Predicted team vs. Adelaide

[dont bowl there]

Dodd has been one of our best and most consitant players this year. Some people really need to watch the game a bit beter.

 

[Bradesmaen]

You want to drop the BOG (for freo) from the kangaroos game? Did you watch Dodd on the weekend at all?

I don't want Dodd dropped, but he was nowhere near BOG for us on the weekend.

 

[Ripper]

I don't want Dodd dropped, but he was nowhere near BOG for us on the weekend.

Made 4 errors in 29 disposals and was ranked highest on ground out of both teams by a fair bit by pro stats.

9 rebound 50's , 3 inside 50's , 4 contested possies , 4 tackles and a goal.

Macca on the other hand ended up with the lowest ranking for Freo , just ahead of Daniel Wells.

 

[pistol17]

I don't want Dodd dropped, but he was nowhere near BOG for us on the weekend.

Watch the game again. You must have watched a different game to the rest of us. Check out the stats Ripper posted.

 

[Bradesmaen]

Watch the game again. You must have watched a different game to the rest of us. Check out the stats Ripper posted.

Stats mean nothing when 3 of his errors gave three goals.

 

[Brumbies]

He always choices to spoil instead of going for a constested mark. He was good last year.

Um is it fair to point out that he is doing the disciplined and team thing. As a defender you are taught to punch before mark if all our other defenders did this we may win more games.

 

[Scham]

We're bound to see some new blood and some creative selections now! You beauty!

 

[dockers_bengals]

We're bound to see some new blood and some craetive selections now! You beauty!

who?Either they are injured or where injured or show no consistant form

 

[pistol17]

who?Either they are injured or where injured or show no consistant form

Ill give you one name who has been consistent all year.

Andrew Foster!!

 

[Scham]

Ill give you one name who has been consistent all year.

Andrew Foster!!

Exactly!

Ibbo and Drum should be considered too.

 

[Plugga]

If Harvey wants the gig next year he'll want the strongest team possible for this game, as he'll want an upset win & then all the talk will be on Harv's as next coach for 2008.

OUT: Murphy (suspended)
Gilmore (hack)
Walker (played last game for Freo)


IN: Farmer
Warnock
MCarr

If CC was in charge this week I think he would have swung open the changes & brought in Drum, Duffield, Foster. But Harvs will need to see who wants to play for him first & so Mundy, Hasleby, Crowley & Schammer will be given another shot.

 

[summerthebat]

Harvey will play who he thinks can play, it's going to be interesting to see if his view on players will greatly differ now he can take majority of control.

That's if he does take over?

 

[Scham]

CC would've played Parker

Harvey apparently has a lot of time for Duffield, whreas CC didn't apparently. I'll be interested to see if Harvey backs the guy in and even more interesting will be how he (Duffield) responds.

 

[Kenny_01]

Macca has to go, as does Walker.

Out- Macca, Walker, Murphy, Gilmore

In- Duffman, Foster, Ibbo, Warnock

Gilmore was good but has to make way for Warnock. Unless Sandi is rested.

Possibly bring in Drum as well and give him M Carrs role..... for maybe Thornton.

 

[Plugga]

Macca has to go, as does Walker.

Out- Macca, Walker, Murphy, Gilmore

In- Duffman, Foster, Ibbo, Warnock

Gilmore was good but has to make way for Warnock. Unless Sandi is rested.

Possibly bring in Drum as well and give him M Carrs role..... for maybe Thornton.

Kenny - I will be astounded if he makes those changes. I'll buy you a Crownie in the BWR...it ain'ty going to happen. Ibbo has been serviceable for the Sharks, but probably doesn't derserve a call up at the moment. Macca will play, Thornton will play, Matt Carr will play

 

[Slacker]

Harvey will play who he thinks can play, it's going to be interesting to see if his view on players will greatly differ now he can take majority of control.

That's if he does take over?

Agree that it will be very interesting to see Harvey's team (if Harvey takes the role). Harvey will be coaching to win too so he probably won't bring in young guys to "blood" them.

 

[Kenny_01]

Kenny - I will be astounded if he makes those changes. I'll buy you a Crownie in the BWR...it ain'ty going to happen. Ibbo has been serviceable for the Sharks, but probably doesn't derserve a call up at the moment. Macca will play, Thornton will play, Matt Carr will play

Agree... it's wishful thinking on my part but maybe with a new coach...

 

[Scham]

Harvey will be coaching to win too so he probably won't bring in young guys to "blood" them.

It astounds me that people still think that playing young players means you won't win!Hello?