Remove this Banner Ad

Training Pre-season 2026

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

You're quite correct. Dow's performance over the last couple of years,even though sub standard was at a higher level than MRJ. His possession rate much better than Rioli. Yet Rioli survives. Why?
If I was the cynical type I would say because of his surname.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

You're quite correct. Dow's performance over the last couple of years,even though sub standard was at a higher level than MRJ. His possession rate much better than Rioli. Yet Rioli survives. Why?

Do you even watch games? They play completely different positions and roles
 
Couldn’t we say the same about Thomson Dow and others who have had as much chance as MRJ and are gone?
I just don’t think he’s got the elite ball use skills you want, let alone he doesn’t get it much in the first place.
Dow had one trick, he was good off the deck and looked to have a great hand-pass, which didn't ever eventuate. Rioli has elite speed off the mark, so that is something we do not have in the middle of the ground.

Don't get me wrong, I am pretty critical of him as a player, but he has one trait that separates him from many, speed. Combined with his defensive pressure if he improves his offensive work he might turn the corner, I reckon he has this season to prove it or he will go the way of Dow.
 
As I stated earlier the ridiculous support for MRJ is unbelievable. What have we seen in spurts? 5 years of low possession and disgraceful disposal. Runs on the board at VFL level mean nothing when he's not replicated it at AFL level. This is not about respect for our players. It's about respect for performance. You have to earn respect in AFL and his performance so far is nothing short of RS. Unless his contribution to the team improves out of site, his next phase is delisting.


MRJ Midfield wow. NO WAy. Earn it first.
What is so bad about wanting a kid to make it? Granted his performances at AFL level have been frustrating but as long as he is on our list he warrants being supported. Now nobody is saying that posters can't be critical, but instead of being abusive when doing so, it would be great if posters spoke about them the same way they would expect someone to talk about them and that is with some respect. Surely that's not that hard to do.
 
Some real Stockholm syndrome going on here. You dont need to stick up for your master FFS.
boss GIF
 
People like Michaels who actually bring us some content are what makes BF go around, as without it all that’s left is reading nuffie comments from people like you and me.

Don’t discourage people who bring content by belittling them and trying to make them feel like sh*t.

Keep it up Michaels … content of any kind is great.

This board has some A-grade trolls

Unfortunately your trolling is amateur hour stuff

Do better

Outside of his chat with Rhy all he does is summarise other people’s content. He needs to create his own brand and content to be of any interest to me.


IMG_9305.jpeg
 
People like Michaels who actually bring us some content are what makes BF go around, as without it all that’s left is reading nuffie comments from people like you and me.

Don’t discourage people who bring content by belittling them and trying to make them feel like sh*t.

Keep it up Michaels … content of any kind is great.
Unlucky Michaels youre no longer a nuffie 🤣🤣🤣
 

I look at this from the other angle. Why do we have to get along all the time? Boring.

Why can't we feel good about fighting with each other? I am currently working on a new batch of nasty bitchy comments specifically designed to make people feel bad about themselves. I just thought it was time I did something constructive around here.

Sorry, I got that wrong.

I just thought it was time I did something constructive around here, campaigner.
 
Outside of his chat with Rhy all he does is summarise other people’s content. He needs to create his own brand and content to be of any interest to me.
Yeah … outside of his 43-minute chat with the RFC head of recruiting immediately after the draft, he really didn’t deliver much of value this draft period.

Any other unpaid content providers from other clubs have 43-minute interviews with their heads of recruiting?

And I do something really novel … when I see something from Michaels that doesn’t interest me, I don’t watch it. When I see things like an interview with Rhy, an in-depth discussion with Dylan Alexander whom I rate etc…, then I tune in.

It’s ground breaking behaviour.
 
I look at this from the other angle. Why do we have to get along all the time? Boring.

Why can't we feel good about fighting with each other? I am currently working on a new batch of nasty bitchy comments specifically designed to make people feel bad about themselves. I just thought it was time I did something constructive around here.

Sorry, I got that wrong.

I just thought it was time I did something constructive around here, campaigner.
1764886225117.png
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Do you even watch games? They play completely different positions and roles
Yes I watch games. Every week live, year in year out.

I'm not trying to match Rioli v Dow by position. I was pointing out that Dow was better performed than Rioli overall but was moved on.They're both bog ordinary players that would not get a game at a decent side. So I'm questioning why you'd persevere with Rioli. He's on the list for this year so I'll hope by some miracle he actually comes good and provides some value. All I see in Rioli is a player with speed who will chase ferociously. He appears to have no other redeeming AFL features. He cannot kick over a jam tin, has disgraceful disposal, is a poor decision maker and has extremely low possessions in a game. I was pointing out the idea of playing him in the midfield was nonsensical and that he should have to earn the right to play midfield.

I think he's a bust and Richmond should have been rid of him. I'll keep my fingers crossed that he some how turns it around, but I just can't see it. I think many on BF show blind faith in a player that has had ample time to show they are good enough. Probably because they declared the player would be good or a star and are not accepting that he's bombed.
 
Yes I watch games. Every week live, year in year out.

I'm not trying to match Rioli v Dow by position. I was pointing out that Dow was better performed than Rioli overall but was moved on.They're both bog ordinary players that would not get a game at a decent side. So I'm questioning why you'd persevere with Rioli. He's on the list for this year so I'll hope by some miracle he actually comes good and provides some value. All I see in Rioli is a player with speed who will chase ferociously. He appears to have no other redeeming AFL features. He cannot kick over a jam tin, has disgraceful disposal, is a poor decision maker and has extremely low possessions in a game. I was pointing out the idea of playing him in the midfield was nonsensical and that he should have to earn the right to play midfield.

I think he's a bust and Richmond should have been rid of him. I'll keep my fingers crossed that he some how turns it around, but I just can't see it. I think many on BF show blind faith in a player that has had ample time to show they are good enough. Probably because they declared the player would be good or a star and are not accepting that he's bombed.
Can you list all the players you want retired and delisted at the end of 2026
 
Yes I watch games. Every week live, year in year out.

I'm not trying to match Rioli v Dow by position. I was pointing out that Dow was better performed than Rioli overall but was moved on.They're both bog ordinary players that would not get a game at a decent side. So I'm questioning why you'd persevere with Rioli. He's on the list for this year so I'll hope by some miracle he actually comes good and provides some value. All I see in Rioli is a player with speed who will chase ferociously. He appears to have no other redeeming AFL features. He cannot kick over a jam tin, has disgraceful disposal, is a poor decision maker and has extremely low possessions in a game. I was pointing out the idea of playing him in the midfield was nonsensical and that he should have to earn the right to play midfield.

I think he's a bust and Richmond should have been rid of him. I'll keep my fingers crossed that he some how turns it around, but I just can't see it. I think many on BF show blind faith in a player that has had ample time to show they are good enough. Probably because they declared the player would be good or a star and are not accepting that he's bombed.
He may well prove to be the failure you're saying, but for me, he’s shown so far to be a decent small forward AT TIMES. Always seemed to fade in games, and needs to kick a few more goals imo.

Having watched the training videos and the comments from Caesar on PRE, who attends most training sessions, it appears on face value that the penny has finally dropped with Rioli, and he’s the fittest he’s ever been at this time of the pre-season.

My only worry is how he comes back after the Xmas break, but I’m hoping he does what he did after the AFL season ended, get involved with a personal trainer and work his ass off. Apparently, he has been up the front in some of the full ground running drills at training, so hopefully his endurance has reached the levels required to perform at AFL level. If it has, and he fails to perform again this year, then yep, he will be gone I’d reckon. But until then, I’ll support him.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Outside of his chat with Rhy all he does is summarise other people’s content. He needs to create his own brand and content to be of any interest to me.
Why would anyone strive to be of any interest to you? ..genuine question..
Because you come across on here as a thoroughly unlikeable individual
 
Why would anyone strive to be of any interest to you? ..genuine question..
Because you come across on here as a thoroughly unlikeable individual
Genuine questions can only be answered by genuine persons.

He doesn't pay when he loses bets on his opinions therefore any opinions he has ultimately mean nothing.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Training Pre-season 2026

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top