It wouldn't be a problem if the captaincy was handed off to someone else and Sloane was subject to the same selection criteria as any other player.This news should please one of his biggest fans no end.....LOL
-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Injury Post Season Medical Update
- Thread starter simmo97
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Given we must have already committed to 95% of the cap, we probably canāt fit his full payout into this year. Same issue with Gibbsā $600k when we wanted him out of the club.
There was an article recently where his improvement is continuing and that they may have gotten it a bit wrong or pushed a bit hard in the past.
You would be just about the only that wouldn't be sure who it referred to...just like it was a no brainer that you'd reply...
Tongue in cheek. Did my post not make it clear who I thought youād be referring to.
I hope Sloane comes back fit and strong.
Gives him the best chance of being a useful cog in the machine.
Donāt pretend the guy canāt play. He could be useful in 2023. Just need to put that ego away and take a small role.
If, on the other hand, we think he should be a midfielder when things get tight ā¦ or we think he will be central to anything we improve on ā¦ that sounds like trouble.
If Rory craves the limelight, harks back to good ol days, captain courageous ā¦ that sounds like disaster.
He lost his pace. He can still run all day, just not very quickly. Heaven knows how much worse that gets after a knee?
I will be interested to see if we actually have a role for him that the team needs, a role that plays to what remains of his strengths. He looked good in his last couple of games before injury at HF, but that ship might have sailed.
More importantly, will he be first picked? Hope not, but on history itās probable. Donāt pick him because of who he his, then push him into a role he canāt play ā¦ or push out a young player so Sloaney gets to run out to the cheers of the adoring crowd.
Donāt gift games. No matter what.
Gives him the best chance of being a useful cog in the machine.
Donāt pretend the guy canāt play. He could be useful in 2023. Just need to put that ego away and take a small role.
If, on the other hand, we think he should be a midfielder when things get tight ā¦ or we think he will be central to anything we improve on ā¦ that sounds like trouble.
If Rory craves the limelight, harks back to good ol days, captain courageous ā¦ that sounds like disaster.
He lost his pace. He can still run all day, just not very quickly. Heaven knows how much worse that gets after a knee?
I will be interested to see if we actually have a role for him that the team needs, a role that plays to what remains of his strengths. He looked good in his last couple of games before injury at HF, but that ship might have sailed.
More importantly, will he be first picked? Hope not, but on history itās probable. Donāt pick him because of who he his, then push him into a role he canāt play ā¦ or push out a young player so Sloaney gets to run out to the cheers of the adoring crowd.
Donāt gift games. No matter what.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 15,104
- 27,514
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
What position would you play him and whose spot is he taking?
Iād have to see how he comes back from injury.
He could probably tag. Maybe as a professional medical sub? If we have some injuries, possibly hff?
I would not want to see him and Keays on the ground together in 2023.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 15,104
- 27,514
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
The issue is we donāt tag and there is no way Sloane will be the sub.
We will also have Keays and Sloane together.
Iām ok with Sloane taking McHenrys spot for example but that wonāt happen either.
We have Taylor and Pedlar we need to get in the side. Cook needs to be developed. Rachelle will play more. We are bringing in Rankine. I just canāt see how playing Sloane helps us at all. He is going to be a hindrance.
I donāt wish injury on anyone and but it would have been better had he did his knee late in the year and not early. The additional games would have given more of a reality check of where heās at and missing a fair chunk of 2023 should have made the decision to retire easier.
I find it hard to believe that people are hoping Sloane comes back into the side.
As George said we have to fit in Rochelle, Pedlar, Taylor, hopefully Rankine and Cook.
Surely we have moved on from Sloane (& Crouch), would be absurd to have him as our captain - sit him down, thank him for his contributions and offer him the job of leading our reserves until his contract runs out.
As George said we have to fit in Rochelle, Pedlar, Taylor, hopefully Rankine and Cook.
Surely we have moved on from Sloane (& Crouch), would be absurd to have him as our captain - sit him down, thank him for his contributions and offer him the job of leading our reserves until his contract runs out.
If he's fit, this is where I'd like to see Sloane play most of his game time, a lead up small forward/flank to extend his career (and replace McHenry/Murphy).
He's a good contested overhead mark, and reliable kick at goal (unlike the other two), which would seem to fit into Nicks game plan where we seem to be bombing a lot of rebounds to a small forward. To me it's a possible win-win: the great Leigh Matthews finished his career this way, it ain't a bad thing.
I could handle Sloane having small bursts in the middle as relief, with the emphasis on the word small. The focus of the midfield has to be speed, creativity and accurate delivery, and the majority of the time should be dedicated to the kids.
We've been saying a fit Sloane is going to have a better year next year for the last 5 years.
The reality is, he isn't.
Giving in to this and trying to put him i the team because he's the Captain, or to justify the ludicrous contract is what will hold this club back.
This is the next generations time.
Sloane should aim to be the SANFL captain and move in to player development and maybe coaching.
The reality is, he isn't.
Giving in to this and trying to put him i the team because he's the Captain, or to justify the ludicrous contract is what will hold this club back.
This is the next generations time.
Sloane should aim to be the SANFL captain and move in to player development and maybe coaching.
Hence my trepidation.
I can see a chance for Rory to be helpful to the rebuild, I just don't see us going that way. History says he will be pushed (and push himself) forward ahead of others that deserve the exposure and the opportunity.
- Aug 30, 2021
- 15,104
- 27,514
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Smart move, plays injured from round 6, form suffers, meanwhile weāve got Worrell playing well in the SANFL, wait until the end of the year for surgery and puts him behind in preseason training.
Idiots
I really struggle to see the logic behind this
Smart move, plays injured from round 6, form suffers, meanwhile weāve got Worrell playing well in the SANFL, wait until the end of the year for surgery and puts him behind in preseason training.
Idiots
- Aug 30, 2021
- 15,104
- 27,514
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Now all Iāve done is shared club information and commented how stupid we were, is that classified as being negative or would the positive people prefer if we ignored it? WeedsMullet84 what do you reckon? Do I have personal issues for posting club info?
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Do you remember when Burgess talked about getting players to toughen up and play with nigglesā¦? That.
Smart move, plays injured from round 6, form suffers, meanwhile weāve got Worrell playing well in the SANFL, wait until the end of the year for surgery and puts him behind in preseason training.
Idiots
Most niggles donāt require surgery
- Aug 30, 2021
- 15,104
- 27,514
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
This is more than a niggle! Heās required surgery and itās delayed his preseason
jenny61_99
Premium Platinum
Well, yeah, they can do. Even if itās just an arthroscope.
Minor ones they would do during the year and have them back playing
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 81,390
- 81,830
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Well many of us were commenting during the year why were we playing a clearly injured Doedee, particularly when we had an in form Worrell playing in the sanfl.
Outcome was Doedee played many poor games, such that many posters were questioning whether he is still a good player.
Also, Doedee was making his injury worse, meaning he would end up having surgery threatening his start to the 2023 season... where we were a better chance of playing finals than in 2022 where we were little chance!
Missed opportunity to get games into q talented young player who played better than Doedee on average (because he was injured).
Same old same old s**t Crows selection of playing injured players... which is insane when you are not playing finals.
Smart move, plays injured from round 6, form suffers, meanwhile weāve got Worrell playing well in the SANFL, wait until the end of the year for surgery and puts him behind in preseason training.
Idiots
Thatās how we rebuild, concentrate on the right now.
- Oct 7, 2018
- 1,345
- 2,735
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
The comment was "most". Niggles might need surgery very occasionally, but definitely most do not.
Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- May 24, 2006
- 77,315
- 151,907
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Moderator
- #49
Little did Burgess know soldiering on needlessly through injury was the one thing we already had down pat
- Nov 5, 2009
- 10,060
- 9,269
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
The issue with this is that Pedlar/Taylor/Cook have a combined 16 games between them. Pedlar struggled to put together a string of SANFL games, yet you think he is gonna be playing a bunch of AFL games in 2023. Taylor hasn't even debuted and Cook has played 11 games over 2 years.
Lets not act like these 3 are destined to play significant time in 2023.
Similar threads
