Analysis Rate our playing list from best player to worst by ability

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ads734

Club Legend
Jan 24, 2013
1,526
4,027
AFL Club
St Kilda
Potential All Australians

1. Marshall
2. Hill
3. Billings
4. Ross
5. Gresham

Top 10 players in the team

6. Carlisle
7. Membrey
8. Steele
9. Howard
9. Hannebry
10 Roberton - presuming he plays
10. Battle
11. Clarke
12. Wilkie

Mid Tier players

13. Jones
14. Savage
15. Dunstan
16. Sinclair
17. Geary
18. King (Based on where I think he will be by the end of the season
19. Lonie
20. Webster
21. Brown
22. Hind
23. Ryder
24. Butler

Emergency

24. Coffield
25. Parker
26. Paton
27. Long
28. Kent
29. Langlands

Depth reserves
30. McKenzie
31. Austin
32. Marsh
33. Joyce
34. Phillips
35. Clavarino
36. Bytel
37. Mayo
38. ALabakis
 

Ads734

Club Legend
Jan 24, 2013
1,526
4,027
AFL Club
St Kilda
Hind in front of Ryder? When was he all Australian?
On current output /potential for the season I have him ahead yes. I worry about Ryder’s production next year. I don’t doubt his importance in terms of structure though.

Also sure he was all Australian but on that basis he should be higher then Marshal but going on recent form /potentisl
Form next year I stick by having Himd higher
 

OxSaint

Team Captain
Oct 7, 2015
439
1,160
AFL Club
St Kilda
Top 10 now:



1. Marshall
2. Hill
3. Hanners
4. Ross
5. Gresham
6. Billings
7.Membrey
8. Roberton
9.Steele
10. Wilkie

Predicted top 10 by end of 2020

1. Marshall
2. Hanners
3. Hill
4. Gresham
5. Roberton
6. Billings
7. Ross
8. Clark
9. Membrey
10. Jones

Big max to be challenging the top 10 in the 2021 season
 

Top Bottom