*Rate A Player Thread*

[Knowledge]

I would have thought he could have potentially created his own new rating.

 

[Jessica Watson]

Nah, he's not as bad as the others.

He was actually good in one of the games he played.

 

[jd2006]

Konchesky is a 1, based on him being a current LFC player that isn't Haxi or Poosen.

What about Merieles and Cole? Or are they like in the category "they who must not be named"?

 

[belfast_bomber]

Meireles is all right. Slow as a week in Adelaide, but apart from that it's the rubbish around him that's making him look bad. And the shit tats.

Least he dropped the ludicrous comb-over.

 

[Jessica Watson]

Meireles tries hard and looks to move things on and get forward. He's a good player.

He's being asked to play ridiculously out of position (either on the right side of midfield or a deeper role than he normally does).

I think he's quite good actually.

Joe Cole on the other hand. **** right off, stupid w***er.

 

[SebastianVettel]

Meireles is a really good player - but like Gerrard, is struggling to provide much because of the shitness of others, despite actually playing well themselves.

Then again, Meireles wasn't a Hodgson signing, so it doesn't surprise me that he's actually good at football. Didn't want him - which would explain the ridiculous use of him on the right whenever ****ing Poulsen is fit.

 

[jd2006]

Yeah well at least he is an improvement on Aquaman, and right now it would be hard for anyone to look good in that XI.

 

[belfast_bomber]

Funny you should mention Aquilani, he apparently is hitting some real form for Juventus.

Pool should cash in while they can, because he will get crocked again.

 

[youngsaint]

Yeah i watched the aquaman on the weekend and he was excellent.

 

[Dagger5]

Juve have an option to buy him for 13m at the end of the season. They will take it if things keep going the way they are.

 

[Jessica Watson]

His finish from the weekend was class - however, the defending in the lead up to the goal was comical.

 

[Coledinho]

Yeah well at least he is an improvement on Aquaman, and right now it would be hard for anyone to look good in that XI.

Cant be serious.; Aquaman would captain Liverpool atm. The 13 mill Juventus will cough up will be the signing of next transfer window

 

[ShearMagic9]

Fabricio Coloccini...

 

[Jessica Watson]

8/10.

Was a big name signing from Spain, is an international player and a good one at that.

He struggled early on at Newcastle as he didn't adapt to English football, but his season in the Championship really helped him out, also now he has a good partner in Williamson, he's looking much better.

Not looking as slow as he was (but perhaps with more confidence, he's just reading the game better and backing himself). He's also making the right decisions and chipped in with a goal on the weekend.

He's very good at bringing the ball out of defence and his passing is good too.

 

[Crimson King]

Fabricio Coloccini...

Paging Lunchlady Doris and co..

 

[Benno_900]

Embers, please rate our failed signing: Samir Nasri.

 

[Crimson King]

8/10.

Was a big name signing from Spain, is an international player and a good one at that.

He struggled early on at Newcastle as he didn't adapt to English football, but his season in the Championship really helped him out, also now he has a good partner in Williamson, he's looking much better.

Not looking as slow as he was (but perhaps with more confidence, he's just reading the game better and backing himself). He's also making the right decisions and chipped in with a goal on the weekend.

He's very good at bringing the ball out of defence and his passing is good too.

Gotta love the hair as well..

Good post, though.

 

[ObaMartins]

I think its more his positioning more than anything that has improved, means he doesnt have to cover as much ground anymore. I think the partner is irrelevent. He partnered Bossong for most of his first season who is a good player. The bloke has just come along in leaps and bounds.

One of the best CB in the league. If he could teach Perch something about positioning (Perch has looked like Colo did in his first season, spending 100% of the match chasing his opposing player towards the goal after he's standing in Shearers Bar for most of the match) we'd be set at the back.

 

[Knowledge]

Embers, please rate our failed signing: Samir Nasri.

Best player bar Fabregas.

 

[Pumbi]

Embers, please rate our failed signing: Samir Nasri.

Hes been a failure because Embers is never wrong.

 

[Super Hans]

Benzema

 

[X_box_X]

8/10.

Would have liked to have seen him at the World Cup. He could have saved France.

Nick Kalmar

 

[iffstarz]

Can't rate - never seen him play. Maybe the poster below me can help

Rate: Mesut Oezil

 

[A Bit High]

Would have loved him at MUFC!!!

 

[ShearMagic9]

Cheik Tiote.