Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread Random recruiting hypotheticals 2011

  • Thread starter Thread starter Krooooze
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

A More Expansive List Would Be.

Sam Reid (syd)
Shaun Mckernan (ade)
Mitch Brown (Geel)
Aaron Cornelius (bri)
Jake Carlisle (ess)
Jordan Roughead (wb)
Kurt Tippet (ade)
John Butcher (pta)
Jackson Trengrove (pta)
Phil Davis (ade)
Jayden Post (rich)
Scott Gumbleton (ess)
Ryan Schoenmakers (haw)
Tom Hawkins (gee)
Robbie Tarrant (nm)
maybe a Joel Tippet (GC)
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Blueboys7 said:
Mitchell is a beauty, just needs to get his body right. He has a good tank, great hands and is a nice set shot at goal.

At 198cm and an already imposing size, he could be ready to go by next year if his body holds up through a full preseason.

We still need another KPF prospect though.
Click to expand...



We have Andrew Walker to show that chronic shoulders can be fixed !!


Not great for a key forward to lose that shoulder mobility but Wayne Carey was able to adapt.


If not, he can use Walkers method of gaining more 'reach' with his marking !!:D:D
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Mitch Morton from Richmond

Yay or Nay ???
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

NAUGHT5 said:
I mentioned him last year.
Now that Walker is doing what he's doing, we really don't have a spot for him.
Click to expand...

I disagree, we could play him future up the ground, on wing ...

Don't think you can have enough goal kickers/offensive weapons to be honest.

He has talent to burn but is being dragged down by Richmond's toxic culture
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

lionel_luthor said:
I disagree, we could play him future up the ground, on wing ...
Don't think you can have enough goal kickers/offensive weapons to be honest.
He has talent to burn but is being dragged down by Richmond's toxic culture
Click to expand...

100% on each point. :thumbsu:
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

lionel_luthor said:
I disagree, we could play him future up the ground, on wing ...

Don't think you can have enough goal kickers/offensive weapons to be honest.

He has talent to burn but is being dragged down by Richmond's toxic culture
Click to expand...

I haven't really seen him play up the ground. But would he get a game as a wingman at Carlton?
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

NAUGHT5 said:
I haven't really seen him play up the ground. But would he get a game as a wingman at Carlton?
Click to expand...

He played some good footy as a midfielder last year but has since fallen off the radar. Has a lot of talent but his head isn't in the right place at the minute.

If he came cheaply I'd entertain the idea.
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Blueboys7 said:
He played some good footy as a midfielder last year but has since fallen off the radar. Has a lot of talent but his head isn't in the right place at the minute.

If he came cheaply I'd entertain the idea.
Click to expand...

Richmond brought back Tuck after weeks of being on the outer and he was arguably Richmonds best on the weekend.

Who knows how many rough diamonds there may be at the RFC.
They seemingly don't do themselves any favours with their treatment of their players.
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Tuck has purposely been on the outer despite decent VFL form, because of a verbal altercation he had with Wayne Campbell several weeks ago now.

Make no mistake - Tuck is gawnnnnn.
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Just out of interest...what's the issue with Tuck's ear?

Also, what's all that gunk Robbie Warnock has on his shirt every game? :)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

smashbox gill said:
A More Expansive List Would Be.

Sam Reid (syd)
Shaun Mckernan (ade)
Mitch Brown (Geel)
Aaron Cornelius (bri)
Jake Carlisle (ess)
Jordan Roughead (wb)
Kurt Tippet (ade)
John Butcher (pta)
Jackson Trengrove (pta)
Phil Davis (ade)
Jayden Post (rich)
Scott Gumbleton (ess)
Ryan Schoenmakers (haw)
Tom Hawkins (gee)
Robbie Tarrant (nm)
maybe a Joel Tippet (GC)
Click to expand...

take your pick lol
my top 6
reid
k. tippet
Mitch Brown
Tom Hawkins - you can't ignore the size of this guy. love to see him grab this comp by the throat. probably doesn't no how good he can be
Shaun Mckernan
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

smashbox gill said:
A More Expansive List Would Be.

Sam Reid (syd)
Shaun Mckernan (ade)
Mitch Brown (Geel)
Aaron Cornelius (bri)
Jake Carlisle (ess)
Jordan Roughead (wb)
Kurt Tippet (ade)
John Butcher (pta)
Jackson Trengrove (pta)
Phil Davis (ade)
Jayden Post (rich)
Scott Gumbleton (ess)
Ryan Schoenmakers (haw)
Tom Hawkins (gee)
Robbie Tarrant (nm)
maybe a Joel Tippet (GC)
Click to expand...
Bloody hell. Might as well put Buddy and Cloke on the list.
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

HARKER said:
Richmond brought back Tuck after weeks of being on the outer and he was arguably Richmonds best on the weekend.

Who knows how many rough diamonds there may be at the RFC.
They seemingly don't do themselves any favours with their treatment of their players.
Click to expand...

I Reckon Richard Tambling and Aaron Fiora could have been champions if they were drafted to another club.

The way that club has treated many of if it's draftees is appalling, i think Jayden Post could be another young gun ruined by Richmond
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

My mail is sydney may look to offload Jesse White ... I ask again
Yay or Nay ???
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

smashbox gill said:
A More Expansive List Would Be.

Sam Reid (syd)
Shaun Mckernan (ade)
Mitch Brown (Geel)
Aaron Cornelius (bri)
Jake Carlisle (ess)
Jordan Roughead (wb)
Kurt Tippet (ade)
John Butcher (pta)
Jackson Trengrove (pta)
Phil Davis (ade)
Jayden Post (rich)
Scott Gumbleton (ess)
Ryan Schoenmakers (haw)
Tom Hawkins (gee)
Robbie Tarrant (nm)
maybe a Joel Tippet (GC)
Click to expand...

In regards as to why these players failed to make my list:

Jordan Roughead - more a ruck prospect
Kurt Tippett - we don't have the coin
John Butcher - First round picks rarely move this early, Port would be very keen to hang on to
Trengove - Signed recently
Davis - CHB and a key to Adelaide, don't have the coin required to move him
Post - Not great
Gumbleton - Another injury prone player?
Schoenmakers - Lanky Key defender, not really what we are looking for
Hawkins - About as imposing as a mouse, we need presence not a token tall
Tarrant - Maybe, haven't seen enough to comment
Tippett - Haven't seen
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

lionel_luthor said:
My mail is sydney may look to offload Jesse White ... I ask again
Yay or Nay ???
Click to expand...

Nay.

We need a tall forward with presence. White aint it
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

lionel_luthor said:
My mail is sydney may look to offload Jesse White ... I ask again
Yay or Nay ???
Click to expand...

Yes. Still has a chance to be very good.
 
Re: Tom Hawkins to Carlton

Blue and Silver said:
Schoenmakers - Lanky Key defender, not really what we are looking for
Click to expand...
Even though I'm not up to date on his recent form, I would jump at the chance to get Schoenmakers. He could easily grow into a forward role like Walker and Waite. Even Jack Riewoldt played as a backman in a match against Carlton in 2009. Hawthorn wouldn't give up a third year tall for anything less than a best 22 player like Garlett.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom