If you don't include Roger James you are a campaigner
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Carnt argue with that... but overall I didnt rate dew very highly. Just my opinion.I'm a sucker for a player that can kick heaps of goals from outside 50.
One of the most natural match winners to play the game.Carnt argue with that... but overall I didnt rate dew very highly. Just my opinion.
Steve Brosnan?Jason Davenport
Allan Murray
Derek Murray
John Rombotis
Adam Cockshell
Jaxon Crabb
Chris Hall
Marlon Motlop
Fabian Deluca
Matthew Westhoff
Luke Peel
Wade Thompson
Ryan Williams
Simon Phillips
Wade Champion
Look at their best 22 in the 2002-2004 era.
Select 12-13 players from it then add Robbie Gray and Travis Boak.
Maybe a Westhoff or Wingard to squeeze in.
7. Shaun Burgoyne
8. Robbie Gary
Nah.Would've been spot on if you'd remembered to add Jay Schulz.
Wanganeen out then?Anyone that leaves our club and plays for another AFL club is automatically disqualified under my definition of "top"
Of course that's very subjective.
Nah.
Tredrea was our best AFL era player.
It shouldnt even be up for debate.
View attachment 662002
From the players that were in the 2004 flag winning side. Wilson, Kane Cornes, Tredrea, Thurstans, Lade, Kingsley, Roger James and Cassisi were one club AFL players.
And of those 8 players Wilson and Tredrea were the only players from our SANFL system that stayed at the club their whole career.
I think our best AFL player ever was Wanganeen. He could play defence, midfield, and forward, and play them well. He was courageous and smart, and could play above everyone else, and was a clutch player.
Did someone debate it?
Jason Davenport
Allan Murray
Derek Murray
John Rombotis
Adam Cockshell
Jaxon Crabb
Chris Hall
Marlon Motlop
Fabian Deluca
Matthew Westhoff
Luke Peel
Wade Thompson
Ryan Williams
Simon Phillips
Wade Champion
This is possibly the most offensive thing I’ve seen on these boards. And I lived through ‘The Official Meatspin Thread’.