Ranking Collingwood Players

[richie_cole#13]

1.Nathan Buckley
2.Chris Tarrant
3.Anthony Rocca
4.James Clement
5.Scott Burns
6.Josh Fraser
7.Ben Johnson
8.Paul Licuria
9.Shane Wakelin
10.Simon Prestigiacomo
11.Shane Woewodin
12.Guy Richards
NEW. Chad Morrison
13.Tarkyn Lockyer
14.Alan Didak
15.Brodie Holland
16.Ryan Lonie
17.Richard Cole
18.Leon Davis
19.Cameron Cloke
20.Nick Maxwell
21.Jason Cloke
22.Shane O'Bree
23.Julian Rowe
24.Tristan Walker
25.Tom Davidson
26.Dane Swan
27.Mark McGough
28.Rhyce Shaw
29.Matthew Lokan
30.David King
31.Luke Mullins
32.Bo Nixon
33.Luke Shackleton
34.Andrew Williams
35.Justin Crow
Yet To Play
36.Zane Leonard
37.Brayden Shaw
38.Heath Shaw
39.Billy Morrison
40.Brent Hall
Rookie Listed
41.David Fanning
42.Dean Benson

If you don't agree with any players position just make a case...

 

[Ice goddess]

Woey and Didsy should be above Lockyer who is really very ordinary. Has not played a decent game for about 3 years.

 

[rychenroller]

Scott Burns No.2, the epitome of Collingwood

Guy Richards is way too high considering what he has achieved to date. Maybe next year, but I wouldn't call him top 10

Tarrant No.3, outshines Rocca like a supernova.

 

[Jabso]

1. Nathan Buckley
2. Chris Tarrant
3. James Clement
4. Anthony Rocca
5. Scott Burns
6. Ben Johnson
7. Josh Fraser
8. Paul Licuria
9. Shane Wakelin
10. Shane Woewodin


11. Simon Prestigiacomo
12. Richard Cole
13. Alan Didak
14. Brodie Holland
15. Guy Richards
16. Tarkyn Lockyer
17. Leon Davis
18. Mark McGough
19. Jason Cloke
20. Nick Maxwell

21. Cameron Cloke
22. Ryan Lonie
23. Tristen Walker
24. Shane O'Bree
25. Julian Rowe
26. Tom Davidson
27. Dane Swan
28. Rhyce Shaw
29. Luke Mullins
30. Matthew Lokan

31. David King
32. Luke Shackleton
33. Bo Nixon
34. Steven McKee
35. Andrew Williams
36. Justin Crow
37. Benjamin Kinnear

Yet To Play
38. Brayden Shaw
39. Heath Shaw
40. Zane Leonard
41. Brent Hall
42. Billy Morrison

Rookie Listed
43.David Fanning
44.Dean Benson

Top 5 Young Players (based on how good they are likely to be):
1. Richard Cole
2. Alan Didak
3. Cameron Cloke
4. Guy Richards
5. Tom Davidson

Copeland Top 5:
1. James Clement
2. Ben Johnson
3. Shane Woewodin
4. Scott Burns
5. Paul Licuria

 

[bucksisbest]

1.Nathan Buckley
2.James Clement-Chris Tarrant
4.Scott Burns
5.Anthony Rocca
6.Ben Johnson
7.Josh Fraser
8.Paul Licuria
9.Shane Wakelin
10.Shane Woewodin
11.Brodie Holland
12.Ryan Lonie
13.Alan Didak
14.Richie Cole
15.Presti
16.Leon Davis
17.Cameron Cloke
18. Guy Richards
19. Nick Maxwell
20.Mark McGough
21. Julien Rowe
22.Jason Cloke
23.Tarkyn Lockyer
24.Shane O'Bree
25.Tristan Walker
26.Rhyce Shaw
27.Dane Swan
28.Matthew Lokan
29.Tom Davidson
30.David King
31.Steve McKee
32.Justin Crow
33.Luke Mullins
34.Luke Shackleton
35.Bo Nixon
36.Ben Kinnear
37.Andrew Williams

 

[Jabso]

Any other kind of rankings you would want?
How about top 5 hair styles?
1. Brodie "What the f***" Holland
2. Richard "If Dids can do it I can do it better" Cole
3. Alan "I had the rat-tails first" Didak
4. Chris Tarrant's pre-season 2003 dreadlocks
5. Jason Cloke's short lived purple hair when he killed Carey

 

[IDGAF]

Easy............ they are schithouse

 

[Rocca Flys High]

Get lost!

 

[Rocca Flys High]

Top 10

1 Buckley
2 Rocca
3 Tarrant
4 Clement
5 Fraser
6 Burns
7 Licuria
8 Woewodin
9 Walklen
10 Prestigachimo

 

[Rocca Flys High]

Fanning>Benson

Rocca=2

 

[Rocca Flys High]

More likley to win games with Rocca than Tarrant

 

[rychenroller]

More likley to win games with Rocca than Tarrant

Tarrant is versatile, Rocca is a gorilla. I would so much rather Tarrant than Rocca. I rank Rocca about 5, behind Buckley, Burns, Tarrant, Clement in that order.

People severely overrate Anthony. When he's on he's great. When he isnt, he is deplorable. He doesnt bust packs as much as he should and he has the stamina of Marlon Brando (before death). I'm glad he's ours and I'd hate to see him elsewhere but he'd be number 5 max to me.

 

[Rocca Flys High]

no

2!

 

[rychenroller]

Post some justification or is this just inane chatter.

Hey 911 posts in 2 months, or about 15 a day...nice going.

 

[Rocca Flys High]

make it chatter!

rocca for vice

 

[Nardz]

Woey and Didsy should be above Lockyer who is really very ordinary. Has not played a decent game for about 3 years.

might have something to do with the fact that he's barely played a game in the last 3 years

 

[Rocca Flys High]

Who says Rocca for 2?


I do!


Rocca makes wins!

 

[Nardz]

Who says Rocca for 2?


I do!


Rocca makes wins!

my top 5 would be Buckley, Tarrant, Clement, Burns, Rocca.

To tell you the truth i think he's lucky to even fit into that top 5. if its going by form he wouldnt even be top 10.

see how he goes next searson...

 

[Rocca Flys High]

He'll make a lot of marks and goals


Not much goals this season

 

[Nardz]

He'll make a lot of marks and goals


Not much goals this season

he had an absolute shocker this season!

im hoping it was the injuries he was carrying.

if he has another year like that ill almost go as far to say he'll become nothing more than a fringe player.

 

[Rocca Flys High]

it's injuries

 

[Nardz]

it's injuries

hope ur right

then lets hope he has a big one next year, and gets us back into the finals.

if him and tarrant fire, all we need is the midfield to function correctly and we'll be back up there.

I can see buckley spending alot of time accross half forward, so we need midfielders to step up.

Burns will be vital i think, but who else is really gonna be the focus of our midfield??

lockyer, licuria.... didak?

 

[rychenroller]

Buckley for half back...roaming around the fifty to grab the clearance. He'd play a great rebounding role coz he still isnt much of a forward.

Focus our midfield? Lica when he's not running with someone, Burns unless they play him forward, Didak I think can do it...and dare I say it? Davis?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

1.Nathan Buckley
2.James Clement
3.Anthony Rocca
4.Chris Tarrant
5.Josh Fraser
6.Scott Burns
7.Paul Licuria
8.Ben Johnson
9.Guy Richards
10.Shane Wakelin
11.Simon Prestigiacomo
12.Shane Woewodin
13.Tarkyn Lockyer
14.Alan Didak
15.Brodie Holland
16.Ryan Lonie
17.Richard Cole
18.Leon Davis
19.Cameron Cloke
20.Nick Maxwell
21.Jason Cloke
22.Shane O'Bree
23.Julian Rowe
24.Tristan Walker
25.Tom Davidson
26.Dane Swan
27.Mark McGough
28.Rhyce Shaw
29.Matthew Lokan
30.David King
31.Luke Mullins
32.Bo Nixon
33.Luke Shackleton
34.Andrew Williams
35.Justin Crow
Yet To Play
36.Zane Leonard
37.Brayden Shaw
38.Heath Shaw
39.Billy Morrison
40.Brent Hall
Rookie Listed
41.David Fanning
42.Dean Benson

If you don't agree with any players position just make a case...

The ones in bold should be changed: Look at my best 25

1. Buckley
2. Burns
3. Tarrant
4. Clement
5. Rocca
6. Fraser
7. Lockyer
8. Licuria
9. Woewodin
10. Didak
11. Presti
12. Lonie
13. Wakelin
14. Presti
15. Holland
16. Richards
17. Johnson
18. Davis
19. Cole
20. J. Cloke
21. Maxwell
22. C. Cloke
23. Rowe
24. Walker
25. Swan

That's all I need!

 

[billyskene]

ben johnson will ******** in the copeland trophy, clement woewodin buckley will fight out the minor placing