Quadruple double?

[jerry springer]

The current members of the exclusive AFL & AFLW Quadruple Double Club - 10 x Kicks/Handballs/Marks/Tackles in a game

Scott Thompson (Adelaide) - 24th May 2008 Rd 9 vs WCE : 17 kicks, 15 handballs, 10 marks 10 tackles (0BLV/8CV)
Joel Selwood (Geelong)- 25th July 2009 Rd 17 vs Haw :19 Kicks, 23 Handballs, 10 marks and 11 tackles (3BLV/10CV)
Brent Stanton (Essendon)- 31st July 2011 Rd 19 vs Collingwood:22 kicks, 18 handballs, 11 marks, 14 tackles (0BLV/0CV)
Ben McGlynn (Sydney) - 19th April 2014 Rd 5 vs Fremantle:14 Kicks,10 Marks,10 Handballs,12 Tackles (2BLV/9CV)
Tom Rockliff (Brisbane) - 10th Aug 2014 Rd 20 vs Adelaide:22 kicks, 18handballs, 10 marks, 10 tackles (0BLV/2CV)
Corey Enright (Geelong) - 8th May 2015 Rd 6 vs Collingwood: 18 kicks,11 handballs,12 marks,11 tackles (0BLV/5CV)
Karl Amon (Port Adelaide)-26th June 2022 Rd 15 vs Gold Coast: 16 Kicks, 10 Handballs, 10 Marks, 10 Tackles (3BLV/0CV)
Josh Dunkley (Brisbane)- 5th May 2023 Rd 8 vs Carlton 22 Kicks, 11 Handballs, 11 Marks, 13 Tackles (3BLV/10CV)
Josh Dunkley (Brisbane)- 28th June 2024 Rd 16 vs Melbourne 17 Kicks, 15 Handballs, 12 Marks, 10 Tackles(3BLV/9CV)
Jack Steele (St Kilda)- 17th August 2024 Rd 23 Vs Geelong 15 kicks, 11 Handballs, 10 Marks, 10 Tackles(2BLV/6CV)
(BLV = Brownlow votes/CV = Coaches Votes)

AFLW

Charlie Rowbottom (Gold Coast)8th Sept Rd 2 Vs Carlton 22 kicks,13 Handballs,10 Marks,10 Tackles (2WAFL B&F Votes)

 

[paulige]

Need some proper quadruple double talk, drop marks which are all uncontested bs and replace with clearances.

I think the intention is that the stats are unrelated and involve no double-dipping. E.g. you can record a clearance and a kick in one action.

For something truly terrible, replace marks with:

• hitouts
• bounces
• spoils

 

[JADED]

I think the intention is that the stats are unrelated and involve no double-dipping. E.g. you can record a clearance and a kick in one action.

For something truly terrible, replace marks with:

• hitouts
• bounces
• spoils

We'll definitely be leaving the criteria as is, but

Xerri got Kicks, handballs, Tackles and hitouts once last year.
Marshall with Kicks, Handballs, Marks & hitouts this year.
Haven't looked any further but the list would double no doubt.

 

[sr36]

I thought you were calling for dropped marks to be one of the stats and thought that was brave

Mason Cox would have nailed that part of it every week for a decade - the other legs - maybe never?

 

[sr36]

I think the intention is that the stats are unrelated and involve no double-dipping. E.g. you can record a clearance and a kick in one action.

For something truly terrible, replace marks with:

• hitouts
• bounces
• spoils

Marks get you either a kick or a handball - they've slipped in there under false pretences.

 

[eth-dog]

Marks get you either a kick or a handball - they've slipped in there under false pretences.

Spoils the true 4th stat

 

[paulige]

Marks get you either a kick or a handball - they've slipped in there under false pretences.

Well you’ve given me a lot to think about, now.

 

[paulige]

We'll definitely be leaving the criteria as is, but

Xerri got Kicks, handballs, Tackles and hitouts once last year.
Marshall with Kicks, Handballs, Marks & hitouts this year.
Haven't looked any further but the list would double no doubt.

Oh no doubt - hence why I suggested replacing with any of those stats would be “terrible”!

The criteria are perfect as they are - I love how rare it is that a player gets it done. Perfectly balanced.

 

[Maddo11]

You can also get a handball or kick from a tackle if it's HTB.. you also may not get a kick or handball from a mark if it's the end of the quarter.

 

[dlanod]

Marks get you either a kick or a handball - they've slipped in there under false pretences.

They could get you tackled and a free kick against if you take too long.

 

[dlanod]

We'll definitely be leaving the criteria as is, but

Xerri got Kicks, handballs, Tackles and hitouts once last year.
Marshall with Kicks, Handballs, Marks & hitouts this year.
Haven't looked any further but the list would double no doubt.

I did a bit of research earlier in this thread - there'd be a massive explosion with HOs. Gary Dempsey would have 15, Stef Martin four.

 

[eth-dog]

With hit outs you'd have to put a minimum of 40 at least

 

[Orange crush]

With hit outs you'd have to put a minimum of 40 at least

HO to advantage

 

[H00t]

With hit outs you'd have to put a minimum of 40 at least

I think 10 hit outs is fine just that a quadruple double stays marks, kicks, tackles and handballs. And 10 hit outs makes it a quintuple double as something extra special that will be rarely, if ever, done.

Rather than have all 5 categories be the same weight and only four need to be achieved.

 

[sr36]

I think 10 hit outs is fine just that a quadruple double stays marks, kicks, tackles and handballs. And 10 hit outs makes it a quintuple double as something extra special that will be rarely, if ever, done.

Rather than have all 5 categories be the same weight and only four need to be achieved.

Might be worth it's own thread. I think someone will get there. Ruck is one role where they can get a lot of tackles but also run to positions to take a heap of marks. Big Maxy would have gone close at some stage, wouldn't he?

 

[H00t]

Might be worth it's own thread. I think someone will get there. Ruck is one role where they can get a lot of tackles but also run to positions to take a heap of marks. Big Maxy would have gone close at some stage, wouldn't he?

From a quick glance not really. Xerri or Marshall seem like they could do it.

Would need pretty much everything to go right in game for it to happen though

 

[Hobbes]

Adding hit-outs is ridiculous. Maybe 10 marks is rare and 10 tackles is rarer, but anyone can do them. 90% of the players on the field will never be a chance for 10 hit-outs.

 

[Maddo11]

From a quick glance not really. Xerri or Marshall seem like they could do it.

Would need pretty much everything to go right in game for it to happen though

Marshall got close a couple of times last season from memory

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

 

[katana]

reckon weddle is able to pull this off one day

 

[SSSSSS]

reckon weddle is able to pull this off one day

Don't think he'd get many tackles playing on a wing/HBF unless we play him as an inside mid but that would be a waste of his skill set IMO.

 

[sr36]

Don't think he'd get many tackles playing on a wing/HBF unless we play him as an inside mid but that would be a waste of his skill set IMO.

Weddle is like Kouta was. He'll be able to play anywhere.

 

[katana]

Don't think he'd get many tackles playing on a wing/HBF unless we play him as an inside mid but that would be a waste of his skill set IMO.

he's already had two games of 9 tackles.

 

[RobbyRoy]

he's already had two games of 9 tackles.

When? Career high of 6 tackles, averaged 2 this season. He's young and versatile for sure, so not ruling it out, but doesn't jump off the page.

 

[Bill Crouse]

Marshall got close a couple of times last season from memory

R17 2023 was his closest. 20 kicks, 10 handballs, 10 marks and 7 tackles

 

[kozi]

Tackles in by half time. Could junk marks late if they’re up by a lot