Random Question Thread (Part 3)

[sthmelb_dimmies]

Opinions on McPhee's role at Freo post Barlow? His 119 last week has me very interested.

 

[walken79]

Ricky Henderson gonna keep his spot folks?

 

[footycool]

Opinions on McPhee's role at Freo post Barlow? His 119 last week has me very interested.

No, just no

 

[SandyMcManus]

Opinions on McPhee's role at Freo post Barlow? His 119 last week has me very interested.

Remove the interest mate. He was pinch hitting down and took a lot of marks. With McPharlin, Tarrant and Broughton coming back, expect to see Adam all over the ground. Would be a horrible pickup IMO.

 

[The Spornstar]

Ricky Henderson gonna keep his spot folks?

I'd say so, though if you're looking at picking him up at his current price he's probably no longer a bargain.

Any Swans or Eagles fans out there know what the go is with:
- Gary Rohan (is he likely to come back in this year?) or
- Luke Shuey (is he a chance as well by season's end)?

 

[kfleong2000]

Shuey is a chance by season's end, definitely. If fit he WILL play.

If.

 

[nsj91]

I'd say so, though if you're looking at picking him up at his current price he's probably no longer a bargain.

Any Swans or Eagles fans out there know what the go is with:
- Gary Rohan (is he likely to come back in this year?) or
- Luke Shuey (is he a chance as well by season's end)?

would have to say shuey playing again this year is unlikely.. hes still struggling with glandular fever. still seems a long way from training.

as for rohan, hes probably only an injury or two from a game

 

[nsj91]

a question as well.. andrew carrazzo?

racked up huge numbers early in the season, and is shown little respect by the opposition so always has the potential to go off.

the defensive jobs hes being given are killing his scoring though.

is he good enough to turn it around, or will he continue to score 70s and cripple aspiring sides?

 

[Chimpdaddy]

a question as well.. andrew carrazzo?

racked up huge numbers early in the season, and is shown little respect by the opposition so always has the potential to go off.

the defensive jobs hes being given are killing his scoring though.

is he good enough to turn it around, or will he continue to score 70s and cripple aspiring sides?

I think you can expect him to score high 70s, low 80s if his role continues.

How many more rounds do you think it'll be before Swan doesn't meet his b/e and falls a little in price? I'm basically waiting for him to fall to the 500k mark before I can afford him!

 

[The Spornstar]

I'm a little worried about round 22. Assuming all goes to plan, in my league my likely GF opponent will have from Geelong: Ablett, Selwood, Enright, Chapman and Pods.

I will have Enright, Bartel and SJ.

The Cats have WCE at SS in round 22.


I like the fact my team has a pretty even spread of players from the top teams, but this may cost me in round 22.

I need to upgrade and bring in a forward, should I be looking at Chappy, despite his dodgy hammies?

Do people think Geelong may rest players in round 22, on the eve of the finals, given their weak opponent?

 

[Ammo_Lover]

I'm a little worried about round 22. Assuming all goes to plan, in my league my likely GF opponent will have from Geelong: Ablett, Selwood, Enright, Chapman and Pods.

I will have Enright, Bartel and SJ.

The Cats have WCE at SS in round 22.


I like the fact my team has a pretty even spread of players from the top teams, but this may cost me in round 22.

I need to upgrade and bring in a forward, should I be looking at Chappy, despite his dodgy hammies?

Do people think Geelong may rest players in round 22, on the eve of the finals, given their weak opponent?

id get a few cats in...wont be rested, in my opinion

selwood, chappy and pods would be minimum 350 points between them round 22 vs eagles

 

[Banked.]

How many more rounds do you think it'll be before Swan doesn't meet his b/e and falls a little in price? I'm basically waiting for him to fall to the 500k mark before I can afford him!

Richmond and Carlton in next two weeks, all games from here at the MCG - can't see it happening soon, perhaps not for the season.

 

[The Spornstar]

Is there a precedent for players being rested in round 22 for teams in the finals? I would imagine coaches would rather rest players in round 21 than round 22, but I'm not exactly sure what's happened in the past.

That WCE v Geelong game in round 22 could be the most important DT game of the year. Most teams have at least 3 Geelong players, who will be up against very poor opposition (whilst Collingwood, Hawthorn and St Kilda are up against tougher opponents). However, if they are rested, that's a huge problem too. You'd think that Geelong wouldn't rest players because they will be probably fighting for top spot, BUT they are playing the Eagles....thoughts?

Still struggling with decisions such as bringing in Chappy/GAJ to finish off my team...

 

[IDIG]

Really not sure Spornstar. Being at Skilled im guessing they'd be less inclined to rest players as there isnt the travel aspect but with that said, Bomber has already stated that they will be resting so that seems a more obvious choice of game to do it. Really tough to say but personally i agree round 22 isnt the round to do it.


My question is, how does everyone think Hall will go this week against North ie. Scott Thompson. I'm 90% sure i'll be trading him to Reiwoldt but i think there's every possibility he'll kick a bag.

 

[pauldrc]

Playing an opponent who had H. Shaw (out) and both Webberly and Davis (out) as emergencies in his backs...does he end up getting Webberly's 54pts or Davis zero???

 

[Galacticos]

Do you get anything for coming first in week in your state in the schools comp?

 

[dylan123]

Do you get anything for coming first in week in your state in the schools comp?

WEEKLY LEADERS

Score the most points in your state or territory in any round during the National Schools Competition from Rounds 4-18, and you'll receive an achievement certificate to acknowledge your performance and a participation football.

Not sure if you get anything other then a certificate though.

 

[pauldrc]

Playing an opponent who had H. Shaw (out) and both Webberly and Davis (out) as emergencies in his backs...does he end up getting Webberly's 54pts or Davis zero???

Ok,

He gets the 54pts, which is odd, as I thought you got the lowest of the 2 scores if you have 2 emergencies in the same position, but since Davis didn't play, this zero doesn't count somehow....

 

[Cat for Life]

Ok,

He gets the 54pts, which is odd, as I thought you got the lowest of the 2 scores if you have 2 emergencies in the same position, but since Davis didn't play, this zero doesn't count somehow....

lowest scoring emergency.

 

[kfleong2000]

If Davis played and scored a zero, he would get the zero.

Any player that does not set foot on the field is ignored for all intents and purposes.

 

[pauldrc]

If Davis played and scored a zero, he would get the zero.

Any player that does not set foot on the field is ignored for all intents and purposes.

Ok,

That's what it is then, thanks for that.

Couldn't work out why the 54pts counted....

 

[Scootyb]

Does anyone else find that when they log onto the Dreamteam site it doesn't fully load, and when you put your password in you can see it, before not being able to log in? i haven't been able to get in all day today because of it. Does anybody know why or how to fix the problem?

 

[TheWhiteRhino]

I'm in a fantasy league that has the same scoring system as DT. I need to sit one of these guys this week:

Hurley vs Coll
Dempsey vs Coll
Gray vs WCE
Betts vs Rich

Any suggestions? I think either Hurley or Dempsey may struggle against the Pies but can't work out which one.

 

[TheWhiteRhino]

I'm in a fantasy league that has the same scoring system as DT. I need to sit one of these guys this week:

Hurley vs Coll
Dempsey vs Coll
Gray vs WCE
Betts vs Rich

Any suggestions? I think either Hurley or Dempsey may struggle against the Pies but can't work out which one.

Anyone?

Thanks

 

[The Spornstar]

Do Eagles fans think Ashton Hams will come straight back into the side next week?