Player X vs Y

[The_Steadier]

who to keep?

Suckling vs Jaench

 

[Kadog]

Still stuck on Hibberd v Kade

Blues are crap and could rest 90% of their team FFS

Bombers striving for finals cannot rest players, but cannot risk players either

I just dont know!

Blues have no depth so I doubt players will get rested. Only those that have carried injuries will be put on ice. ie: Walker, maybe Judas.

Simpson rarely misses games and will still get alot of ball thru halfback. He's a junk time specialist too.

Hibberd is great but he's already missed twice thru injuries. He's more likely to miss from the two and with no trades to spare, could put you in the shithole.

Hibberd 90-105 (injury query)
Vs
Simpson 70-140 (durable)

 

[Kadog]

Ward vs. Goddard?

This is my last trade, I've put Ward in for the meantime as he's marginally more likely to pump out those big 130+ scores. Bombers running into finals though, and Ward faces three potential tags in finals with Collingwood, Melbourne and WB, while Goddard should get away scott free. Any thoughts? I don't even know how often Ward is tagged, I know Treloar cops it at times.

Goddard. Bank his 120s plus in games that matter.

 

[Kadog]

Best player to have for SC Finals??

Sloane v. Boomer

Boomer. He's in career form statiscally.

 

[Kadog]

Jamar and shenton M9 to.

Big boy and the Chad.

V's

Minson and ryan bastinac.

Big boy & Chad.

 

[Kadog]

JPK or Boomer?

JPK for mine. Set n forget Stud.

 

[Kadog]

who to keep?

Suckling vs Jaench

Jeansch.

 

[Kadog]

who to keep?

Suckling vs Jaench

Jeansch.

Keep one: Z. O'Brien vs B. Acres

And, with no trades left after this:

M8: S. Mitchell (DPP could come in handy) vs K. Jack/Murphy/NDS etc

id keep Acres. Saints will play kids. Should be back very soon

 

[SnappyHappy]

Boomer. He's in career form statiscally.

Yeah I've decided on Boomer ahead of Sloane.

But now considering Boak. He has averaged 115.5 since the bye.

So,
Boomer v. Boak

 

[Kadog]

Yeah I've decided on Boomer ahead of Sloane.

But now considering Boak. He has averaged 115.5 since the bye.

So,
Boomer v. Boak

I'd take Sloane ahead of Boak.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Me too.
Get Boomer.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Done. Breust > Boomer locked in

 

[toxic]

keep acres- we are running a creche down at morabbin this year and he's one of our favourite rug rats.
will get games.

and get smitch in, no brainer

Did Acres play VFL last week?

 

[karaoke]

Did Acres play VFL last week?

No & not named this week apparently.

 

[toxic]

No & not named this week apparently.

thx

 

[Test Tickle]

He

thx

He's injured again

 

[karaoke]

Did Acres play VFL last week?

No & not named this week apparently.

He
He's injured again

Update - FYI

http://www.saints.com.au/video/2014-07-15/weekly-injury-report-round-18

 

[Goats]

Mitchell, Boomer with Sandi & 1 trade for the year

Vs.

Gray, Goldy & Mitchell next round with no more trades for the year.

Going for overall, opinions appreciated.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Mitchell, Boomer with Sandi & 1 trade for the year

Vs.

Gray, Goldy & Mitchell next round with no more trades for the year.

Going for overall, opinions appreciated.

Do you have cover for Sandi this week?

 

[Goats]

Do you have cover for Sandi this week?

Nah, Stefan in the fwd line but no one to swing with.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Nah, Stefan in the fwd line but no one to swing with.

Tough call then. If you are going for overall I would say trade Sandi but I doubt you will get through the last 5 weeks with 0 trades. What is your cover like in other positions?

 

[Goats]

Tough call then. If you are going for overall I would say trade Sandi but I doubt you will get through the last 5 weeks with 0 trades. What is your cover like in other positions?

Have pretty good cover every where but in the rucks, Bruest/Zorko at F7 & Burgoyne at D7 with the ability to swing them into the mids. Might just cop the 0, kicking myself for not starting with a Brown/Thurlow for the sake of 12k.

Thanks for your help Snappy.

 

[Goats]

Minson & Boomer

Vs.

Goldy & Gray

 

[juddola]

Minson & Boomer

Vs.

Goldy & Gray

I like option 2.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Need to bench one of the following:

Hurn (v Richmond)
Birchall (v Sydney)
Jaensch (v Collingwood)