People said the same thing about North 12 months ago. A good draft, a shrewd trade or two and a couple of kids who have been on the list for a few years stepping up and it all changes quickly.Thilthorpe is literally the only Crows U23 who I'd have any interest in adding to our list. They are screwed for a long time.
North have hit rock bottom and are on the way up.True, yet north are still bottom and in trouble for a long time yet, so they are right ish.
In trouble for a long time yet?True, yet north are still bottom and in trouble for a long time yet, so they are right ish.
Literally the only thing he's good at is kicking goals, this is one of the dumbest ideas I've ever heard. You may as well say we should recruit Jimmy Rowe and try him in the ruck.
I have seen him play, and do think that they have some good young guys coming through as every team but Geelong does, but when can you honestly see them competing for a flag again? Next year, 3 years? 5 years?In trouble for a long time yet?
Have you seen Davies Uniacke play? lol
Thomas, Powell, Simpkin + pick 1 last year and another high pick this year.
I think they'll be ok...
I don't think they will compete for a flag, but easiest way to build a competitive team quickly is to have a stacked midfield. Second half of the year they have played a lot better than your typical spooners and there is still a lot more upside.I have seen him play, and do think that they have some good young guys coming through as every team but Geelong does, but when can you honestly see them competing for a flag again? Next year, 3 years? 5 years?
Bloody hell your being a bit generous arent yaHere's my comparison list. I tried to be as impartial as possible (and probably failed) and i'll be the first to admit that my knowledge of the bottom end of the Crows list is based on very little watching. I feel like we have a better top end and they have more depth of youngsters (who MAY develop).
I'd definitely take ours.
Port U23 v Crows U23
Butters > Schoenberg
Georgiadis = Thilthorpe
Drew = Butts
Rozee = Scholl
Duursma > Fogharty
Marshall > Murphy
Bergman = Murray.
Farrell = Rowe
Jones > McHenry
Frederick < Berry
Hayes < Hamill
Woodcock < Pedlar
McEntee < McPherson
Williams < Jones
Garner > Hately
Schofield = Worrell
Mead = McAsey
Lord > Gollant
Pasini = O’Connor
Burgoyne < Cook, Borlase, Newchurch Parnell
Yeah like I said probably a bit generous, though I assure there are those on the other side who wouldn't agree.Bloody hell your being a bit generous arent ya
are you Hamish? Are you a crows apologist?
rozee equal to sholl??? That’s deadset the strangest Thing I’ve read on this forum..
bergman equal to murray???
how are berry and pedler better than their comparisons. I’m not woodcock fan but fu** me hes done a shitload more than pedlar.. has pedlar touched the footy yet. Fredrick miles ahead of berry at this stage
farrell equal to rowe? On what earth. Ask all 18 clubs who they would pick first between Rowe a slow plodder with no game at all or farrell.