+ Hodgee having to eat humble poo watching the replay of his high tackle on Shuey
Review Positives and Negatives vs Umpires
- Thread starter HoneyBadger35
- Start date
- Tagged users None
+ Hodgee having to eat humble poo watching the replay of his high tackle on Shuey
Keys
Looking for a cloud to yell at
- Moderator
- #52
Positives only, we all know the negative
+our midfield unit finally shared the load and functioned as a group - Priddis, shuey, Hutchings, gaff, sheed, masten and Jetta all complemented each other without leaving the heavy lifting to just a couple
+yeo, a couple of brain farts aside, played the role that suits him as a high HF and was dangerous all night
+lecca wound back the clock and was a really good contributor. Cripps also was really dangerous
+gov was a beast turning back attack after attack. Such a good marker of the ball coming into defence
+Hutchings on Mitchell was exceptional. Good coaching, great execution by the player
+nelson had his hands full with Rioli but curtailed his influence substantially
+sheppingham is back, they were terrific.
+butler and hurn both very reliable
+Lycett tucked well and was a presence around the ground. We gunna need him now
+JK you ******* beast
+jack, good to have you back
+pridda's work around the stoppages in the first half was elite
+jettas tackle on Burgoyne to get a goal and the players getting around him
+sheed was solid and in form is a central plank of our midfield
+masten laid a tackle and kinda put his body on the line. Liked his game immensely
-despite all that I still wanna cry
+our midfield unit finally shared the load and functioned as a group - Priddis, shuey, Hutchings, gaff, sheed, masten and Jetta all complemented each other without leaving the heavy lifting to just a couple
+yeo, a couple of brain farts aside, played the role that suits him as a high HF and was dangerous all night
+lecca wound back the clock and was a really good contributor. Cripps also was really dangerous
+gov was a beast turning back attack after attack. Such a good marker of the ball coming into defence
+Hutchings on Mitchell was exceptional. Good coaching, great execution by the player
+nelson had his hands full with Rioli but curtailed his influence substantially
+sheppingham is back, they were terrific.
+butler and hurn both very reliable
+Lycett tucked well and was a presence around the ground. We gunna need him now
+JK you ******* beast
+jack, good to have you back
+pridda's work around the stoppages in the first half was elite
+jettas tackle on Burgoyne to get a goal and the players getting around him
+sheed was solid and in form is a central plank of our midfield
+masten laid a tackle and kinda put his body on the line. Liked his game immensely
-despite all that I still wanna cry
Umpire Positives:
+Kind of kept up with the play, I think.
Umpire Negatives:
-Dean Margetts (the bald one)
-50m penalties for nothing.
-Heavy bias against the home team.
-Annoyed the crowd the most I've ever seen
+Kind of kept up with the play, I think.
Umpire Negatives:
-Dean Margetts (the bald one)
-50m penalties for nothing.
-Heavy bias against the home team.
-Annoyed the crowd the most I've ever seen
Can't believe Darling hasn't been mentioned.
Went into the ruck and was really effective against McEvoy around the ground for periods of the third and fourth quarter.
Went into the ruck and was really effective against McEvoy around the ground for periods of the third and fourth quarter.
Positives
Everyone had a dip ....contested ball...finally for a night we were clean with the ball for a change
Jetta had some positive pieces of play even
Loved the hutch ...did a number on mitchell ....he's destroyed us so many times
Negatives
NN injury
He's one player .....teams have won flags with average rucks
Everyone had a dip ....contested ball...finally for a night we were clean with the ball for a change
Jetta had some positive pieces of play even
Loved the hutch ...did a number on mitchell ....he's destroyed us so many times
Negatives
NN injury
He's one player .....teams have won flags with average rucks
FatPizza
Premiership Player
- May 25, 2015
- 3,370
- 7,363
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Vs Geelong in 2012 takes the cake for that one.
FatPizza
Premiership Player
- May 25, 2015
- 3,370
- 7,363
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
And better midfields...
I reckon we recruit a mature aged ruckman in the draft for a year of its a year injury
- Jan 13, 2013
- 23,104
- 45,290
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Our midfield isn't the most skilled ever
But if and it's a big if .....if they can work collectively hard like we have the last two games anything is possible
Masten had thirty .....priddis , shuey gaff ....if they work thier tails off we can still create some havoc in the finals I think
- Jan 13, 2013
- 23,104
- 45,290
- AFL Club
- West Coast
If only our list management team had someone with your knowledge and tactical nous on it
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,945
- 94,268
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
I'd say common sense (and well overdue) coaching.
- Apr 3, 2010
- 3,065
- 5,154
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Philly Eagles, Boston Red Sox
Last year after Emacs and browns injuries it was RIP season... played in the granny. Now after NN's its RIP season... Lycett isnt a crab we have had 1 loss since the bye and played a fair chunk of them without NN. Pressure makes Diamonds.
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,945
- 94,268
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
We looked gold all year sans the defenders. How have we looked this year without Naita?
I wish I shared your optimism.
Keys
Looking for a cloud to yell at
- Moderator
- #69
Tagging Mitchell is what we all hoped would happen
Using hutch was less obvious and if we did a poll pre game I reckon most would have said he wouldn't be up to it
Simmo won the coaching battle tonight and all Clarko had in his presser was we play the oval better and he can't wait to get back to the MCG
Give simmo his credit he never blamed the ground for a loss
A few more positives whilst I try to drink away the part of my brain that saw Nicant hrt kneewsagag iaohgaogi agggggaag
Whilst Hill certainly had a quiet game, he was putting in a lot of work. Got to the right spots a lot of the time, and was a bit unlucky when Darling and JK were clunking contest marks all night. The improvements in his workrate have been huge the last couple of years, and even when he's not pulling in the numbers I think he's a lock in the 22.
On the forward half work, I was really impressed with how well our big blokes helped each other out with blocks and moving through space. A lot of the marks taken in the forward 50 were a result of fantastic teamwork.
I might be overrating Lycett here, but man can he do everything. He was taking grabs and intercept marks, getting clearances from his own taps, making spoils. His own tapwork still needs some work. But anyone thinking Rory Lobb is a better prospect than this bloke needs to rewatch the footage this week. He's becoming a really rounded prospect and I know why the club has locked him in long term.
Rioli was shut down pretty well, but I'm not sure how? Thought Nelson spent quite a bit of time near him but it was probably a team effort there to not allow him a good deal of space.
Shuey is a beast. Hurn can be a ******* tank. JJK is JJK. Our leaders have delivered pretty consistently in the second half of the season.
Cripps was really awesome again. Horrendously underrated on BF. His pressure is fantastic as usual and his kicking in particular (was surprised to read earlier in the week that he's one of the best in the comp this year for i50s). Love seeing him further up the ground and really using his speed / lateral movement.
Heads were over the ball motherluckers. HEADS WERE OVER THE BALL
Whilst Hill certainly had a quiet game, he was putting in a lot of work. Got to the right spots a lot of the time, and was a bit unlucky when Darling and JK were clunking contest marks all night. The improvements in his workrate have been huge the last couple of years, and even when he's not pulling in the numbers I think he's a lock in the 22.
On the forward half work, I was really impressed with how well our big blokes helped each other out with blocks and moving through space. A lot of the marks taken in the forward 50 were a result of fantastic teamwork.
I might be overrating Lycett here, but man can he do everything. He was taking grabs and intercept marks, getting clearances from his own taps, making spoils. His own tapwork still needs some work. But anyone thinking Rory Lobb is a better prospect than this bloke needs to rewatch the footage this week. He's becoming a really rounded prospect and I know why the club has locked him in long term.
Rioli was shut down pretty well, but I'm not sure how? Thought Nelson spent quite a bit of time near him but it was probably a team effort there to not allow him a good deal of space.
Shuey is a beast. Hurn can be a ******* tank. JJK is JJK. Our leaders have delivered pretty consistently in the second half of the season.
Cripps was really awesome again. Horrendously underrated on BF. His pressure is fantastic as usual and his kicking in particular (was surprised to read earlier in the week that he's one of the best in the comp this year for i50s). Love seeing him further up the ground and really using his speed / lateral movement.
Heads were over the ball motherluckers. HEADS WERE OVER THE BALL
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,945
- 94,268
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
I'd have to disagree, Hutch has been used as a tagger on several occasions this year, but on the other hand I am as grumpy as **** right now and looking for a confrontation.
- Sep 6, 2015
- 28,197
- 23,338
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Pelicans, Perf Wildcats
I'd have to disagree, Hutch has been used as a tagger on several occasions this year, but on the other hand I am as grumpy as **** right now and looking for a confrontation.
Liked it
Similar threads
