chef
Moderator
Im just messing around.
ADE
1 v WSW
0 42'
NL
0 v NH
0 PM
MEM
0 v IND
0 PM
POR
0 v MIA
0 PM
LAC
0 v DET
0 PM
DAL
0 v SA
0 PM
MIN
0 v CHI
0 PM
MEL
0 v BNE
0 PM
ORL
0 v MIL
0 PM
NY
0 v TOR
0 PM
CLE
0 v NO
0 PM
COL
9.6
60 v GWS
14.6
90 FT
GCS
8.11
59 v CAR
9.16
70 FT
WB
10.13
73 v BL
8.6
54 FT
NM
10.8
68 v ADE
16.13
109 FT
STK
15.12
102 v WCE
13.4
82 FT
MEL
12.13
85 v GEE
9.6
60 FT
FRE
13.18
96 v HAW
12.9
81 FT
SYD
26 v CRO
18 FT
PAR
12 v STG
26 FT
GC
42 v NEW
16 FT
CLA
17.6
108 v SFR
13.14
92 FT
GLE
13.13
91 v WWT
9.8
62 FT
EFR
8.5
53 v SUB
12.14
86 FT
CBD
18 v MEL
52 FT
WES
30 v NQ
34 FT
KT
10.7
67 v LDL
15.6
96 FT
STU
6.9
45 v NWD
10.6
66 FT
NA
9.12
66 v STH
11.11
77 FT
GLE
8.7
55 v CLA
13.9
87 FT
WES
11.10
76 v ADE
12.10
82 FT
WP
19.6
120 v WCE
6.6
42 FT
PER
6.13
49 v SWA
14.15
99 FT
PA
8.16
64 v CEN
7.5
47 FT
EP
7.7
49 v PT
24.10
154 FT
ORL
106 v IND
111 FT
DEN
121 v SA
119 FT
CHA
101 v ATL
105 FT
ADE
83 v PER
68 FT
NEW
1 v MVC
2 FT
POR
118 v DET
103 FT
WEL
3 v WUN
2 FT
OKC
93 v PHI
117 FT
BOS
145 v MIN
136 FT
NO
101 v PHI
94 FT
MEL
84 v NZB
78 FT
GS
107 v WSH
110 FT
UTH
128 v SAC
112 FT
DEN
87 v BOS
105 FT
LAC
126 v HOU
109 FT
SYD
1 v MCY
1 FT
ILL
82 v CNS
80 FT
BRO
101 v LAL
126 FT
SYD
84 v SEM
98 FT
PHX
134 v WSH
106 FT
NY
133 v MEM
129 FT
CLE
115 v TOR
135 FT
GS
125 v HOU
109 FT
MIL
119 v CHA
127 FT
ATL
120 v CHI
108 FT
Players who haven't reached their potential
- Thread starter Cruyff14
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Art Vandelay_
TheBrownDog
- Oct 28, 2012
- 86,235
- 114,144
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers, AC Milan
I smile seeing his name now.
TubbsFarquhar
Hall of Famer
mike123
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 13, 2013
- 29,805
- 26,355
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Juventus
Those stats don’t really paint the full picture and are hardly fair comparison when you consider Pogba started out at Juve when he was 19 whilst has been in his prime the whole time at ManU. His last two years with us where hardly overrated.
The flop narrative comes from Pogba being an easy scapegoat and the ridiculous expectation put on him at ManU.
If Pogba has a quiet game at Juve, Vidal, Marchisio or Pirlo would pick up the slack and no one would bat an eyelid. Pogba has a quiet game eith ManU and they lose all hell breaks loose against him.
jod23
TheBrownDog
- Apr 2, 2000
- 65,987
- 20,967
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Not really because Coutinho was never bandied about as the best AM in the world or potential to be etc. Where as Pogba was apparently the next big thing, future best CM in world football but he never really reached those heights, at Juve or United.
Cruyff14
Premium Platinum
United fans, will or does Antony Martial belong in here? Buckleys Jocks RPCB
Clause in his contract to win the golden ball isn't there, but that looks like it has 0 chance of happening.
Clause in his contract to win the golden ball isn't there, but that looks like it has 0 chance of happening.
Buckleys Jocks
Club Legend
- Jul 7, 2014
- 2,349
- 2,943
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Yeah, not a bad shout at all.
I genuinely think that he's one of the most naturally talented footballers that I've ever seen at the club but he has never really looked like having the desire or application needed to make the most of it.
RPCB
Brownlow Medallist
Totally agree.
Martial definitely belongs on here. This season has been a great disappointment after last season.
Buckleys Jocks
Club Legend
- Jul 7, 2014
- 2,349
- 2,943
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
He's always been that way. It was the knock on him when he first signed with United as I remember reading comments from some of his youth team coaches about him struggling to apply himself.
Punchy Bassett
Brownlow Medallist
That broken leg really set him back wasn't a standard break think I read somewhere there was a chance he could have lost the leg.
Buckleys Jocks
Club Legend
- Jul 7, 2014
- 2,349
- 2,943
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Disagree with this one. He's been one of United's best players since the COVID restart and has expanded his game considerably this season.
The mental scars obviously stuck around for years as well. At his best he fearlessly bulldozes down that left flank but he just looked devoid of any confidence and was too timid when it came to using his pace for a very long time there.
jd2010
#freeWelly #freeDele
- Feb 1, 2010
- 32,030
- 15,619
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur
He's in the top 3-5 left backs in the league imo
Elmer_Judd
#Teague2020
- Jul 25, 2019
- 14,317
- 25,168
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Leeds United
Neymar.
Should have been on Ronaldo/Messi (or under) level by now with All his talent, but he has not put it all together for various reasons
Should have been on Ronaldo/Messi (or under) level by now with All his talent, but he has not put it all together for various reasons
Punchy Bassett
Brownlow Medallist
Lazy simple as that doesn't have the killer desire of those other two
ossie_21
Premium Platinum
Absolutely shocked to see that he just turned 29 yesterday.
Mans been 25 since forever
RPCB
Brownlow Medallist
Ronaldo and Messi’s level?. We are talking about two footballers who are genuinely two of the greatest to ever play the sport.We are not talking about just anyone here, these are icons who have scored 700+ career goals for club and country each. We will never see the likes of Ronaldo and Messi ever again when they retire.
Neymar was never reaching that level.
Cruyff14
Premium Platinum
Think Quaresma is a good shout here. Huge things were spoken about him early on but he clearly didn't reach the heights that people thought he would get to.
Hulk, Pato and Robinho are three others as well I'd add while I am at it.
I always thought Hulk would have joined a big team after he left Porto rather than going to Zenit and then China.
Hulk, Pato and Robinho are three others as well I'd add while I am at it.
I always thought Hulk would have joined a big team after he left Porto rather than going to Zenit and then China.
Yoda_
Hall of Famer
- May 6, 2007
- 30,331
- 15,306
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
Alan Dzagoev
Bonanza Krcic
Alexander Pato
Tony Vilhenna
Jeffrey Bruma
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Bonanza Krcic
Alexander Pato
Tony Vilhenna
Jeffrey Bruma
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Cruyff14
Premium Platinum
Jack Wilshere. Kid destroyed Barca at 19 (10 years to the day yesterday in fact), but injuries obviously ruined him.
Could have been one of the top CMs in the world if he wasn't perennially injured.
Could have been one of the top CMs in the world if he wasn't perennially injured.
Magma
Hall of Famer
neymar was never going to be ronaldo/messi level. the likelihood is that no one else will be, but neymar still have a better than 1/2 goal to appearance ratio, will likely pass pele as brazil's top scorer and is a global superstar. i dont think he hasnt met his potential at all. all while playing out wide most of his career. only injuries have slowed him down.
