POTY QF v Adelaide

[AG]

5. Adam Goodes
4. Ted Richards
3. Ryan O'Keefe
2. LRT
1. Josh Kennedy

YPOTY: Alex Johnson

 

[grimlock]

15 votes to Morto! The X Factor

 

[Ed_Gein]

5 - Richards
4 - Goodes
3 - O'Keefe
2 - LRT
1 - Kennedy

Wow. It's hard to figure out who to put top of the pile, because it feels like putting Kennedy and LRT down in 2 and 1 is a bit of an injustice.....

 

[S120]

5. Ted Richards
4. Adam Goodes
3. Lewis Roberts-Thomson
2. Ryan O'Keefe
1. Josh Kennedy

YPOTY: Alex Johnson

Clear top 5 for me. Very difficult to assign points within that top 5 though. All 5 were worthy of being our BOG.

 

[MarkP]

5. Goodes
4. LRT
3. Richards
2. Kennedy
1. ROK

AJ for youngster and was all kinds of awesome

 

[Indie_]

5. Ted Richards
4. Adam Goodes
3. Ryan O'Keefe
2. Lewis Roberts-Thompson
1. Josh Kennedy

YPOTY: Alex Johnson

 

[BarneyBent]

5. Richards
4. ROK
3. Kennedy
2. Goodes
1. LRT

YPOTY: Johnson

Yeah, throw a napkin over the top 5.

 

[Dangas]

5. Goodesy set us up!
4. RoK was super
3. Teddy was brilliant on Walker
2. JPK = gun!
1. LRT was amazingly brilliant in his old possie.

YPOTY: Johnson was solid, in finals too.

 

[Onetonylockett]

5- ROK
4- Goodes
3- Richards
2- LRT
1-KEnnedy

YPOTY- Johnson

 

[Jack2Jack]

5. Goodes
4. O'Keefe
3. Kennedy
2. Richards
1. LRT

YP - Johnson

 

[MF]

5 Kennedy
4 Richards
3 Goodes
2 Okeefe
1 LRT

 

[Crackers27]

5. LRT
4. Goodes
3. Richards
2. ROK
1. Kennedy

YPOTY - AJ

 

[Mick Oxlong]

I'd love to play the old junior football 'team effort' vote but here we go:

5. Kennedy
4. Goodes (not a game breaker hey Stat?).
3. ROK
2. Hannebery
1. Richards (tore Tex a new one)

YPOTY: Johnson...**** he's good!

A very special mention to LRT, a game to rival his effort in 05 GF! Still want Grundy back though.

 

[SM]

5. Goodes - happy to be proven wrong and to pull my head in about him.
4. Richards
3. Kennedy
2. ROK
1. Morton

YPOTY: Johnson

 

[Mick Oxlong]

5. Goodes - happy to be proven wrong and to pull my head in about him.
4. Richards
3. Kennedy
2. ROK
1. Morton

YPOTY: Johnson

I tip my hat

 

[SM]

I tip my hat

In fact the original deal today was I had to drink every time Goodes touched it, and down my drink every time he goaled, but Vonn told me I had to do it for Jack instead... rather thankful in retrospect!!

 

[Mick Oxlong]

In fact the original deal today was I had to drink every time Goodes touched it, and down my drink every time he goaled, but Vonn told me I had to do it for Jack instead... rather thankful in retrospect!!

That would have been nasty...but worth it!

 

[SM]

That would have been nasty...but worth it!

Vonn had McGlynn and was almost comatose after the first half, Soph had Nick Smith and so started strongly, and Grim had Eski who never really threatened to knock him out.

 

[swansfan51]

How are people putting LRT ahead of Richards? He played a very good game but Richards was immense

5. Goodes
4. O'Keefe
3. Richards
2. Kennedy
1. Shaw - smashed Petrenko and provided good drive. Nobody gave him a vote so I wanted to recognise him

YPOTY - Johnson (AFL giving him 4/10 was very poor)

 

[The King!]

5 lrt- how many can do what he was asked to do?
4 kennedy awesome
3okeefe
2 goodes
1 richards

 

[grimlock]

5 Goodes
4 O'Keefe
3 Kennedy
2 Richards
1 Malceski

YPOTY Reid

 

[grimlock]

Vonn had McGlynn and was almost comatose after the first half, Soph had Nick Smith and so started strongly, and Grim had Eski who never really threatened to knock him out.

Eski had 20 touches, 1 less than Jack. Not including the kickouts.

 

[SM]

Eski had 20 touches, 1 less than Jack. Not including the kickouts.

Hey I didn't say Jack had a strong game, on the contrary I thought he had a very quiet one!

 

[Mick Oxlong]

How are people putting LRT ahead of Richards? He played a very good game but Richards was immense

5. Goodes
4. O'Keefe
3. Richards
2. Kennedy
1. Shaw - smashed Petrenko and provided good drive. Nobody gave him a vote so I wanted to recognise him

YPOTY - Johnson (AFL giving him 4/10 was very poor)

This is the POTY, it's an individual choice and everyone's vote should be respected as seen through their eyes.

 

[CAS79]

5: Kennedy
4: Richards
3: Goodes
2: ROK
1: LRT

YPOTY: AJ