Post Your Team Here

[joelselwood]

Hoping I can get a few comments on this side!! Thanks guys!
(salary cap almost dried out btw)

B: Hodge - Newman - C.Cornes - Adcock - Malceski - Raines - Hill (Dawson, McKernan)

M: Bartel - Judd - Kerr - Cousins - Reilly - Rich (Davenport, Adams)

R: Cox - McIntosh (Lobbe, Roughead)

F: Pavlich - Franklin - J.Brown - Lucas - Alwyn Davey - Headland- Yarran (M.Brown, Gumbleton)

All comments appreciated

 

[MrTripleC]

Back
Hodge
Goddard
Cornes
Malceski
J. Smith
Maguire
Grimes
(Suban/Sloane)

Mid
Ablett
Judd
Pendlebury
Selwood
Cousins
Rich
(Robinson/Strauss)

Ruck
Cox
Ottens
(Sullivan/Currie)

Forward
Riewoldt
Harvey
Brown
Headland
Higgins
Yarran
Ziebell
(Thorp/Gumbleton)

 

[FRROST]

He's only got fricken 3, hardly a risk mate!

Your not wrong, different strategy! i have 1 first yr starting in every position and have for the past 3 yyrs i find it is the way to go. you just need to have some luck early but also need to research plenty! it allows you to pick up more expensive and permanent players from the start and then that means your team has 3 rookies in each possi which will go up in price so mid yr you should have 12 rookies ready to be used for trade for cash and then upgrade or you may get lucky and be able to squeeze them into your starting lineup. but ay thats the strategy i go with coz i have found it works.

 

[FRROST]

Hoping I can get a few comments on this side!! Thanks guys!
(salary cap almost dried out btw)

B: Hodge - Newman - C.Cornes - Adcock - Malceski - Raines - Hill (Dawson, McKernan)

M: Bartel - Judd - Kerr - Cousins - Reilly - Rich (Davenport, Adams)

R: Cox - McIntosh (Lobbe, Roughead)

F: Pavlich - Franklin - J.Brown - Lucas - Alwyn Davey - Headland- Yarran (M.Brown, Gumbleton)

All comments appreciated

Nice team mate, some really good quality keepers in there and some good risks, i thought bartel and hodge where a touch expensive but if you can get em in then you can be sure to have them all yr as captain choices.

As a carlton supporter, just sit back on yarren for now until the pre-season comp is over coz he played prac game other day and really struggled, whereas robinson starred and he is much more cheaper, so keep an eye out.

plz comment on my team

 

[FRROST]

Back
Hodge
Goddard
Cornes
Malceski
J. Smith
Maguire
Grimes
(Suban/Sloane)

Mid
Ablett
Judd
Pendlebury
Selwood
Cousins
Rich
(Robinson/Strauss)

Ruck
Cox
Ottens
(Sullivan/Currie)

Forward
Riewoldt
Harvey
Brown
Headland
Higgins
Yarran
Ziebell
(Thorp/Gumbleton)

ok, massive riskd in ottens, cousins, headland. and ablett, your one of the first, there has been debate on whether to get him or not and i would suggestnot, he will score 100's week in week out but will come down in price coz he wont avg 130!!!

 

[Mancey]

Yeah no way i'll get ablett first up. He's almost guaranteed to be cheaper by round 4 and i'll grab him then i think

 

[jonnycoping]

So happy that SC has returned.

Check out:

http://www.aflsupercoach.com

Its a site me and some media colleagues are running.

And yes, we're obsessed.

 

[1st time sc]

this is my 1st time with the game so a bit of help may be needed thanksd

Smashers : your selected Herald Sun TAC SuperCoach so far:
d
e
f
Bowden, J ,. Fisher, S, Scotland, H , Shaw, H, , Drummond, J, Hurley, M , Davis, P

emg O'Keefe, D, Reed, S

m
i
d
Hodge, L, , Pendlebury, S, Stevens, N , Cousins, B, Hill, S, Hartlett, H, Rich,
emg rich D, Cockie, A
r
u
c
k
s
Ottens, B, Campbell, R

emg Sellar, J, Keeffe, L

f
o
r
Pavlich, M, Franklin, L, Brown, J, Bradshaw, D, Fevola, B, Watts, J, Yarran, C
emg Bennell, J, Breust, L
i still have 89,000 to spend but was trying to save it for later in the year.

 

[Hands Open]

Subject to change -

BAC: Hodge Newman Shaw Houli Malceski Petterd EMG: P Davis L Greenwood

MID: Bartel M Murphy J Selwood Kerr Skipworth Rich EMG: S Blease D Beams

RUC: Cox Hille EMG: Cordy Trengove

FWD: Deledio J Brown Chapman Al Davey Lucas Higgins Sidebottom EMG: Sidebottom S Wright

The ones I'm not sure about are Hodge + Bartel - are they worth the investment? Bartel screwed me around last year, but Hodge seems to be more of a goer.. Alwyn Davey is another I'm not sure about with injuries etc. I feel like my midfield is a little light on have Skipworth and Rich in, what are other peoples thoughts?

With the side like it currently is i have $61k left

Cheers

 

[Ingall]

DEF - Goddard, B - Newman, C - Cornes, C - Malceski, N - Selwood, S - Petterd, R - Hill, S (Schoenmakers, R - Suban, N)

MID - Bartel, J - Judd, C - Cornes, K - Swallow, A - Higgins, S - Rich, D (Shuey, L - Blease, S)

RUC - Cox, D - Jolly, D (Naitanui, N - Currie, D)

FWD - Riewoldt, N - Harvey, B - Pavlich, M - Deledio, B - Porplyzia, J - Henderson, L - Watts, J - (Walker, T - Ballantyne, H)


Bit of a wait and see on Naitanui, and debating Higgins v Skipworth.

Also hoping to see some of the rookies in pre-season comp before confirming their selection.

 

[Snap the old Sausage]

Any advice would be welcome. I notice a lot of people dont (in fact I havent notice 1) have McClean in their sides. Is there a good reason for this?

BACKS Bowden, Goddard, Lockyer, Adcock, Malceski, Houlihan, Hill (Suban, Rance)

MIDS Judd, Gibbs, McClean, Haselby, Reilly, Coughlan (Dangerfield, Beams)

RUCKS Cox, Hille (Messen, Keeffe)

FORWARDS Harvey, Pavlich, Franklin, Reiwolt J, Veszpremi, Higgins, Skipworth (Gubleton, Grant)

 

[Snap the old Sausage]

DEF - Goddard, B - Newman, C - Cornes, C - Malceski, N - Selwood, S - Petterd, R - Hill, S (Schoenmakers, R - Suban, N)

MID - Bartel, J - Judd, C - Cornes, K - Swallow, A - Higgins, S - Rich, D (Shuey, L - Blease, S)

RUC - Cox, D - Jolly, D (Naitanui, N - Currie, D)

FWD - Riewoldt, N - Harvey, B - Pavlich, M - Deledio, B - Porplyzia, J - Henderson, L - Watts, J - (Walker, T - Ballantyne, H)


Bit of a wait and see on Naitanui, and debating Higgins v Skipworth.

Also hoping to see some of the rookies in pre-season comp before confirming their selection.

Strong forward line, but do you think Reiwoldt will increase in value from where he is? I think he would be better off getting about Round 6-8.

 

[Snap the old Sausage]

Subject to change -

BAC: Hodge Newman Shaw Houli Malceski Petterd EMG: P Davis L Greenwood

MID: Bartel M Murphy J Selwood Kerr Skipworth Rich EMG: S Blease D Beams

RUC: Cox Hille EMG: Cordy Trengove

FWD: Deledio J Brown Chapman Al Davey Lucas Higgins Sidebottom EMG: Sidebottom S Wright

The ones I'm not sure about are Hodge + Bartel - are they worth the investment? Bartel screwed me around last year, but Hodge seems to be more of a goer.. Alwyn Davey is another I'm not sure about with injuries etc. I feel like my midfield is a little light on have Skipworth and Rich in, what are other peoples thoughts?

With the side like it currently is i have $61k left

Cheers

If you can afford it change Murphy for Gibbs as I think Gibbs having bulked up a bit with have a belter.

 

[Manginable Claw]

Feedback please:

DEF: Goddard, Gilbee, Ladson, Malceski, Smith-J, Houlihan, Grimes
EMERG: Post, Suban

MID: Judd, Corey, R-Griffen, K,Cornes, Shirley, Rich
EMERG: Dangerfield, Swift

RUCKS: Hille, Kozi
EMERG:J-White, Meesen

FOR: Harvey, Pavlich, Deledio, Davey-Alwyn, Porplyzia, Higgins, Yarran
EMERG: Gumbleton, Grant

 

[Ingall]

Strong forward line, but do you think Reiwoldt will increase in value from where he is? I think he would be better off getting about Round 6-8.

I don't think he will increase, and will probably go down if anything, but he's not there for the money. He's there for the 110+ points a week he scores. Like you said, I could probably get him cheaper later but that uses up a trade which, as you can see from my side, will be needed later in the season. I'd rather pay a bit extra for some guns now (still might try and get Ablett in too) instead of taking the wait and see approach for players that are probably going to end up in my team anyway. Hold of on 3 or 4 gun players now and that's 3 or 4 trades you have to make later. Just my 2c.

 

[R1KSTA]

Backs: Goddard Newman Mackie S.Stevens McPhee Ryder S.Hill
(Hurley, Suban)

Mids: Judd J.Selwood Kerr Cotchin Rich Robinson
(Blease, Beams)

Rucks: Cox Simmonds
(Vickery, Trengove)

Fowards: Pavlich Franklin Didak Porplyzia Fevola Yarran J.Riewoldt
(Sidebottom, T.Walker)


Feedback please!!

 

[NRFL boy]

Hi all, would love some feedback:

Backs: Waite, Gilbee, C Cornes, Ellis, Hanley, Maguire, Egan (Grima, Hill)

Mids: Judd, Ablett, Hodge, Bartell, Haselby, Coughlan (Jetta, Myer)

Rucks: Cox, Ottens ( Messen, J Tippett)

Forwards: Fevola, Franklin, O'Keefe, J Brown, Rusling, Higgins, Yarran (Gumbleton, Hughes)

This is exactly the $10 million. That wasn't my aim just how it turned out

 

[Griff19]

Feedback would be great!!!

Backs

Hodge, C.Cornes, McLeod, Adcock, S.Buckley, Houlihan, Grimes (Okeefe & Grima

Midfield

Bartel, Judd, J.Selwood, Cousins, Masten, Rich (Davenport & Beams)

Ruck

Cox, Minson (Trengrove & Sellar)

Forward

B.Harvey, Franklin, Deledio, Lucas, Headland, Higgins, Watts (Yarran & M.Brown)


not 100% on baclkline, S.Buckley & Grimes??? (Think Buckly is in for a big year though)

Aslo suspect on a couple up forward!!

Thoughts???

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Feedback would be great!!!

Backs

Hodge, C.Cornes, McLeod, Adcock, S.Buckley, Houlihan, Grimes (Okeefe & Grima

Midfield

Bartel, Judd, J.Selwood, Cousins, Masten, Rich (Davenport & Beams)

Ruck

Cox, Minson (Trengrove & Sellar)

Forward

B.Harvey, Franklin, Deledio, Lucas, Headland, Higgins, Watts (Yarran & M.Brown)


not 100% on baclkline, S.Buckley & Grimes??? (Think Buckly is in for a big year though)

Aslo suspect on a couple up forward!!

Thoughts???

I'm not very good at this but here goes:
McLeod worries me with injury, and age. Not sure how many games he played last year but in my mind there's a question over his durability.

Bartel, Hodge and Harvey for mine are over-priced. They have to have extremely strong starts to warrant their price. Hodge has had a slightly hindered preseason and Bartell's role seems to be changing with Selwood stepping up. Franklin might even be overpriced at this point.

Minson is a very good pick as a second ruck imo.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Hi all, would love some feedback:

Backs: Waite, Gilbee, C Cornes, Ellis, Hanley, Maguire, Egan (Grima, Hill)

Mids: Judd, Ablett, Hodge, Bartell, Haselby, Coughlan (Jetta, Myer)

Rucks: Cox, Ottens ( Messen, J Tippett)

Forwards: Fevola, Franklin, O'Keefe, J Brown, Rusling, Higgins, Yarran (Gumbleton, Hughes)

This is exactly the $10 million. That wasn't my aim just how it turned out

Maguire and Egan are suspect choices. Egan will miss a lot of the season and Maguire - anything could happen. Bottom priced so maybe that makes it a good idea.

Goughlan I worry about in your midfield.

Yarran - I've heard of lot of Carlton supporters pumping up Robinson ahead of him. I've put Robinson in my team because of this as I think he'll play a lot of games this year. Feel free to shed some light on this if you have a hunch, opinion or knowledge.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Feedback please:

DEF: Goddard, Gilbee, Ladson, Malceski, Smith-J, Houlihan, Grimes
EMERG: Post, Suban

MID: Judd, Corey, R-Griffen, K,Cornes, Shirley, Rich
EMERG: Dangerfield, Swift

RUCKS: Hille, Kozi
EMERG:J-White, Meesen

FOR: Harvey, Pavlich, Deledio, Davey-Alwyn, Porplyzia, Higgins, Yarran
EMERG: Gumbleton, Grant

Good backline
Midfield looks good - I don't know much about Shirley?
Kozi is a perennial let down, even in supercoach. I'd keep my distance.
Forward line looks solid - I like it

 

[Flawed Genius]

Hi all, would love some feedback:

Backs: Waite, Gilbee, C Cornes, Ellis, Hanley, Maguire, Egan (Grima, Hill)

Mids: Judd, Ablett, Hodge, Bartell, Haselby, Coughlan (Jetta, Myer)

Rucks: Cox, Ottens ( Messen, J Tippett)

Forwards: Fevola, Franklin, O'Keefe, J Brown, Rusling, Higgins, Yarran (Gumbleton, Hughes)

This is exactly the $10 million. That wasn't my aim just how it turned out

Hanley, Maguire, Egan.. pretty risky picks. If there's anything better for their prices, I'd take it. Egan the most risky, as he doesn't look like playing (?) this year.

The rest is pretty good, Rusling a bit suspect in the forward line, and your reserves are fairly solid.

Upgrade or change your backline around and you'll have a very solid team.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Now - I need some serious help with my team!?!

Backline: H Shaw, C Cornes, J Adcock, X Ellis, R Houlihan, A Raines, M Tyler, Emergencies: L Henderson, J Laidler

Midfield: C Judd, S Pendlbury, J Selwood, D Kerr, J Lewis, C Morton, D Emergencies: Rich, M Robinson

Rucks: Jolly, McIntosh Emergencies: J Meeson, D Currie.

Forwards: Pavlich, Deledio, Johnson, J Roughead, S Lucas, P Veszpremi, J Ziebell, Emergencies: S Gumbleton, S Higgins.

So what I was thinking is get a solid core: Shaw, Cornes, Judd, Pendlebury, Selwood, Pavlich, Deledio, Johson and then look for under-priced players from there.

Lewis and Roughead are hawks that I reckon will be given bigger roles and will do well out of it this year.

Clearly I ran out of cash and have put Tyler, Henders and Laidler (who?) in the backline as they were cheap. Where have I overspent and what can I do???

 

[BigE]

Goddard, H Shaw, Mackie, Adcock, Malceski, Raines, S Hill (shoenmakers, mckernan)

Judd, Corey, Cross, Mitchell, Cousins, H Hartlett (R Bail, D Beams)

Ottens, Simmonds ( Trengrove, Z Clarke)

B Harvey, Franklin, J Brown, Didak, Higgins, Hentschel, Ziebell (Sidebottom, Gumbelton)

 

[Mancey]

Anyone got a better 94k defender prospect than Rance for my bench?