Premiership players at 2 different clubs

Remove this Banner Ad

In the SAFA (now SANFL), there was a Fred Curnow who played in a premiership for Port Adelaide (1910), Sturt (1915) and North Adelaide (1920). I'm not 100% it is the same person but am assuming it is.
This suggests it is: https://australianfootball.com/players/player/cec+curnow/19023

"War Horse" Curnow Explains His System.

There is probably not a better-known footballer playing to-day than F. C. Curnow, North's champion ruck man, who is affectionately known as the "war horse." In his time he has played with four different league clubs, and is at presenet assisting to coach the red-and-whites.

Curnow first played football for the Moonta Club in the Yorke's Peninsula Association in 1904, but left a few years later for New Zealand. He played there for two years—1907 and 1908—and then returned to South Australia to live in Adelaide. He played for South Adelaide in 1909, and for Port Adelaide a year later. In that season Ports went top after having been beaten only twice. They also defeated the premier teams of Broken Hill, New South Wales, and Western Australia. Callinan, Congear, and himself formed the rucks in those days. From Port Adelaide Curnow went to Unley, and played for Sturts in 1912-13-14, and 1915, and then again moved, this time to settle permanently in North Adelaide. In his early days he played in the ruck and forward, but of recent years has been spelled in the half-back lines. He is one of the oldest men in the league still playing, but is still in the pink of condition, as his remarkable speed last Saturday proved.

https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/200928124
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

It will be interesting if and when GWS win a premiership
They've only got two players (Mumford and Shaw) on their list who are premiership players with other clubs, so there wouldn't be too many changes to make to the list of 2-club flag winners.
 
both blokes could make this list this year
Could happen! Those with a chance in 2019 are:

Brisbane: Christensen, Hodge
Carlton: Thomas
Collingwood: Roughead, Varcoe
Essendon: Stringer
Fremantle: Hamling, B. Hill
Geelong: Dahlhaus
GWS: Mumford, Shaw
Melbourne: Lewis
Port Adelaide: Lycett
St Kilda: Brown, Hannebery
Sydney: Franklin
Western Bulldogs: Duryea, Suckling
 
Updated list:
  1. Eddie Drohan = Fitzroy (1898, 1999) and Collingwood (1903)
  2. Mick Grace = Fitzroy (1898, 1899) and Carlton (1906, 1907)
  3. Frank Caine = Carlton (1906, 1907) and Essendon (1912)
  4. Jim Martin = Essendon (1912) and Fitzroy (1913)
  5. Charlie Norris = Collingwood (1910) and Fitzroy (1913, 1916)
  6. Tom Fitzmaurice = Essendon (1923, 1924) and Geelong (1925)
  7. Horrie Edmonds = Collingwood (1929, 1930) and Richmond (1934)
  8. Jack Carney = Geelong (1931) and Carlton (1938)
  9. Brighton Diggins = South Melbourne (1933) and Carlton (1938)
  10. Keith Stackpole = Collingwood (1935, 1936) and Fitzroy (1944)
  11. Gordon Abbott = Geelong (1937) and Essendon (1942, 1946)
  12. Peter McLean = Melbourne (1964) and Carlton (1968)
  13. Ian Stewart = St Kilda (1966) and Richmond (1973)
  14. Barry Davis = Essendon (1962, 1965) and North Melbourne (1975)
  15. Doug Wade = Geelong (1963) and North Melbourne (1975)
  16. Brent Crosswell = Carlton (1968, 1970) and North Melbourne (1975, 1977)
  17. Barry Rowlings = Hawthorn (1976) and Richmond (1980)
  18. Bryan Wood = Richmond (1973, 1974, 1980) and Essendon (1985)
  19. Darren Jarman = Hawthorn (1991) and Adelaide (1997, 1998)
  20. Martin Pike = North Melbourne (1999) and Brisbane Lions (2001, 2002, 2003)
  21. Blake Caracella = Essendon (2000) and Brisbane Lions (2003)
  22. Gavin Wanganeen = Essendon (1993) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  23. Byron Pickett = North Melbourne (1999) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  24. Damien Hardwick = Essendon (2000) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  25. Jason Ball = West Coast (1994) and Sydney (2005)
  26. Cameron Mooney = North Melbourne (1999) and Geelong (2007, 2009)
  27. Stuart Dew = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2008)
  28. Darren Jolly = Sydney (2005) and Collingwood (2010)
  29. Shaun Burgoyne = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2013, 2014, 2015)
  30. Lewis Jetta = Sydney (2012) and West Coast (2018)
 
Last edited:
2021 qualifiers

Brisbane - Birchall
Collingwood - Roughead
Essendon - Stringer
Fremantle - Hamling
Geelong - Dahlhaus, Smith
Gold Coast - Ellis, Townsend
GWS - Mumford
Hawthorn - Burgoyne
Port Adelaide - Goldsack, Lycett
St.Kilda - Butler, Frawley, Hannebery, Hill
Sydney - Franklin
Western Bulldogs - Duryea
 
2021 qualifiers

Brisbane - Birchall
Collingwood - Roughead
Essendon - Stringer
Fremantle - Hamling
Geelong - Dahlhaus, Smith
Gold Coast - Ellis, Townsend
GWS - Mumford
Hawthorn - Burgoyne
Port Adelaide - Goldsack, Lycett
St.Kilda - Butler, Frawley, Hannebery, Hill
Sydney - Franklin
Western Bulldogs - Duryea
Geelong - Dahlhaus, Smith
Port Adelaide - Lycett
Western Bulldogs - Duryea
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Brett James and Aaron Keating started on the bench in Adelaide's first flag in 1997, then played in Norwood's premiership in the SANFL a week later
 
2022 update

One of Isaac Smith or Lance Franklin will become the 31st entrant to the list

Luke Dahlhaus could join Smith if he whips out the steel chair and takes out a few teammates by Saturday
 
Bump.

Updated list:
  1. Eddie Drohan = Fitzroy (1898, 1899) and Collingwood (1903)
  2. Mick Grace = Fitzroy (1898, 1899) and Carlton (1906, 1907)
  3. Frank Caine = Carlton (1906, 1907) and Essendon (1912)
  4. Jim Martin = Essendon (1912) and Fitzroy (1913)
  5. Charlie Norris = Collingwood (1910) and Fitzroy (1913, 1916)
  6. Tom Fitzmaurice = Essendon (1923, 1924) and Geelong (1925)
  7. Horrie Edmonds = Collingwood (1929, 1930) and Richmond (1934)
  8. Jack Carney = Geelong (1931) and Carlton (1938)
  9. Brighton Diggins = South Melbourne (1933) and Carlton (1938)
  10. Keith Stackpole = Collingwood (1935, 1936) and Fitzroy (1944)
  11. Gordon Abbott = Geelong (1937) and Essendon (1942, 1946)
  12. Peter McLean = Melbourne (1964) and Carlton (1968)
  13. Ian Stewart = St Kilda (1966) and Richmond (1973)
  14. Barry Davis = Essendon (1962, 1965) and North Melbourne (1975)
  15. Doug Wade = Geelong (1963) and North Melbourne (1975)
  16. Brent Crosswell = Carlton (1968, 1970) and North Melbourne (1975, 1977)
  17. Barry Rowlings = Hawthorn (1976) and Richmond (1980)
  18. Bryan Wood = Richmond (1973, 1974, 1980) and Essendon (1985)
  19. Darren Jarman = Hawthorn (1991) and Adelaide (1997, 1998)
  20. Martin Pike = North Melbourne (1999) and Brisbane Lions (2001, 2002, 2003)
  21. Blake Caracella = Essendon (2000) and Brisbane Lions (2003)
  22. Gavin Wanganeen = Essendon (1993) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  23. Byron Pickett = North Melbourne (1999) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  24. Damien Hardwick = Essendon (2000) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  25. Jason Ball = West Coast (1994) and Sydney (2005)
  26. Cameron Mooney = North Melbourne (1999) and Geelong (2007, 2009)
  27. Stuart Dew = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2008)
  28. Darren Jolly = Sydney (2005) and Collingwood (2010)
  29. Shaun Burgoyne = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2013, 2014, 2015)
  30. Lewis Jetta = Sydney (2012) and West Coast (2018)
  31. Isaac Smith = Hawthorn (2013, 2014, 2015) and Geelong (2022)
 
Last edited:
I doubt this has happened...
3 different clubs and 3 premierships? surely someone has come close
 
No AFL player has ever been able to emulate the feat of NRL player Glen Lazarus, who played premierships for three different teams in the Brisbane Broncos, Canberra Raiders and Melbourne Storm.

I can't think of any WAFL, SANFL or VFA/L players to have won a premiership at 3 different clubs; does anyone know of any from these leagues?
The only player I can think of at State League level doing so was Kyle Wilson who played in three premierships in TFL Statewide League football for three different clubs.
Devonport (1988), Hobart (1990) and Clarence (1996).
He was recruited by Devonport from country Victoria for the 1988 season.
Later went on to do coaching and coached Hobart Under-18s to the Grand Final in 2002.
 
Me and a guy from work are trying to figure out the 27 or more players that have won premierships at 2 different clubs.

The list I have sop far is Ian Stewart, Cameron Mooney, Barassi, Wanganeen, Hardwick, Dew, Pyke & Jarman. Obviously the age limits me to this kind of knowledge.

Is there a link to a site that displays the whole list or can anyone help he with the rest of the name?
Jason Ball - west coast n Sydney
 
Me and a guy from work are trying to figure out the 27 or more players that have won premierships at 2 different clubs.

The list I have sop far is Ian Stewart, Cameron Mooney, Barassi, Wanganeen, Hardwick, Dew, Pyke & Jarman. Obviously the age limits me to this kind of knowledge.

Is there a link to a site that displays the whole list or can anyone help he with the rest of the name?
Lewis jetty west coast n sydney( common combo)
 
Bump.

Updated list:
  1. Eddie Drohan = Fitzroy (1898, 1899) and Collingwood (1903)
  2. Mick Grace = Fitzroy (1898, 1899) and Carlton (1906, 1907)
  3. Frank Caine = Carlton (1906, 1907) and Essendon (1912)
  4. Jim Martin = Essendon (1912) and Fitzroy (1913)
  5. Charlie Norris = Collingwood (1910) and Fitzroy (1913, 1916)
  6. Tom Fitzmaurice = Essendon (1923, 1924) and Geelong (1925)
  7. Horrie Edmonds = Collingwood (1929, 1930) and Richmond (1934)
  8. Jack Carney = Geelong (1931) and Carlton (1938)
  9. Brighton Diggins = South Melbourne (1933) and Carlton (1938)
  10. Keith Stackpole = Collingwood (1935, 1936) and Fitzroy (1944)
  11. Gordon Abbott = Geelong (1937) and Essendon (1942, 1946)
  12. Peter McLean = Melbourne (1964) and Carlton (1968)
  13. Ian Stewart = St Kilda (1966) and Richmond (1973)
  14. Barry Davis = Essendon (1962, 1965) and North Melbourne (1975)
  15. Doug Wade = Geelong (1963) and North Melbourne (1975)
  16. Brent Crosswell = Carlton (1968, 1970) and North Melbourne (1975, 1977)
  17. Barry Rowlings = Hawthorn (1976) and Richmond (1980)
  18. Bryan Wood = Richmond (1973, 1974, 1980) and Essendon (1985)
  19. Darren Jarman = Hawthorn (1991) and Adelaide (1997, 1998)
  20. Martin Pike = North Melbourne (1999) and Brisbane Lions (2001, 2002, 2003)
  21. Blake Caracella = Essendon (2000) and Brisbane Lions (2003)
  22. Gavin Wanganeen = Essendon (1993) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  23. Byron Pickett = North Melbourne (1999) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  24. Damien Hardwick = Essendon (2000) and Port Adelaide (2004)
  25. Jason Ball = West Coast (1994) and Sydney (2005)
  26. Cameron Mooney = North Melbourne (1999) and Geelong (2007, 2009)
  27. Stuart Dew = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2008)
  28. Darren Jolly = Sydney (2005) and Collingwood (2010)
  29. Shaun Burgoyne = Port Adelaide (2004) and Hawthorn (2013, 2014, 2015)
  30. Lewis Jetta = Sydney (2012) and West Coast (2018)
  31. Isaac Smith = Hawthorn (2013, 2014, 2015) and Geelong (2022)
A very good list of players
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top