Remove this Banner Ad

Review R20: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly vs. Port: Like taking candy from a baby

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Not sure many would have assumed we could be in such a rich vein of form whilst still playing a number of marginal players - Cook, Pedlar, Taylor and Jones. I suppose Cumming and Rachele (hopefully) auto replace perhaps Jones and one of the other lads. Will be interesting to see who holds their place.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Schoenberg must also be on shaky ground .....that said I'm not sure of the contractural status of Murphy and Schoenberg
Schoenberg is definitely the easiest delist - even ahead of Murphy, Burgess and Smith (none of whom should be offered a new contract).

Schoenberg & Burgess are both on the rookie list, which just means we shuffle a likely 2026 delistee to the rookie list (as we have for the last few years), thereby freeing up a spot on the senior list.
 
So apparently Carr is going to recruit a bunch of mongrels to dig Port out of the hole they're in. Why do Port people always default to this mindset? They're cavemen stuck in the dark ages of footy. Are any of the top teams in the AFL right now that have made their list out of a bunch of thugs?
 
The commentary mentioned that last year Laird was the grumpiest guy ever but now has cheered up. He threw a tantrum for getting moved back but has been contributing much more to the team since doing so.
It was Ricciuto making a joking reference to Laird being grumpy (a well-known joke around the club), and a suggestion that a new relationship and new puppy might have "cheered him up".
 
So apparently Carr is going to recruit a bunch of mongrels to dig Port out of the hole they're in. Why do Port people always default to this mindset? They're cavemen stuck in the dark ages of footy. Are any of the top teams in the AFL right now that have made their list out of a bunch of thugs?
Any/all teams coached by Alastair Clarkson & Damien Hardwick? OK... not all thugs, but they certainly had more than their fair share of players who indulged in "unsociable football".
 
So apparently Carr is going to recruit a bunch of mongrels to dig Port out of the hole they're in. Why do Port people always default to this mindset? They're cavemen stuck in the dark ages of footy. Are any of the top teams in the AFL right now that have made their list out of a bunch of thugs?
Other than SPP there’s not really any snipers out there anymore who actively go out and hurt people? So not sure who they’re looking at
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Crouch is still AFL standard, no doubt. But his role as an inside bull has been taken by Peatling and Berry, and he has no other strings to his bow. At this stage he is a depth player.

We should be looking to trade him for a club that needs his sort. Or else just signing him on as depth, with a salary to match.

I've liked Crouch over the journey, but he has been replaced.
 
Isn't it nice having some genuinely elite talents who you just know love smashing Port and who continuously turn up for it in Thilthorpe and Rankine?

You can just tell it means something extra to them.

Nice to have locals. Can't wait to add Draper to the mix.
And Neal Bullen loved it as well 12 tackles and watch him for minute after he kicked that first goal. Absolutely pumped
 
Both out of contract, along with Bond, Gallagher, Strachan, Taylor, Smith, Burgess, Crouch and Tex I think
I think that’s correct.

Ignoring Gallagher as Cat B, I reckon Bond, Taylor, and either Tex or Burgess play on

One or more of Taylor, Berry, Butts or our 2023 first rounders yet to debut could be trade bait though for NWM in my view. If we can get Nas, we mortgage the farm.

So delist : Shoey, Murph, Smith, Crouch and Burgess. Crouch and possibly Shoey (actually rate him more than most) a chance to get picked up elsewhere
 
Not sure many would have assumed we could be in such a rich vein of form whilst still playing a number of marginal players - Cook, Pedlar, Taylor and Jones. I suppose Cumming and Rachele (hopefully) auto replace perhaps Jones and one of the other lads. Will be interesting to see who holds their place.

Picking the right marginal players is essential. Guys like Cook and Taylor have great football IQ and a lot of untapped talent. Much better than picking effort grunts like we have done for years
 

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

And Neal Bullen loved it as well 12 tackles and watch him for minute after he kicked that first goal. Absolutely pumped
Also very pumped when other teammates score. Actually all our players are. They are finding true joy in the moment. It’s brilliant to see. Goals, smothers, tackles. Perhaps this is Davis’s influence celebrating the ā€œlittle thingsā€ but love to see it
 
Crouch is still AFL standard, no doubt. But his role as an inside bull has been taken by Peatling and Berry, and he has no other strings to his bow. At this stage he is a depth player.

We should be looking to trade him for a club that needs his sort. Or else just signing him on as depth, with a salary to match.

I've liked Crouch over the journey, but he has been replaced.
Hopefully Nicks can put himself (the need to perform) ahead of an ageing servant of the club.
 
Picking the right marginal players is essential. Guys like Cook and Taylor have great football IQ and a lot of untapped talent. Much better than picking effort grunts like we have done for years
Absolutely but much of it is also the combo of a fit team this year relative to last (TT, Worrell, Rankine, Murray etc missing much) AND the ā€œbig 4ā€ inclusions of Curtin and the trade in guys. Add them all and it’s at least a third of the team that’s far superior. And career best years for Keane, Worrell, Rachele, TT, Soli, Dawson etc

What really excites me is we were only ranked mid table for salary cap pressure in the recent H Sun article (along with Power and way below stressed salary cap teams above us like Blues). We should be able to bring in a Nas ANd one ore quality player - I roughly estimate around 2-2.5m spare still in the cap

Bring in Nas, small crumbing forward and perhaps another swingman tall and the future looks very very bright.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Review R20: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly vs. Port: Like taking candy from a baby

🄰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top