Pound for Pound?

[drew_j]

Who's your vote for best PFP fighter in the MMA world? For me it's Takanori Gomi. Then a tie between Fedor and Georges St Pierre with Mauricio Rua close behind. I can't believe I can't get Wandi in there. Not to mention Crocop who is, like shogun, a very light fighter for the heavyweigth divs.

 

[Magnum]

I'd agree with that.
I think that the lighter fighters will always have an advantage with a PFP comparison though. Fedor though even so big is pretty amazing to be considered in the best Pound for Pound. He is that good. I guess the argument could be, if Fedor was shrunk to the size of 'kid' , who would win? Too hypothetical to answer I reckon.

 

[drew_j]

Fedor is just so good. I mean he has a second rate conditioning for an MMA fighter. Yet his ability has put him at the top of the best heavy weigth div in the world. Love to see him fight crocop again. Shame his move to UFC will deny the fans that fight. Crocops improvement over the last year has been impresive.

 

[Presti_is_god]

My top 5 P4P would go

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Shogun
4. Gomi
5. Hughes

 

[Magnum]

My top 5 P4P would go

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Shogun
4. Gomi
5. Hughes

Yeah, my list pretty much exactly. I'd probably stick cro cop close too, he'd at least be in the mix.