POLL: Hayes vs Judd?

[Kerrby]

2 x B&F's
2 x All Aust
1 x All Aust captain
2 x top 5 finishes in MVP (voted by players)
R/U Brownlow
09 - led comp in contested poss and clearances.

Shite?

How hard would it be to win a B&F at Carlton? Almost as easy as winning one at Richmond.

Also would explain why they gave Judd captaincy before he even played a game for Carlton.

 

[TheGoatBaron]

How hard would it be to win a B&F at Carlton? Almost as easy as winning one at Richmond.

Also would explain why they gave Judd captaincy before he even played a game for Carlton.

Fevola should have won it in 08 and Marc Murphy in 09. Judd got lucky twice, just like in 2005, when he won the Norm Smith Medal. He is grossly overrated by the media.