Preference - GWS OR BRIS?

[jackcass]

Apparently we're just making up the numbers so not really sure it matters who wins this week, as long as the game is brutal.

 

[domin8tors]

Brisbane for mine. if GWS one day play to their optimum consistently then we could merge Collingwood and Richmond and i don't think we would win.

 

[Somebody]

GWS are the only other team left to have thrashed us this year.
Bris prefered, but GWS would be the more intense.

 

[adammania9]

Mitch Robinson will miss Saturday night through injury but may return for a preliminary final if they get through

 

[DinoSoar]

Knew Greene wouldn’t get a suspension, no one gets suspended during the finals these days.

 

[Drought Break]

Knew Greene wouldn’t get a suspension, no one gets suspended during the finals these days.

Cloke and Rocco would disagree mate

 

[Nuffsaid]

Brisbane we match up better against them.

 

[gopies1981]

It be a very hostile environment whoever plays the pies!! We need all our 85,000 members out in force to make it a see if black and white at the mcg!!

 

[NonPhixion]

Much rather play Brisbane. Giants are far more talented & could have Coniglio back for the prelim should they make it. They will be out for revenge after last year too. Praying the lions win, no disrespect but I’d be a lot more confident playing them

 

[left at home]

Really don’t care, which team, but probably be gws.

 

[Kilmo]

Much rather play Brisbane. Giants are far more talented & could have Coniglio back for the prelim should they make it. They will be out for revenge after last year too. Praying the lions win, no disrespect but I’d be a lot more confident playing them

Same. But they won't win.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

I must be the only one who prefer GWS. They’re generally bad at the G. They haven’t won a final at the G.

Also, I would back our defence to hold Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg to low scores.

GWS will be travelling back-to-back.

Brisbane play the G well. They weren’t bad against at the Tigers. Only poor goal kicking blew the game open.

 

[Aishole]

I must be the only one who prefer GWS. They’re generally bad at the G. They haven’t won a final at the G.

Also, I would back our defence to hold Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg to low scores.

GWS will be travelling back-to-back.

Brisbane play the G well. They weren’t bad against at the Tigers. Only poor goal kicking blew the game open.

Yeah im with you, give me GWS. We have a good history against them aside from the 1 quarter this year. They have a history of fluffing it at the G & on big occasions. Our pressure + 90,000 pies fans would have them looking like deers in headlights

 

[Kirby]

I'm not worried about match ups with either side.

I'd only prefer Brisbane because if they get through this week I think that they will be mentally shot by the preliminary final, after such a long season for them.

 

[rdangelo]

Would have preferred Richmond tbh

Don't count out Geelong just yet. Towled up both WCE and Richmond early on in the year. They're the type of team that can click from nowhere.

 

[Jen2310]

Mitch Robinson will miss Saturday night through injury but may return for a preliminary final if they get through

Didn't he do his hamstring? lol

 

[Jen2310]

I must be the only one who prefer GWS. They’re generally bad at the G. They haven’t won a final at the G.

Also, I would back our defence to hold Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg to low scores.

GWS will be travelling back-to-back.

Brisbane play the G well. They weren’t bad against at the Tigers. Only poor goal kicking blew the game open.

Not totally true. They haven't won at the G in 5 years. Since 2014, against us, funny enough.

 

[Finnishpie]

brsbane are the weaker team

 

[TKiL]

We can't be choosy - either will be tough - need our A game every minute.

 

[domus]

Knew Greene wouldn’t get a suspension, no one gets suspended during the finals these days.

Collingwood players have copped their fair share in past eras. Cloke, Rocca and Carmen and each suspension had a huge impact on the outcome of the GF. Yet two Sydney Swan players blatantly punched their opponents and both played in their respective grand finals (Barry Hall and Dunkly). Enough to make you smell a dirty big rat.

 

[swoop42]

I tipped straight sets for Brisbane prior to the finals starting but I really hope I'm wrong as GWS worry me much more after their dominant display against the red hot Bulldogs.

I'm tipping West Coast but really only care that it's a dominant display by the victor whoever that may end up being. I want Richmond nervous by the end of the night

 

[PicaBoo]

Knew Greene wouldn’t get a suspension, no one gets suspended during the finals these days.

That didn't age well.

 

[DinoSoar]

That didn't age well.

really, have I missed something? Has the Match Review Officer or the AFL tribunal handed out a suspension for an in game incident since last Saturday’s games? No? Didn’t think so ...

Can’t conflate an anti-doping suspension with on-field, game day incidents that are 100% within the AFL’s discretion.

 

[PicaBoo]

really, have I missed something? Has the Match Review Officer or the AFL tribunal handed out a suspension for an in game incident since last Saturday’s games? No? Didn’t think so ...

Can’t conflate an anti-doping suspension with on-field, game day incidents that are 100% within the AFL’s discretion.

You're right. My bad

 

[magpies42]

Brisbane, but I also wanted west coast to beat Melbourne last year...we take of ourselves and we can beat anyone