MVP R2: Votes v. GWS

[Headless]

Am I the only who who thought McDonald was just average? Looked like our BOG because everyone else was just that bad.

He was better last week, but also had more competition. This is delectably one of the slight flaws in our system; play well in a losing team, and you will likely receive fewer votes than an equivalent game in a winning team.

6. T McDonald
3. J Viney
2. J Hogan
1. C Salem

 

[wheaters31]

6 McDonald
3 Viney
3 Hogan

 

[Dory_77]

Am I the only who who thought McDonald was just average? Looked like our BOG because everyone else was just that bad.

Took some good marks, made some good spoils and kept Cameron pretty quiet all day. Did his job and with so few others doing there's, naturally he get's a greater share of votes.

 

[youngbear]

10 - T McDonald
1 - Hogan
1 - Salem

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

4 - T McDonald
3 - Hogan
2 - Viney
2 - Salem
1 - Watts

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

4. MacDonald
2. Hogan
2. Newton
2. Garland
2. viney

I didnt see Watts as being in our best at all. He laid a good tackle and crashed one pack, which was great to see, but he also put in some pitiful half hearted, hand waving efforts too. Just a massive difference between his best and worst, still.

Everyone sees the game a bit differently, I thought he was solid and we didn't have too many who were solid on the day.

 

[Demon 16]

4 Cross
4 McDonald
2 Viney
2 Hogan

 

[pure demon]

5 - t mac
3 - hogan
2 - salem
2 - viney
Hard to find anyone else worthy. So many played below par games

 

[CM Sean]

4 - Tom McDonald
2 - Jack Viney
2 - Christian Salem
2 - Jesse Hogan
2 - Daniel Cross

 

[ponsdale]

4 - T McDonald
3 - Hogan
2 - Viney
2 - Salem
1 - Watts

Agreed as above.