Remove this Banner Ad

Premier C - 2016

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Full credit to Marcellin yesterday, jumped us early against the wind and it was always catch up. The future looks good where ever that may be with 11 players under 20 yesterday. Still 3 to go , anything can happen and hopefully it gets down to who wins the Timekeepers cup in round 18.
On another note why was there 3 umps yesterday.
 
Full credit to Marcellin yesterday, jumped us early against the wind and it was always catch up. The future looks good where ever that may be with 11 players under 20 yesterday. Still 3 to go , anything can happen and hopefully it gets down to who wins the Timekeepers cup in round 18.
On another note why was there 3 umps yesterday.

Coz the size of the Ground

Max "Made his come back as a man in Green yesterday" Leader
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

AFL use 3 umpires on ground the size of Marcellin's. Also getting umps ready for finals when they have 3 umpires.
It didn't work, 1 of the three was good, the girl won't make a decision and the other one would be better doing Clubbies. The girl we have had 6 times, that's a joke.
 
It didn't work, 1 of the three was good, the girl won't make a decision and the other one would be better doing Clubbies. The girl we have had 6 times, that's a joke.
I understand the main role of Chuck and Gibbo is development but when there’s a scarcity of capable umps in the lower grades I don’t get why they aren’t used in Prem ‘C’ more often.

Coz the size of the Ground

Max "Made his come back as a man in Green yesterday" Leader

Central Maxy?
 
Last edited:
It didn't work, 1 of the three was good, the girl won't make a decision and the other one would be better doing Clubbies. The girl we have had 6 times, that's a joke.

I bit my tongue last week and didn't name or suggest . I don't think it's the girls fault. I think that she has been told not to give decisions so she doesn't make bad ones. She missed time after time last week. Didn't disadvantage either side , but you have to make them when you need to protect players going for the ball..she needs to be given lower grades and more education on the rules of th e game.

As I said not her fault she is being put in a position she shouldn't be in. We need to encourage umpire so they don't get disheartened but they need to learn in low grades.
 
I bit my tongue last week and didn't name or suggest . I don't think it's the girls fault. I think that she has been told not to give decisions so she doesn't make bad ones. She missed time after time last week. Didn't disadvantage either side , but you have to make them when you need to protect players going for the ball..she needs to be given lower grades and more education on the rules of th e game.

As I said not her fault she is being put in a position she shouldn't be in. We need to encourage umpire so they don't get disheartened but they need to learn in low grades.
That surprises Scruffy. I've heard the Monders Prez, who has "A" Section central umpiring GF credits to his name, suggest umps are told to call 'em as they 'em.
 
I bit my tongue last week and didn't name or suggest . I don't think it's the girls fault. I think that she has been told not to give decisions so she doesn't make bad ones. She missed time after time last week. Didn't disadvantage either side , but you have to make them when you need to protect players going for the ball..she needs to be given lower grades and more education on the rules of th e game.

As I said not her fault she is being put in a position she shouldn't be in. We need to encourage umpire so they don't get disheartened but they need to learn in low grades.
That's it Scruff, spot on. She's not bad,but lets the othere ump do all the work. How was Willy yesterday, a tad cold I would think.
 
That's it Scruff, spot on. She's not bad,but lets the othere ump do all the work. How was Willy yesterday, a tad cold I would think.
Tough day down there yesterday . Blowing it Ts off. We had a serious injury which stopped the game and Ambulance had to take one of our kids away. An incidental head knock but he collapsed when he got up...terrible to watch and his parents were there.

Willy played there ground well and scored both times into the gale by using the protected areas of the ground and derived to win.

We had 5 out ,all key players incl the Captain but don't want to make any excuses because we didn't play smart....

Hopefully the loss we needed to kick us into gear going into finals
 
Bit different from saying she doesn't pay 'em.

Great to see you and Mr Bedford getting along so well these days. Wouldn't be surprised to see him jump on the bandwagon come finals.:)

Don't no what your talkin about ....he's always been very complimentary of me....I've been the Mastermind and a Goose....been called a lot worse than that....
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I understand the main role of Chuck and Gibbo is development but when there’s a scarcity of capable umps in the lower grades I don’t get why they aren’t used in Prem ‘C’ more often.



Central Maxy?
Yep

Came up ok to.
 
The shorter umpire was a shocker , too reactive. Terrible facilities for the away teams , one toilet between two teams all day, it's not good enough.
 
The O's arn't gone yet . 3 games to go Maple

Mathematically no. But if you can't make a prediction on this site, where can you? They will both drop IMO.
Maplebet has been inundated today with all monies pointing towards this. You gotta respect the money flow..
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

3 umps in c grade. Lowly d3 gleneira v elsternwick gets one field ump in freezing windy conditions. Good old district sides suffer.

At Elsternwick Ground #2?

My grandpa could hobble around there and umpire a d3 game without missing much.

Totally different to the speed of Premier C on a quick deck at Bulleen.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top