Post your team thread V.2

[P-MONEY]

Here is my 1000000 attempted at a team.. Any suggestions?

Backs

Gilbee, L, McMahon, J, Adcock, J
Mundy, D, Malceski, N, Rooke, M
Hill, S, Suban, N, Petrenko, J

Mids

Corey, J, Cross, D ,Cornes, K
Kerr, D, Cousins, B , Griffen, R
Rich, D, Dangerfield, P

Rucks

Ottens, B , Simmonds, T
Currie, D, Roughead, J

Forwards

Franklin, L, Johnson, S, Fevola, B
Mooney, C, Motlop, D, Higgins, S
Ziebell, J, Brown, M, Grant, J

 

[TheNextBigThing]

Quick question, Cox and Melceski or Frasier and Milburn?

 

[RhysFN]

\

1,078,800 left
any advice needed thanks

 

[razor1]

Every team here just about has Yarran starting. From what Ratten said he will not play early in the season. Make sure you have emergencies that cover him.

 

[Sambo90]

Every team here just about has Yarran starting. From what Ratten said he will not play early in the season. Make sure you have emergencies that cover him.

Hey mate, if he's not in the squad released wednesday he's out!

 

[UpTheGuts]

\

1,078,800 left
any advice needed thanks

Ummm. get over yourself?

It is a comp you know mate... advice is one thing, but this is basically asking someoone else to sit your test

 

[jonoman89]

Backs: Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, H. Shaw, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)

Midfield: Ablett, Judd, Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Gibbs, Beams (Robinson, Swift)

Rucks: Ottens, McIntosh (Jacobs, Pyke)

Fowards: Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, S. Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, M. Brown (T. Walker, Gumbleton)

Anyone? Haha.

 

[Checkers]

My team, im looking at making some changes so comments welcom.

Back:
L.Hodge, B.Goddard, S.Fisher, J.Adcock, N.Malceski, A.Raines, S.Hill (M.Hurley, A.Rance)
Midfield:
G.Ablett, J.Selwood, S.Pendlebury, N.Foley, B.Gibbs, B.McLean (D.Beams, L.Anthony)
Ruck:
D.Cox, J.White (A.Graham, S.Jacobs)
Forward:
B.Deledio, A.Didak, D.Thomas, A Woneamirri, H.Skipworth, W.Thompson (T.Walker, M.Brown)



Want to trade Woneamirri, just not sure who for.

 

[munk3ymark]

My team, im looking at making some changes so comments welcom.

Back:
L.Hodge, B.Goddard, S.Fisher, J.Adcock, N.Malceski, A.Raines, S.Hill (M.Hurley, A.Rance)
Midfield:
G.Ablett, J.Selwood, S.Pendlebury, N.Foley, B.Gibbs, B.McLean (D.Beams, L.Anthony)
Ruck:
D.Cox, J.White (A.Graham, S.Jacobs)
Forward:
B.Deledio, A.Didak, D.Thomas, A Woneamirri, H.Skipworth, W.Thompson (T.Walker, M.Brown)

Want to trade Woneamirri, just not sure who for.

It's certainly an interesting forward line- I had to go and look up W. Thompson o). Is he going to get a game?
Wonaeamirri is in a tricky price bracket- there's not a lot in the $350-ishK forwards. I've been considering Morton from the Hawks, but am not yet sold. Or perhaps Cox from the Pies? Also not sure Daisy Thomas is going to give you much, but I may be wrong- if he plays back more he may end up with a lot of touches.

Mclean in the mids is also risky- he only played 14 games each of the last two seasons, and 16 the one before that. If he stays on the park he could be good though, although expect a few ups and downs.

Might be back later with my team- kids bedtime...

 

[Brahma Bull]

mister 2 - I can't find any faults with your line up really. Ziebell may not get a constant game, and you could replace White with Jacobs and save some cash. Apart from that, top team. $200k up your sleeve is never a bad thing.



Backs: Goddard, Gilbee, Cornes, H. Shaw, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Petrenko, Suban)

Midfield: Ablett, Judd, Pendlebury, Dal Santo, Gibbs, Beams (Robinson, Swift)

Rucks: Ottens, McIntosh (Jacobs, Pyke)

Fowards: Pavlich, Deledio, Franklin, S. Johnson, Higgins, Skipworth, M. Brown (T. Walker, Gumbleton)

Yeh mate I'll try and give some constructive criticism (if any)

I really like the team balance. TBH there aren't many faults. Be wary of Shaw in the backline as he is no certainty to startfor round one. And not too sure if SJ will dominate supercoach, but hey there are quite a few people that have him so I might be missing something. Also, look at your emergencies again as some of them are not as likely to start the year compared to other rookies.

But vgood team.

 

[sainta4life]

B: GODDARD,FISHER,C.CORNES,LOCKYER,MALCHESKI,C.DEMPSEY,RAINES(SUBAN,DAWSON)

C: JUDD,COREY,KERR,JOHNSTONE,MCLEAN,BEAMS(SWIFT,ROBINSON)

R: OTTENS,MCINTOSH(SPENCER,JACOBS)

F: PAVLICH,DELIDIO,J.BROWN,ROUGHEAD,LUCAS,HIGGINS,REID(M.BROWN,GRANT)

i want to leave it like this but it will change im sure haha

thoughts?

 

[Tobias Blues]

B: GODDARD,FISHER,C.CORNES,LOCKYER,MALCHESKI,C.DEMPSEY,RAINES(SUBAN,DAWSON)

C: JUDD,COREY,KERR,JOHNSTONE,MCLEAN,BEAMS(SWIFT,ROBINSON)

R: OTTENS,MCINTOSH(SPENCER,JACOBS)

F: PAVLICH,DELIDIO,J.BROWN,ROUGHEAD,LUCAS,HIGGINS,REID(M.BROWN,GRANT)

i want to leave it like this but it will change im sure haha

thoughts?

i think you could definately have a stronger ruck division. i think you could also do better than johnstone and mclean however it does give you something different and i assume you selected them because you think they will perform. The rest of the team looks pretty strong.

Now my team version 20357 lol
All comments taken on board
Tuck/Haselby/Masten ????

 

[angelatos7]

Here is my team guys

Backline: Goddard, Enright, C.Cornes, Mackie, Hoilhan, Rainies, J.Grmes emg Rance, N.Suban

Mid: Judd, Corey, Selwood, Gybs, Tuck, Rich Emg Dangefeild, Beams

Ruck: Cox, Ottens. Emg: Currie, Jacobs

Fwd: Pavlich, Deledio, Davis, Didak, Higgins, Skipwrt, J.Ziebell Emg: Gumbleton, Grant

I'm not 100% about my emg at the momment. But thats my team so far. What do you guys think I should change?

 

[henno]

I'm a 2nd year supercoach.
I have no rookies in my team as it's too much of a risk imo, despite having several last year.

Back: Goddard, Bock, Cornes, Birchall, Adcock, D.Myers, Geary. Emerg: Dawson, Rance

Mids: Judd, Hayes, J.Selwood, Kerr, Foley, Haselby. Emerg: J.Steven, Swift

Ruck: Hille, McIntosh. Emerg: D.Currie, J. Spencer

Fwds: Bradshaw, Roughead, Porplyzia, Alwyn Davey, J.Riewoldt, S. Higgins, H. Skipworth. Emerg: Thorp, Gumbelton.

Got 600 bucks left LOL.

any suggestions? mids a bit strong, forwards a bit weak? any suggestions on who to trade. there is a lot at stake in my league

 

[bloods01]

Im tossing up between Adcock and Jonathan Brown or Mackie and Roughead. I'm leaning towards Adcock and Brown...thoughts?

 

[jonoman89]

Be wary of Shaw in the backline as he is no certainty to startfor round one.

Why wouldn't he play?

Also, look at your emergencies again as some of them are not as likely to start the year compared to other rookies.

Who would you recommend?

 

[juliem]

SC:

Defenders - Newman, Harding, Morris, Scarlett, Glass, Houlihan, Hill {Petrenko, Quinn}
Midfield - Ablett, Judd, Haselby, Jack, Higgins, Skipworth {Rich, Ziebell}
Ruck - Cox, Petrie {Spencer, Pyke}
Forward - Pavlich, Franklin, Hale, Hill, Motlop, Anthony, Riewoldt J. {Walker, Grant}

DT (intentionally padded with North Melbourne players ):
Defenders - Bowden, Pratt, Harding, Wojcinski, Morris, Firrito, Glass {Hill, Petrenko}
Midfield - Richardson, Harvey, Cousins, Goodes, Harris, Rawlings {Skipworth, Rich}
Ruck - Cox, Petrie {Tippet, Pyke}
Forward - Cloke, Hale, Motlop, Campbell, McGrath, Ziebell, Thompson {Grant, Walker}

* IF Thompson isn't elevated and neither Grant or Walker are named, I will need to make a last minute trade.
** comments on this list for DT should note I'm not taking DT as seriously as SC and thus will not prune this list of excess North Melbourne players so any comments on non North players will be taken with all helpful intent they are offered with

 

[Speck]

SC:

Defenders - Newman, Harding, Morris, Scarlett, Glass, Houlihan, Hill {Petrenko, Quinn}
Midfield - Ablett, Judd, Haselby, Jack, Higgins, Skipworth {Rich, Ziebell}
Ruck - Cox, Petrie {Spencer, Pyke}
Forward - Pavlich, Franklin, Hale, Hill, Motlop, Anthony, Riewoldt J. {Walker, Grant}

I'll just do SC. Very good, only thing is Rich and Ziebell are too rich a bench for my liking, consider Rich on the field for someone, Ziebell out for Beams/Robinson and upgrade a player elsewhere.

I want to get a last opinion before I ban myself from SC!

Backs: Goddard, Gilbee, MacDonald, C Cornes, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Rance, Dawson)

Midfielders: Ablett, Bartel, Judd, Gibbs, Skipworth, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Meesen, Currie)

Forwards: Deledio, Pavlich, Chapman, Walker, Hentschel, Higgins, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Brown)

The only player I'm undecided on is Walker. I'm trying to find the best option at his price range. I would have Fev but that only leaves me with 1k spare. I have 24k I believe.

 

[Windas_Magic]

I'll just do SC. Very good, only thing is Rich and Ziebell are too rich a bench for my liking, consider Rich on the field for someone, Ziebell out for Beams/Robinson and upgrade a player elsewhere.

I want to get a last opinion before I ban myself from SC!

Backs: Goddard, Gilbee, MacDonald, C Cornes, Houlihan, Raines, Hill (Rance, Dawson)

Midfielders: Ablett, Bartel, Judd, Gibbs, Skipworth, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

Rucks: Cox, McIntosh (Meesen, Currie)

Forwards: Deledio, Pavlich, Chapman, Walker, Hentschel, Higgins, Ziebell (Gumbleton, Brown)

The only player I'm undecided on is Walker. I'm trying to find the best option at his price range. I would have Fev but that only leaves me with 1k spare. I have 24k I believe.

Wouldn't touch MacDonald, not worth his price. Mids are fine, same with rucks. Except Currie may not play round 1 and spending a bit more cash for White would be more ideal. Forward line is a little risky,having Walker and Zeibell starting.

My Team:

Backs Goddard, Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Malceksi, Raines, Hill (Suban, Dawson)
Mids: Ablett, Bartel, Cross, Selwood, Tuck, Rich (Beams, Anthony)
Rucks: Hille, Leunberger (White, Spencer)
Forwards: Pavlich, O'Keefe, Deledio, Chapman, Skipworth, Higgins, Walker (Brown, Gumbleton)

 

[juliem]

I'll just do SC. Very good, only thing is Rich and Ziebell are too rich a bench for my liking, consider Rich on the field for someone, Ziebell out for Beams/Robinson and upgrade a player elsewhere.

Midfielders: Ablett, Bartel, Judd, Gibbs, Skipworth, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

I would have Fev but that only leaves me with 1k spare.

*****

Thanks much I'm pretty set on my field players as I don't like any of the logical alternatives at the relevant price ranges so I would thus leave my MF bench as is. Appreciate the input though, that's what we're here for . I can see from your team though that you have cashed up in your MF. Trying to bag the Brownlow medallist early? And Fev - considered him but have had him a few times before in previous years and he isn't always reliable enough for me. Yes, he gets big numbers on occasion but his attitude often expressed on the field in a negative way can make his FF results hot and cold from one week to the next and I would rather have a player who will consistently score 80 - 90 every week adding to the same year end total that Fev will get with the occasional 120+

 

[munk3ymark]

Wouldn't touch MacDonald, not worth his price. Mids are fine, same with rucks. Except Currie may not play round 1 and spending a bit more cash for White would be more ideal. Forward line is a little risky,having Walker and Zeibell starting.

My Team:

Backs Goddard, Fisher, Cornes, Drummond, Malceksi, Raines, Hill (Suban, Dawson)
Mids: Ablett, Bartel, Cross, Selwood, Tuck, Rich (Beams, Anthony)
Rucks: Hille, Leunberger (White, Spencer)
Forwards: Pavlich, O'Keefe, Deledio, Chapman, Skipworth, Higgins, Walker (Brown, Gumbleton)

Almost identical backs to mine- risk/reward on Drummond is damned tempting. Mids are cool- Tuck's clearly the best in his price range, but perhaps less likely to gain/keep a spot than some others (see my dilemma below). Rucks perhaps a teensy bit light on- if you're going Leuenberger (or any other junior/2nd/3rd ruck) then Big Cox is the only answer IMHO. Forwards are OK- again the risk/reward in Chappy- and Gumby is no certainty to start in the first few weeks owing to injury.

Here's my lot:
B: Goddard, S Fisher, Chornes, Malceski, Raines, Collier, Hill (Suban, Petrenko)

M: Ablett, Judd, J Selwood, Gibbs, Griffen, C Morton (Rich, Robinson)

R: Cox, Ottens (Jacobs, Spencer)

F: Deledio, J Brown, Fevola, J Morton, Higgins, Krakouer, Ziebell (Walker, M Brown)

There are some questionable choices, I agree, and am more than happy to hear reasons for/against Morton and Morton (as the most obvious ones who have not yet been analysed to death here).

Morton, C could quite easily become Tuck, T or Masten, C, or even Haselby, P (or some other 3-400K mid I haven't been convinced about yet...), and Morton J, well, I dunno-just seemed fair to put another Hawk in when I gave Roughy the flick, and I had him last year. Mebbe spend a bit more and grab Junior Rioli instead?

I'm also not sold on Fev- I put him in for Roughead today, which I may change back again.

Also had Cox/Leuenberger rucks until today- I've currently got about $60K left over, which I could turn into quite a swag if swapped back, but it's big leap of faith in the kid- potentially 30-40-50 points a game less than Ottens/Simmonds if Charman's around (any word from Brisbane-town on that?)

Overall reasonbly happy with it now- just a bit of tinkering needed (I think/hope...)

 

[Saints_87]

B: Goddard, S Fisher, Chornes, Malceski, Raines, Collier, Hill (Suban, Petrenko)

M: Ablett, Judd, J Selwood, Gibbs, Griffen, C Morton (Rich, Robinson)

R: Cox, Ottens (Jacobs, Spencer)

F: Deledio, J Brown, Fevola, J Morton, Higgins, Krakouer, Ziebell (Walker, M Brown)

i think your team is pretty good, all the areas are very consistant only question marks over fevola, krakouer and griffen

HERE IS MY TEAM
i pretty happy with it so far hopefully you will have some improvements for it. The forwards seems to be the weakest link and i still have $139,000

BACKS: GODDARD, GILBEE, C CORNES, J ADCOCK, N MALCESKI, R HOULIHAN, A RAINES (EMG RANCE AND SUBAN)

MIDS: BARTEL, JUDD, CROSS, GIBBS, HASELBY, RICH (EMG ROBINSON AND BEAMS)

RUCKS: COX AND OTTENS (EMG TRENGOVE AND SELLAR)

FORWARDS: N RIEWOLDT, HARVEY, S LUCAS, VESZPREMI, HIGGINS, SKIPWORTH, ZIEBELL (EMG M BROWN AND BALLANTYNE)

 

[munk3ymark]

B: Goddard, S Fisher, Chornes, Malceski, Raines, Collier, Hill (Suban, Petrenko)

M: Ablett, Judd, J Selwood, Gibbs, Griffen, C Morton (Rich, Robinson)

R: Cox, Ottens (Jacobs, Spencer)

F: Deledio, J Brown, Fevola, J Morton, Higgins, Krakouer, Ziebell (Walker, M Brown)

i think your team is pretty good, all the areas are very consistant only question marks over fevola, krakouer and griffen

HERE IS MY TEAM
i pretty happy with it so far hopefully you will have some improvements for it. The forwards seems to be the weakest link and i still have $139,000

BACKS: GODDARD, GILBEE, C CORNES, J ADCOCK, N MALCESKI, R HOULIHAN, A RAINES (EMG RANCE AND SUBAN)

MIDS: BARTEL, JUDD, CROSS, GIBBS, HASELBY, RICH (EMG ROBINSON AND BEAMS)

RUCKS: COX AND OTTENS (EMG TRENGOVE AND SELLAR)

FORWARDS: N RIEWOLDT, HARVEY, S LUCAS, VESZPREMI, HIGGINS, SKIPWORTH, ZIEBELL (EMG M BROWN AND BALLANTYNE)

What's wrong with Griffen? Kraks I've seen arguments for and against, but I'm sold by him over Skipworth (just), and Fev is Fev- I walk past his restaurant on my way to work every day, so I feel like we're almost neighbours. And everybody needs good neighbours. Yanno...

Veszpremi will be out for month or two with a finger injury, and Trengrove is undertaking 'ongoing rehabilitation' for both knee and hammy, so lose them. Aside from that, pretty neat squad- you are exposed up forward- Lucas I'm unconvinced by (although he may still sneak in to my team...), but you've got the holy trinity of cheap forwards, so you won't miss out cos all your opponents will have them as well...

 

[marcmurphy3]

HERE IS MY TEAM
i pretty happy with it so far hopefully you will have some improvements for it. The forwards seems to be the weakest link and i still have $139,000

BACKS: GODDARD, GILBEE, C CORNES, J ADCOCK, N MALCESKI, R HOULIHAN, A RAINES (EMG RANCE AND SUBAN)

MIDS: BARTEL, JUDD, CROSS, GIBBS, HASELBY, RICH (EMG ROBINSON AND BEAMS)

RUCKS: COX AND OTTENS (EMG TRENGOVE AND SELLAR)

FORWARDS: N RIEWOLDT, HARVEY, S LUCAS, VESZPREMI, HIGGINS, SKIPWORTH, ZIEBELL (EMG M BROWN AND BALLANTYNE)

Backline looks good though I'm not sold on Adcock and I'd consider Petrenko over Rance. Midfield looks perfect. Similar to mine in terms of balance of spending. Tbh I don't see Ottens doing that well this year but there arent really much better options around his price. Trengrove and Sellar should go for 2 of Currie, Graham, White and Jacobs.

Also not sold on Lucas and Vezpremi up forward but the rest look good.


My team

B: Goddard, Gilbee, Drummond, Cornes, Malceski, Raines, Hill (Suban, Petrenko)

C: Bartel, Judd, Dal Santo, Gibbs, Masten, Rich (Beams, Robinson)

R: Cox, McIntosh (Graham, Jacobs)

F: Harvey, Pavlich, Deledio, Houlihan, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Brown, Walker)

I also have 136k left in the bank but don't know what I should spend it on? I could upgrade Bartel to Ablett but I think Ablett is overpriced but should I just do it anyways since I can afford it or should I leave the 136k in the bank? Also what are peoples thoughts on Dal Santo? Not many have him. I'm considering Kerr

 

[reddahaydn1]

HERE IS MY TEAM
i pretty happy with it so far hopefully you will have some improvements for it. The forwards seems to be the weakest link and i still have $139,000

BACKS: GODDARD, GILBEE, C CORNES, J ADCOCK, N MALCESKI, R HOULIHAN, A RAINES (EMG RANCE AND SUBAN)

MIDS: BARTEL, JUDD, CROSS, GIBBS, HASELBY, RICH (EMG ROBINSON AND BEAMS)

RUCKS: COX AND OTTENS (EMG TRENGOVE AND SELLAR)

FORWARDS: N RIEWOLDT, HARVEY, S LUCAS, VESZPREMI, HIGGINS, SKIPWORTH, ZIEBELL (EMG M BROWN AND BALLANTYNE)

need more forwards mate....use your money to upgrade lucas... rioli or roughhead, both second years, both going to continue to imrpove... rest looks pretty spot on apart from veszp as said above.


heres my Last Changes (I hope)
Gilbee > Fisher
Malcheski > Scarlett
Currie> jacobs
Pav > Reiwoldt
Yarran > Reid

BACKS - Fisher, Bock, C Cornes, J Adcock, Scarlett, Houlihan, S Hill (Suban, Petrenko)
MID - Ablett (C), Bartell (VC), Cross, Gibbs, Hasleby, D Rich (M Robinson, D Beams)
RUCKS - Hille, McIntosh (Jacobs, J Spencer)
FORWARDS - Harvey, Reiwoldt, Delidio, Roughead, Higgins, Skipworth, Reid (J Grant, M Brown)

$600 left but i'm not planning on till at least week 3. Anyone see anything I've missed or any holes....think i've ironed out most of the creases.