Rate Josh Fraser

[F/D]

Haha I never said that you idiot.


I said he could "potentially" do that. Did he? nope. Fat dud.


Lance is a crap player period. He aint a forward and he cannot play on a key forward downback. He is the type of player who gets cheap kicks in the backline when he was playing there this season.

Rawlings > Whitnall. We shall see this year

 

[Jeremias]

Perry? oh hell no, you bagging Perry? you seen him play? he is going to become a very solid B grade player.

i have seen him once in a wizard cup game.

but other than that, not at all, and i dont think many people have. how many games has he played and after how many years on the roos list?

oh dear...

 

[F/D]

How did he play as a "youngster" in the Wizard Cup game? I thought he played very well.

Perry was 19 this year, same age as Walker apparently.

He hasnt played much footy because he is still developing and we dont "need" to blood for for no reason like Carlton do. You guys shove your players at the deep end and let them sink.


Bye Walker! Stay at the bottom where ya belong!

 

[Jeremias]

so how can u say someone like walker is crap? he has played nearly 40 odd games as a 19 year old, yet perry, at the same age has played how many?

dont need to blood? you're right!

with the likes of rawlings, thurley, hay and green playing for the roos u r montys for a top 4 finish in 2006!

 

[F/D]

They'd all get regular games at carlton though, so your point is....?

 

[Jeremias]

they definitely would not...

 

[Beagle_Charlie]

gee lets see;

collingwood talented U22's;

julian rowe
dale thomas
chris egan
sean rusling
scott pendlebury
danny stanley
travis cloke

carltons;

andrew walker
josh kennedy
marc murphy

julian rowe - Average at best
dale thomas- probably a good player
chris egan - No good
sean rusling - WOW, he can jump high...no good
scott pendlebury - Untried
danny stanley - ???? never heard of him
travis cloke - Most over-rated player in the AFL

Colligwood have maybe 2 or 3 quality players under 22
Carlton have about 14-16......walker, russell, kennedy, murphy, simpson, thornton, fisher, waite, betts, bower, edwards, blackwell, bentick, carrazzo, Hartlett, O'halphin

 

[Cassius_Clay]

chris egan - No good

At least you got that right.

 

[F/D]

they definitely would not...

Yes.

Bowyer, Prendagast, Bryan and Johnson would though huh?


Haha you dont know ******** all about footy mate, give up.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Josh Fraser > Carlton

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Simple,
can't take an overhead mark,

 

[F/D]

Simple,
can't take an overhead mark,

Whitnall = Cant jump.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

julian rowe - Average at best
dale thomas- Gun
chris egan - Gun
sean rusling - Underated Gun
scott pendlebury - Possible Gun
danny stanley - May become a gun
travis cloke - Gun

Colligwood have maybe 12 or 13 quality players under 22
Carlton have about 1-3......walker,
russell, crap
kennedy, good
murphy, good
simpson, average
thornton, poor
fisher, average
waite, average
betts, poor
bower, poor
edwards, ???
blackwell, average
bentick, good
carrazzo, *cough*
Hartlett, crap
O'halphin untried

Why thank you!

 

[Jeremias]

lol Pie 4 Life you wouldn't happen to be a little biased there would u?

 

[Jeremias]

Pie 4 Life...please explain...Hartlett, who has not played an AFL game is crap, yet O'hAilpin, who has, is untried. how does that work.

methinks someone is an idiot...

 

[Jeremias]

Whitnall = Cant jump.

rawlings= cant play

 

[F/D]

rawlings= cant play

A la Fatnall.

 

[F/D]

Pie 4 Life...please explain...Hartlett, who has not played an AFL game is crap, yet O'hAilpin, who has, is untried. how does that work.

methinks someone is an idiot...

You realise this after so long?



Now go cut your wrists.

 

[Jeremias]

no thanks....i wont be part of the traditions of kangaroos supporters.

u can do it for me

 

[Jeremias]

Bowyer, Prendagast, Bryan and Johnson would though huh?

.

bowyer wasnt a walk up starter
prendergast is a dud
bryan is still 'young'-if u can use it as an excuse, so can I
johnson wasnt a walk up starter

interesting to see next year whether or not rawlings will be a walk up start for the kangas.

if he is, you might as well start cracking the eggs open and clean your face

 

[Beagle_Charlie]

Why thank you!

So, Jarad Waite and Brad fisher are average, while Chris Egan is a gun

 

[Jeremias]

So, Jarad Waite and Brad fisher are average, while Chris Egan is a gun

amazing, isnt it! and supporters think we overrate our players!

but then again, what can we expect, they are COLLINGWOOD supporters...

 

[Jeremias]

uh oh....i think someone doesnt know how to respond once they have been proven wrong....

 

[F/D]

bowyer wasnt a walk up starter
prendergast is a dud
bryan is still 'young'-if u can use it as an excuse, so can I
johnson wasnt a walk up starter

interesting to see next year whether or not rawlings will be a walk up start for the kangas.

if he is, you might as well start cracking the eggs open and clean your face

Hahaha North > Carlton.



The End

 

[F/D]

amazing, isnt it! and supporters think we overrate our players!

but then again, what can we expect, they are COLLINGWOOD supporters...

Egan > Fisher.