Remove this Banner Ad

Training Pre-season 2019

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I haven't written him off this year- that was last year. He has to prove his way back in. Tough road.
If he's fit the road is smooth.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Crockatoo until he proves otherwise.
Sadly, I smell Linc, Mennzel, Vardy and Cowan with our #5.
Yea but you're a natural born cynic.
 
Serious mate, you and a few others have written him off from a media article. That's the definition of a major overreaction.
Seriously 'mate', you need to just relax a little. I haven't come to this conclusion from just '1' media article, I've come to this conclusion from 4 years of less than 10 full games a year, numerous media reports and club statements He's injury prone, and he just got another injury, no matter how small it is. It's not an outlandish statement, it's an insight that you disagree with. That's fine, but stop taking a hostile approach when someone disagrees with your evaluation of the situation. I see it as important in the context of his pre-season, career and contract. You don't. That's fine, and I respect that. But don't just quash others because you see it differently.

We don't know how it'll play out yet. I probably shouldn't have used the term 'game, set and match' as that's disrespectful to Cockatoo, so I apologize for that aspect, but I do feel that this weakens his chances of his pre-season not being hampered. Which then limits his chances of him stringing together enough games. Which then limits his chances of getting another contract. That's my view, and I do sincerely hope it's incorrect for the club and the player's sake.
 
Seriously 'mate', you need to just relax a little. I haven't come to this conclusion from just '1' media article, I've come to this conclusion from 4 years of less than 10 full games a year. He's injury prone, and he just got another injury, no matter how small it is. It's not an outlandish statement, it's an insight that you disagree with. That's fine, but stop taking just a hostile approach when someone disagrees with your evaluation of the situation. I see it as important in the context of his pre-season, career and contract. You don't. That's fine, and I respect that. But don't just quash others because you see it differently.

We don't know how it'll play out yet. I probably shouldn't have used the term 'game, set and match' as that's disrespectful to Cockatoo, so I apologize for that aspect, but I do feel that this weakens his chances of his pre-season not being hampered. Which then limits his chances of him stringing together enough games. Which then limits his chances of getting another contract. That's my view, and I do sincerely hope it's incorrect for the club and the player's sake.
I think you're the one who needs to relax. You wrote him off from a media headline.

He'll be right.
 
Yea but you're a natural born cynic.
As if you'd know that.
We go to the same games year in year out.
You see his potential, and you are swayed by that.
I see his extreme lack of resilience, and I am swayed by that.
Simple.
We see the same player yet see different things
 
I think you're the one who needs to relax. You wrote him off from a media headline.

He'll be right.

Literally just explained how that's not the case -

"I haven't come to this conclusion from just '1' media article, I've come to this conclusion from 4 years of less than 10 full games a year"

This is getting cyclical, so I'll leave it there.
 
Those calling for the calves blood, should remember that's a banned substance now.

Reading between the lines I think Nakia's issue might be a great excuse to miss the indigenous camp.
He should be able to go camping, as long as they don't play footy
 
As if you'd know that.
We go to the same games year in year out.
You see his potential, and you are swayed by that.
I see his extreme lack of resilience, and I am swayed by that.
Simple.
We see the same player yet see different things
You're a cynic mate. Everyone can see that.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Literally just explained how that's not the case -

"I haven't come to this conclusion from just '1' media article, I've come to this conclusion from 4 years of less than 10 full games a year"

This is getting cyclical, so I'll leave it there.
Hence my overreaction reply mate. The sky isn't falling.
 
Only when my thoughts aren't in sync with yours, but that's ok. You've got to judge somehow.
Na mate, my thoughts are irrelevant. You're a cynic.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Na you're a cynic. A true blue one too. Glass half empty kinda guy. That's ok.

No that would be me. VD is a beacon of optimism by comparison.

And the glass isn’t half empty - it’s fallen off the bench and smashed.

Cockatoo needs to get fit, and establish form in the VFL before being selected. He doesn’t deserve automatic selection yet.
 
Last edited:
No that would be me. VD is a beacon of optimism by comparison.

And the glass isn’t half empty - it’s fallen off the bench and smashed.

Cockatoo needs to get fit, and establish fork in the VFL before being selected. He doesn’t deserve automatic selection yet.
Yep plenty more cynical than Vdubs. I know I am.
 
Yeah I read that. Hopefully it looks like he'll be ok. It was a definitive statement for Chris Scott.
This is how he says 2E wants to play round one but they'll have to see how he pulls up.
"I'm outlining his wishes, my view is whether it's round one or two it doesn't matter."
"It depends how he's running. We don't have a fixed mindset in that decision making."
FFS. Could be an area manager for a government agency if coaching ever falls through.
Whenever Scott tries to play something down it always makes me more worried!
 
Apologies, never again.
Btw though, where was JOM in their most important game of the year last year?
Regardless there wouldn't be one poster here that wouldn't be doing handstand if we could get 21 games out of Cocky this season at the level Jaeger performed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top