B Section Premier B - 2012

[sticks96]

Sticks, you seem to be all over this topic - is it true that Beaumaris pleaded the charged player's innocence to the extent of him not being involved in the fracas?

Not at all

 

[Max Leader]

yep, truly amazing considering a "medical expert" stood up in front of the "tribunal" and swore that he would miss 5-6 weeks which no doubt played a part in determining Petering's penalty.

How many people, when told by their doctor, give up smoking, actually do?

From my understanding it was the players contrition (big word) that ensured a long gap between games.

 

[sticks96]

How many people, when told by their doctor, give up smoking, actually do?

From my understanding it was the players contrition (big word) that ensured a long gap between games.[/quote

Not sure what the smoking inference (big word) is but if you're suggesting that a doctor's recommendations hold little water I beg to differ. Can't comment on Petering's remorsefulness or lack thereof as I wasn't there.

 

[BrianSpeaking]

I am missing the issue here. Are you guys from Beauy saying that a behind the play king hit is acceptable just because the victim only missed one week? What about the fact that he had to have an operation? 5 weeks is fair IMO.

 

[Max Leader]

I am missing the issue here. Are you guys from Beauy saying that a behind the play king hit is acceptable just because the victim only missed one week? What about the fact that he had to have an operation? 5 weeks is fair IMO.

If this occured off the football field, what would have been the ramification? Ask Simon Cowley.

 

[Cosmo21]

If this occured off the football field, what would have been the ramification? Ask Simon Cowley.

Cowley really?? First of all you had your figures crossed you would win the game by defult and now you are trying to compare this to a king hit in a night club?? Cowley wouldn't have been able to play a game of footy 14 days after his hit?? Would seem that the injuries weren't as bad as made out but I'm assume you already know this hence why you keep biting back

 

[RahRah]

If this occured off the football field, what would have been the ramification? Ask Simon Cowley.

Why would we ask the X-Factor judge about an issue like this?

 

[Cosmo21]

I am missing the issue here. Are you guys from Beauy saying that a behind the play king hit is acceptable just because the victim only missed one week? What about the fact that he had to have an operation? 5 weeks is fair IMO.

BS not at all "behind the play" must be stamped out of the game the sooner the better, but seems to be some major inconsistency in the injury, games missed and also where / when it happened! This can't be over looked....

 

[Privateye]

I am missing the issue here. Are you guys from Beauy saying that a behind the play king hit is acceptable just because the victim only missed one week? What about the fact that he had to have an operation? 5 weeks is fair IMO.

Yes, I agree with you here Brian, 5 weeks sees him miss against St Kevins but first game back will be Uni Blacks.

 

[THE BEACON]

BS not at all "behind the play" must be stamped out of the game the sooner the better, but seems to be some major inconsistency in the injury, games missed and also where / when it happened! This can't be over looked....

If he didn't do it in the first place, then he wouldn't been reported & consequently missing games as a result!!

 

[Ron Jeremy 69]

I am missing the issue here. Are you guys from Beauy saying that a behind the play king hit is acceptable just because the victim only missed one week? What about the fact that he had to have an operation? 5 weeks is fair IMO.

I am with you Brian!

 

[Privateye]

The Seasiders, not happy with being clear enough on the Melee ladder have added another Melee to their score.

Congratulation to Beaumaris - 10 club melees in 2 seasons + 2 games. VAFA record. Rare territory indeed.


Not to be outdone St Bedes and the Krushers stepped up and also have added another melee.
Over to the Brightonians to respond in kind!

THE EYE
​

And just in case it escaped anyone -- Old Brighton v Werribee District.

MAJOR MELEE & MINOR MELEE in the one game - Seniors R2

Old Brighton - $1,150
Werribee - $750

Accepted Prescribed.

 

[zeroseven]

And just in case it escaped anyone -- Old Brighton v Werribee District.

MAJOR MELEE & MINOR MELEE in the one game - Seniors R2

Old Brighton - $1,150
Werribee - $750

Accepted Prescribed.

Well that is a few Chardonnays for M & M in the glasshouse.

 

[bocce]

just heard that Werribee v Uni blakcs game been moved to price down werribee south cause council upgrading ground. big awakening for uni b playing on a cow paddock

 

[Cosmo21]

If he did'nt do it in the first place, then he wouldn't been reported & consequently missing games as a result!!

No doubt really dont think anyone here is saying he should of got off, but this was a complete setup when it come to the amount of time given based on the injury recived! I'm sure the VAFA aren't happy about being made look stupid when a player is going to be out for 6 they use this to sentance and he plays in 2??

 

[Max Leader]

No doubt really dont think anyone here is saying he should of got off, but this was a complete setup when it come to the amount of time given based on the injury recived! I'm sure the VAFA aren't happy about being made look stupid when a player is going to be out for 6 they use this to sentance and he plays in 2??

FFS.
Off the ball. 3-4 weeks
Less than truthful and no contrition additional 1-2 weeks
Injury level - irrelevant

Who pays for the surgery, who covers the lost wages. Not Mr. Petering

PS

Who wouldn't take the 4 points. Didn't deserve them, but 4 points is 4 points.

 

[Cosmo21]

FFS.
Off the ball. 3-4 weeks
Less than truthful and no contrition additional 1-2 weeks
Injury level - irrelevant

Who pays for the surgery, who covers the lost wages. Not Mr. Petering

PS

Who wouldn't take the 4 points. Didn't deserve them, but 4 points is 4 points.

Yep would take the points every day of the week Must have been amazing surgery given the injuries presented, to play 4 days after - Injury level is everything

 

[man in outer]

FFS.
Off the ball. 3-4 weeks
Less than truthful and no contrition additional 1-2 weeks
Injury level - irrelevant

Who pays for the surgery, who covers the lost wages. Not Mr. Petering

PS

Who wouldn't take the 4 points. Didn't deserve them, but 4 points is 4 points.

Surely this topic has had enough airtime. Should count himself lucky IMO. Striking in our league should carry a heavy suspension especially off the ball stuff. By the sounds of things there is no dispute that he stuck a player. Why do some of the district sides feel the need to prove they are tougher than the school teams? Every time we played them that is all you would hear from the crowd and the opposition is about the school boy thing. Even from Beauy; not exactly the land of Mr & Mrs short of a coin.

Back to footy and its looks to be a race in 3, although as we all know early form can be deceiving. I remember as would BS SKOB willing about 6 on the bounce to start an A section season only to just miss relegation. Looking forward to the weekend already. Nothing like a footy ground right next door to the sandbelt...certainly helps organise my saturday!

 

[The Black Bear]

Back to the football, great to see a couple of Blacks players named in the U 23 squad, I personally would have thought that we should had up to half a dozen but that's typical of people not rating our club. Just wondering how 3 players from a Premier C club get in before better players from Premier B or A clubs? Is there someone from that club on the selection panel? Seems very odd, nepotism?

Not afraid to go anywhere to play Werribee, we will play them at the shit farm if need be, which after looking at the location of this weeks game may as well be there! Their form has been pretty 'smelly' the last few weeks!

Winners this week:
Blacks by 75 going away...
Beauy by 40,
OB by plenty, I mean twenty.
OM's by 10 pts
Oakleigh to upset the chokers by 7 points.

What has happened to Cardio, has he been given the lemon and sarse?

 

[AM]

I am with you Brian!

And I find you Brian and Bob Down absolutely enthralling.

 

[Grum Smuth]

Back to the football, great to see a couple of Blacks players named in the U 23 squad, I personally would have thought that we should had up to half a dozen but that's typical of people not rating our club. Just wondering how 3 players from a Premier C club get in before better players from Premier B or A clubs? Is there someone from that club on the selection panel? Seems very odd, nepotism?

Not afraid to go anywhere to play Werribee, we will play them at the shit farm if need be, which after looking at the location of this weeks game may as well be there! Their form has been pretty 'smelly' the last few weeks!

Winners this week:
Blacks by 75 going away...
Beauy by 40,
OB by plenty, I mean twenty.
OM's by 10 pts
Oakleigh to upset the chokers by 7 points.

What has happened to Cardio, has he been given the lemon and sarse?

Why it'll be just like playing Old Brighton! After all the Price Reserve is adjacent to Beach Road!

Hee hee hee

 

[Rooster 24]

Back to the football, great to see a couple of Blacks players named in the U 23 squad, I personally would have thought that we should had up to half a dozen but that's typical of people not rating our club. Just wondering how 3 players from a Premier C club get in before better players from Premier B or A clubs? Is there someone from that club on the selection panel? Seems very odd, nepotism?


While on the U23s. I reckon the rep stuff is great but it is absolutely ridiculous that the U23s game is being played on the same weekend as club games. Why not the weekend of 14th July when the U19s game is on and there is no Premier A, B or C matches. This will really impact on who makes themselves available. (I know it already has)

Thankfully our club only had 3 nominated but we could easily have had a lot more. A big number of our senior list are in this age bracket and many would have very solid claims.

 

[Bluebird]

Back to the football, great to see a couple of Blacks players named in the U 23 squad, I personally would have thought that we should had up to half a dozen but that's typical of people not rating our club. Just wondering how 3 players from a Premier C club get in before better players from Premier B or A clubs? Is there someone from that club on the selection panel? Seems very odd, nepotism?

Clubs were asked to nominate their own players for the squad in the first instance. Don't think anyone would disagree your lot are going along nicely, perhaps they're just trying to keep a lid on. Novel idea

 

[bocce]

Not afraid to go anywhere to play Werribee, we will play them at the shit farm if need be, which after looking at the location of this weeks game may as well be there! Their form has been pretty 'smelly' the last few weeks!

you will be able to be beside yourself and shake hands with the best part of you

 

[WEST]

Not afraid to go anywhere to play Werribee, we will play them at the shit farm if need be, which after looking at the location of this weeks game may as well be there! Their form has been pretty 'smelly' the last few weeks!

you will be able to be beside yourself and shake hands with the best part of you

Harsh call bocce. Go back to WRFL thread.
I think you have your wires crosssed regarding Venue on Saturday