I'd rather grab a 3rd 1st round player, who I can at least hope will become a genuine gun (noting that all of our recent 1st round draftees have turned out well), than a fringe player from another club (who would probably be a fringe player at our club as well).
Losing Dangerfield is a major setback. We need to inject some decent talent into our list, and fringe players like Grigg, CEY, Lyons, Anderson, Hampton and Gore probably aren't going to achieve that. Having 3x selections in the top-14 would give us a decent chance of landing a potential gun player, albeit one who will take a couple of years to reach their full potential.