joe King]

Puopolo or Toy for last defender emergency spot? Worried I'll have too many GC players though (5 so far overall).

 

[jbomb3000]

Puopolo or Toy for last defender emergency spot? Worried I'll have too many GC players though (5 so far overall).

toy will have better job security

 

[Big_D231]

Broughton for mine

Broughton v Grimes thoughts?

Grimes i reckon, saves some cash and should score just as well as broughton at worst.

Mine is 2 of goodes, pav and boomer?, currently have goodes and pav

 

[thenighthawk]

Grimes i reckon, saves some cash and should score just as well as broughton at worst.

Mine is 2 of goodes, pav and boomer?, currently have goodes and pav

boomer has had a very good preseason and i saw him play against geelong and he looked as fit as ever.

still a hard choice for me. personally i'd be locking in pav, and then it's a matter of whether you want consistent good scores throughout the season or some potentially incredible scores and maybe also some very quiet patches.

 

[Axe]

Threads with more than 1000 posts make baby Jesus cry.

Continued here.