manangatang
Günther was slain in the catacombs
- Moderator
- #826
Their midfield is strong but every time I see these names listed I can’t help but feel they’re being overrated on the basis of certain names. My view of each is above and players of ours listed next to them for some point of comparison.Steele Sidebottom
Scott Pendlebury - A-grade / Cotch
Dayne Beams - A-grade if he stays fit / Dusty
Adam Treloar - A-grade / Lambert
Jordan De Goey - not really a mid / Caddy
Will Hoskin-Elliott - not really a mid / Rioli
Travis Varcoe - B-grade at best and 31 next year / Grigg
Daniel Wells - B-grade at best / Edwards (not saying Sheds is B at best)
Jaidyn Stephenson - B-grade and rising / Higgins
Taylor Adams - A-grade / Prestia
Crisp - B-grade / KMac
is a pretty strong midfield
WCE, Dees and the Giants are impressive too
Mcintosh and Graham are going to need to continue to improve. Grigg needs to be replaced. The people saying Richmond are one high quality mid short might be right.
Wells is cooked and hasn’t played consistent football for years.
Varcoe is 31 this year and isn’t super-impactful on a consistent basis.
Our midfield compares very well to theirs with the exception of one (big) thing. Grundy vs. the Nank.
That’s about the only difference for mine.