Autopsy Post match discussion Pies vs Saints

[Laurie Holden]

Anyone else sick of the carry on about Elliott's grab?

Also if it wasn't a mark should it have been a free kick for a punch to the melon?

Only just started watching the game for the second time and like to watch a bit after the emotion is gone so I don't carry on. Cloke free kick in the first quarter was an absolute joke. Lingy saying it was an obvious free kick Player (forgot who) was facing Cloke pushing against holding his jumper whilst not looking at the football....hello!

 

[Matt_352]

Anyone else sick of the carry on about Elliott's grab?

Also if it wasn't a mark should it have been a free kick for a punch to the melon?

Only just started watching the game for the second time and like to watch a bit after the emotion is gone so I don't carry on. Cloke free kick in the first quarter was an absolute joke. Lingy saying it was an obvious free kick Player (forgot who) was facing Cloke pushing against holding his jumper whilst not looking at the football....hello!

its cloke, what u expect from the scumps

 

[Laurie Holden]

its cloke, what u expect from the scumps

I know! Any wonder he gets so frustrated. He just gets scragged any time he goes near it. Varcoe kicked a good goal of Clokes hands in the first, but what about the block first. Any wonder Buckley almost had lost his s*** when he actually got a free kick!

 

[Matt_352]

Yeah I lost my shit too

 

[Somebody]

I'm aware of the circumstances. Marty Clarke was also a part of the deal, as he was pre-listed by GWS when he returned to Australia.

At the time, everybody thought that Clarke, was the main target of the deal, but there has been talk that Hine actually wanted Elliott more. It was a good trade of a second round pick (or first round? Compromised draft etc...)

Ok I wasn'taware of the circ's. I guess that makes Elliot borderline steakknives then. Or maybe steaknives plus a special tomato slicer.