players to get rid of

[Sloth]

Lonie will never play in the black and white again after 2days performance

You didn't like his snap from outside 50?

 

[T-Clo]

leon- Delist/ trade
Lonie- Trade/ keep
B. morrison- Delist
Tex- delist/ trade
Cole- keep/ trade
williams- delist
lokan- delist
j.cloke- Delist/ trade
Hall- keep

 

[Laras_Finest]

Chad Morrison has been solid at collingwood, his in my dream team and the first few rounds he got me fairly good scores for a defender.

I dont even know why he left WEST COAST??????? He played some good footy there especially the last 10 rounds last season.

why did Chad Morrison leave WEST COAST????

 

[Fev0lution]

obree he is turnover city

 

[Jabso]

O'Bree has shown some suprising form this year but he tries too many smartass lollypop kicks and was definately turnover city on Monday. However if he could just smarten up with his disposal he'd be ok.
C.Cloke = Keep. I cannot believe the madness of criticising him as a hack. He is a young player, 2 years younger than "The next big tihng' Bryan, and a big boy, they always take long to develop. With a good preseason he could be a very handy ruckman come forward.

I don't know why Chad left West Coast but it can't be any worse than Chambers leaving WEST COAST??????

 

[Murray]

obree he is turnover city

No you mean Ryan Houlihan

 

[eddiesmith]

Chad left WCE to come back to Melbourne (I guess he is a Victorian)

 

[Coin_Toss]

Won't wear the black & white again after this year:
Andrew Williams (Fumbles too much, gone)
Matthew Lokan (He knows how to get the ball, but he doesn't know what to do with it)
David King (too slow, gone)

Might not wear the black & white again after this year:
Shane Woewodin (MM would probably give him more chances this year)
Ryan Lonie (Lonie should be kept tho)
Chad Morrison (I just want to see him out, but stupid MM would keep him)
Leon Davis (I can't see him playing on next year, but could put him in the "Will get the chance to wear the black & white this year (again)")
Jason Cloke (If Clokey doesn't get another chance this year, he could well be delisted at the end of the year)

Won't get the chance to were the black & white this year (again):
Billy Morrison (If he doesn't improve, he is gone at seasons end)
Brent Hall (I'd keep him on the list next year)
Zane Leonard (If he can't break through the side soon, he is definitely gone at seasons end)
Brayden Shaw (I can't see him playing a game this year, but I'd keep him)


Will get the chance to wear the black & white this year (again):
David Fanning (Deserves another crack)
Richard Cole (You think he will break through the side eventually, good trade bait)
Adam Iacobucci (Hard working kid with a solid future)
Tristen Walker (Good depth player, that could come handy once Wakes had retired)
Guy Richards (Once he has recovered from his latest injury setback, he should be right back in the mix)

Will get the chance to wear the black & white this year for the first time:
Heath Shaw (Skillful player with pace, should make his debut soon)
Tom Davidson (Back from 2 knee reco's)

Others:
Cameron Cloke: (A definite keep. Cameron is still very young, and he has the chance to become our Number 1 ruckman over the next 2 years)
Nick Maxwell: (A definite keep. Nick will develop into a good player for us in the backline)
Dane Swan: (Should be kept. Dane has imrpoved a lot since he has made his return into the side.)
Julian Rowe: (A definite keep. Rowey is a great link player to have in the side, and he would develop into a great winger.)

If I have missed anyone, please tell me.

 

[eddiesmith]

Jason cannot be delisted, re-signed last year for 2 years

Walker a good depth player? Haha, he is only good for a team who wants to get some Priority Picks

 

[MarkT]

Contract or not Jason can be delisted. He just has to be paid out. I agree he will stay but contracts are mere reccomdations these days.

 

[Nardz]

id keep lonie, i just think he will come good!
but get rid of morrison, woewodin, rowe, j cloke, williams.
and obree if we can find a suitable substitue!
i think teh problem is in teh fact we cant find suitabel substitutes for these guys, so we are better of keeping em. Unless we can steal a quality player in return fact is we wont get much better wth draft picks we get or the delisted duds goign around!

And im not syaing there havent been many quality midfielders or players swapping clubs, but we just dont seem to able to get them! for example, stevens, k.johnson, moloney, ottens, gehrig are all good players that we havent managed to secure! hopefully next trade period we will secure a few goodies! i ahve a feeling tenace will be coming our way as will power, but yeah we are long way off tlaking about trades

i really can't understand why you people want to get rid of rowe?
are you crazy?

he's one of the few 2nd year players who has actually shown something, without going back to willi for anextended period of time. Get a clue.

I'd also keep morrison and cloke. Morrisson simply cause he adds experience to the side, and he ain't the worst performer for us this season.

Cloke because he is a young tall defender, and although it will take abit of work, all is not over for him yet.

Young tall defenders are often scrutinised. He killed Hamill, and was mismatched on gehrig who killed him. The fremantle game granted he had a shocker, but i dont think we exactly had any shining stars that day.

Whenever i think of cloke i think of presti. He didnt exactly look like a bright prospect at that age, i dont think anyone imagined he'd still be on the list, and still be holding key fowards down.