Opinion Rank our list 1-30

[Mr_Moogle]

Not including blokes that haven't played AFL. (Curtin, Taylor, Edwards, Ryan etc.)

1. Walker
2. Dawson
3. Rankine
4. Soligo
5. Fogarty
6. Michalanney
7. Rachele
8. Pedlar
9. Murray
10. Hinge
11. Thilthorpe
12. Laird
13. Worrell
14. Milera
15. Keays
16. Crouch
17. Jones
18. Butts
19. Smith
20. Sloane
21. Berry
22. Keane
23. Nankervis
24. Cook
25. Gollant
26. Schoenberg
27. Sholl
28. Murphy
29. Hamill
30. Strachan

 

[Slippery Pete]

Bit sad when most people’s first picked is a man who’ll be 34 this season.

 

[Golumless]

Bit sad when most people’s first picked is a man who’ll be 34 this season.

If he kicked 40, sure.

Put up a 78 goal season and it's more than fair.

 

[Golumless]

For me, and purely a round 1 2024 ranking with no future weighting

1. Dawson
2. Tex
3. Laird
4. Rankine
5. Hinge
6. Murray
7. Fogarty
8. Milera
9. Smith
10. Rachele
11. Crouch
12. O'Brien
13. Sogilo
14. Jones
15. Michaelanny
16. Pedlar
17. Worrell
18. Keays
19. Curtin
20. Murphy
21. Thilthorpe
22. Butts
23. Keane
24. Ryan
25 Nankervis
26. Sloane
27. Strachan
28. Cook
29. Taylor
30. Dowling.

 

[George Kramer]

Tex, legend and playing incredible football still
Dawson
Rankine
Fog
Soligo reckon he’s going to be a gun
Max
Hinge
Murray
Peds
Rachelle
Thilthorpe
Worrell
Smith
Laird
Milera
Jones
Nank
Curtin
Schoenberg
Butts
Crouch will move up if he continues late form
Keays
ROB
Cook
Sholl
Dowling
Ryan
Hamill
Murphy
Strachan

Forgot Keays, out goes Neddy, woohoo

 

[Mr_Moogle]

How can anyone name Curtin or any of our other blokes who haven't played AFL? Is it the vibe?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

How can anyone name Curtin or any of our other blokes who haven't played AFL? Is it the vibe?

Frog said name who we like... & plenty to like going by the preseason!

 

[Mr_Moogle]

Frog said name who we like... & plenty to like going by the preseason!

Yeah but he's also asking us to rank them. Even if you like what you hear about Curtin, how are you supposed to rate him against other players?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Yeah but he's also asking us to rank them. Even if you like what you hear about Curtin, how are you supposed to rate him against other players?

This isn't who are the best players rating, but who do we most like.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

No, just pick the players in order of who you like.

Mr_Moogle

 

[Mr_Moogle]

This isn't who are the best players rating, but who do we most like.

Well that means I need to make a few cuts.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

How can anyone name Curtin or any of our other blokes who haven't played AFL? Is it the vibe?

Yep ; named him on talent

Him and Rachele my fav draftees of ours on talent of last 5-7 years

Froggy threadmaster said it could be interpretated anyway you like

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Tex, legend and playing incredible football still
Dawson
Rankine
Fog
Soligo reckon he’s going to be a gun
Max
Hinge
Murray
Peds
Rachelle
Thilthorpe
Worrell
Smith
Laird
Milera
Jones
Nank
Curtin
Schoenberg
Butts
Crouch will move up if he continues late form
Keays
ROB
Cook
Sholl
Dowling
Ryan
Hamill
Murphy
Strachan

Forgot Keays, out goes Neddy, woohoo

Agree Soligo !

Also think I should have put Max even higher than 6 , like top 3-4, he’s going to be some sort of player

 

[FR0GGY]

Yeah but he's also asking us to rank them. Even if you like what you hear about Curtin, how are you supposed to rate him against other players?

Rank them in your interest level or whatever.
Curtin for me has more interest for me than say bond or Strachan.

 

[Scorpus]

How can anyone name Curtin or any of our other blokes who haven't played AFL? Is it the vibe?

Not having played AFL at all is a huge positive for my rankings which are based on frustration

Hard to get frustrated at a guy you've never seen

 

[adelaidecrows]

Wow, I knew McHenry wasn't in our best 22 but to fall out of top 30 says a lot about his input.

 

[Mr_Moogle]

Wow, I knew McHenry wasn't in our best 22 but to fall out of top 30 says a lot about his input.

He knows he sucks too. It's why he's doing some TV. If he finds a way to get paid to go fishing, he's living the dream.

 

[Dangarman]

He knows he sucks too. It's why he's doing some TV. If he finds a way to get paid to go fishing, he's living the dream.

I always thought Rex Hunt had the best career in the world - gets paid to go fishing in the summer, and to talk about footy during the winter.

 

[Mr_Moogle]

I always thought Rex Hunt had the best career in the world - gets paid to go fishing in the summer, and to talk about footy during the winter.

For someone like Ned I think it'd be even more of a dream job than playing AFL.

 

[WeeBlake]

My list was an exacting assessment of entertainingness + potential + hope + unjustified positive feelings - frustratingness - irrational ill feelings - disappointment

 

[dogs105]

1 Crowell
2 Jarman
3 Jarman
4 Tasker
5 Koster
6 Modra
7 Smart
8 Bassett
9 Edwards
10 Robran
11 James
12 Dawson
13 Walker
14 Soligo
15 Pittman
16 Michalanney
17 Hodges
18 Bond
19 Dangerfield
20 Maric
21 Brown
22 Murphy
23 McLeod
24 Burton
25 Rutten
26 Bickley
27 Liptak
28 Murray
29 Laird
30 Vardy

 

[Mileratkinsshow]

Agree Soligo !

Also think I should have put Max even higher than 6 , like top 3-4, he’s going to be some sort of player

1. Dawson
2. Rankine
3. Tex
4. Laird
5. Hinge
6. Rachele
7. Soligo
8. Max
9. Nick Murray
10. Worrell
11. Thilthorpe
12. Pedlar
13. Jones
14. Fog
15. Milera
16. Mcrouch
17. ROB
18. Curtin
19. Keays
20. Keane
21. Butts
22. Nankervis
23. Smith
24. Berry
25. Cook
26. Gollant
27. Taylor
28. Schoenberg
29. Sholl
30. McHenry


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Billy_01]

If we disbanded and clubs had access to our list in a special draft I’d go

1 Dawson
2 Rankine
3 Thilthorpe
4 Rachele
5 Tex
6 Fog
7 Max
8 Curtin
9 Pedlar
10 Murray
11 Hinge
12 Laird
13 Soligo
14 Milera
15 ROB
16 Worrell
17 Jones
18 Crouch
19 Cook
20 Nank
21 Butts
22 Keays
23 Edwards
24 Gollant
25 Himmelberg
26 Schoenberg
27 Murphy
28 Scholl
29 Smith
30 Hamill

 

[WeeBlake]

1 Crowell
2 Jarman
3 Jarman
4 Tasker
5 Koster
6 Modra
7 Smart
8 Bassett
9 Edwards
10 Robran
11 James
12 Dawson
13 Walker
14 Soligo
15 Pittman
16 Michalanney
17 Hodges
18 Bond
19 Dangerfield
20 Maric
21 Brown
22 Murphy
23 McLeod
24 Burton
25 Rutten
26 Bickley
27 Liptak
28 Murray
29 Laird
30 Vardy

Ru sure about 18

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

1 Crowell
2 Jarman
3 Jarman
4 Tasker
5 Koster
6 Modra
7 Smart
8 Bassett
9 Edwards
10 Robran
11 James
12 Dawson
13 Walker
14 Soligo
15 Pittman
16 Michalanney
17 Hodges
18 Bond
19 Dangerfield
20 Maric
21 Brown
22 Murphy
23 McLeod
24 Burton
25 Rutten
26 Bickley
27 Liptak
28 Murray
29 Laird
30 Vardy

1 Anderson
2 A Jarman
3 D Jarman
4 Tippett
5 S Thompson
6 Modra
7 Smart
8 Rachele
9 Edwards
10 Pedlar
11 McGuiness
12 Dawson
13 Walker
14 Soligo
15 Pittman
16 Michalanney
17 Vince
18 Betts
19 Dangerfield
20 Jenkins
21 Knights
22 Rankine
23 McLeod
24 Burton
25 Rutten
26 Bickley
27 Lynch
28 K Johnson
29 Laird
30 Vardy

31 Sloane
32 Ricciuto
33 Smith
34 Hart
35 Jameson
36 Goodwin
37 Hentschel
38 Sholl
39 Doedee
40 Porplyzia
41 Doughty
42 Cameron
43 O'Brien
44 Bock
45 Henderson
46 Patterson
47 Wright
48 Jaensch
49 Tasker
50 Wiederman
51 Bone
52 Rehn