Draft Expert PMBangers 2023 Draft Thread

[PMBangers]

Do you see Duursma as a mid at AFL a level, or more as a forward who can run through the midfield?

I see him as a mid after 5-6 seasons in the system unless he turns into am A grade forward before that

 

[bc27]

Hey bangers, Who do you have as the better talent out of Jed Walter and Aaron Cadman?

 

[eaglespremiers]

Sydney has matched a bid on Creedence Clearwater Revival

Glory be. Did you hear that through the grapevine?
I bet that they were just lookin' for a reason. No doubt they had a sinister purpose.

 

[PMBangers]

Hey bangers, Who do you have as the better talent out of Jed Walter and Aaron Cadman?

Walter by a margin, Cadman is good and I'm pleased to have him at GWS, but he's never going to be the focal point of a forward line like Jed should eventually do

 

[GWS Goose]

GC got it for more wins over the same period.

They also got Pick #1, a Future End of R1 and a mid Rnd 1 and the Darwin Zone.

I could see this getting up tbh, as it doesn't move anyone's picks, just takes a player out of the pool.

Some of you should be happy, as McKercher has also been in our NGA squads since u/12's.

Really!
Assume you take him at 2 anyway.
Unless he goes 1, unlikely, but becoming possible.

 

[Harry O]

C'mon, it wouldn't even be in the top 5

But you have no possible claim to him. It would simply be the AFL rewarding North for years of mismanagement

 

[Harris 10]

But you have no possible claim to him. It would simply be the AFL rewarding North for years of mismanagement

I'd prefer pick 3 for all those years of mismanagement, but I'd settle for Sanders.

 

[Mofra]

Sydney has matched a bid on Creedence Clearwater Revival

Congratulations to that Fortunate Son

 

[TDS7]

Congratulations to that Fortunate Son

I'm not sure about his hand in the wet, it could really limit his impact as a contested midfielder. I mean Has he Ever Seen the Rain?

 

[botts]

I'm not sure about his hand in the wet, it could really limit his impact as a contested midfielder. I mean Has he Ever Seen the Rain?

Well I’m gonna get spelling right next time if this is the result.

 

[PMBangers]

Me, knowing I brought this all these bad jokes on to myself when I became the meme guy on the board

 

[DoggiesC1954]

Can you please do a top 10 mock draft. I have seen your rankings but just interested to see where players would go if the season finished today.

 

[Wild Bill]

But you have no possible claim to him. It would simply be the AFL rewarding North for years of mismanagement

Like Fraser and Thomas when they ended up at Collingwood?

 

[PMBangers]

Priority Pick and NGA/ Academy discussion are quite possibly the most boring and pointless topics in the DTFA space, the AFL will do what it wants at any given time without much reason or consistency

 

[Supersuns]

Me, knowing I brought this all these bad jokes on to myself when I became the meme guy on the board

 

[PMBangers]

Can you please do a top 10 mock draft. I have seen your rankings but just interested to see where players would go if the season finished today.

Assuming Richmond win;
1 West Coast - Harley Reid
2 Gold Coast [bid] - Jed Walter
3 North Melbourne - Colby McKercher
4 Hawthorn - Dan Curtin
5 Melbourne - Nick Watson
6 Gold Coast [bid] - Ethan Read
7 Sydney - Connor O'Sullivan
8 Adelaide - Ryley Sanders
9 GWS - Zane Duursma
10 Carlton - Nate Caddy

 

[Demon 16]

Assuming Richmond win;
1 West Coast - Harley Reid
2 Gold Coast [bid] - Jed Walter
3 North Melbourne - Colby McKercher
4 Hawthorn - Dan Curtin
5 Melbourne - Nick Watson
6 Gold Coast [bid] - Ethan Read
7 Sydney - Connor O'Sullivan
8 Adelaide - Ryley Sanders
9 GWS - Zane Duursma
10 Carlton - Nate Caddy

I know Watson is pretty incredible but I’d spew if we spent pick 5 (or 4) on a 170cm small forward who doesn’t defend.

 

[PMBangers]

I know Watson is pretty incredible but I’d spew if we spent pick 5 (or 4) on a 170cm small forward who doesn’t defend.

Doesn't defend

 

[Mostyn]

I know Watson is pretty incredible but I’d spew if we spent pick 5 (or 4) on a 170cm small forward who doesn’t defend.

If he goes at 4, that's almost a bargain.

 

[Footy Heads]

would you be able to list the next 20 - 30 players after this would be very interested to see who is in the next crop

 

[Demon 16]

Doesn't defend

I assure you I’ve seen enough. Even in the high profile games nobody seems to call it out. Just my opinion of course.

Maybe it’s something he can learn at the next level as I wouldn’t accuse him of being soft.

 

[PMBangers]

would you be able to list the next 20 - 30 players after this would be very interested to see who is in the next crop

I refuse to think about it at this point for my own sanity

 

[RedmanWasHere]

I refuse to think about it at this point for my own sanity

Next 90?

Actually, you'll end up in solitary confinement.

 

[briztoon]

would you be able to list the next 20 - 30 players after this would be very interested to see who is in the next crop

Many of the draft watchers update lists every month, on the first page of their threads.

 

[PMBangers]

Next 90?

Actually, you'll end up in solitary confinement.

That's the dream