Rate the coaches

Remove this Banner Ad

Benny78

Benny78

Cancelled
BeanCoiNFT Investor
Apr 4, 2016
8,847
7,062
Australia
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Ken Hinkley
I thought with the season to begin I would rate the AFL coaches. My list would go as follows

1. Chris Scott
2. Clarko
3. Ross Lyon
4. Woosha
5. Longmire
6. Hinkley
7. Brad Scott
8. Dimma
9. Beveridge
10. Pyke
11. Cameron
12. The others
13. Nathan Buckley
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Benny78 said:
I thought with the season to begin I would rate the AFL coaches. My list would go as follows

1. Chris Scott
2. Clarko
3. Ross Lyon
4. Woosha
5. Longmire
6. Hinkley
7. Brad Scott
8. Dimma
9. Beveridge
10. Pyke
11. Cameron
12. The others
13. Nathan Buckley
Click to expand...

wow....

1. Clarko (then daylight) - one of few coaches to build a successful team
2. Longmire - inherited a good team, but has kept them up
3. Woosha - won a flag with a good team, but has taken a tough job at essendon
4. Beveridge - won a flag in his second year, first year very good too.
5. Ross Lyon - hasn't proven he can build a team yet, and no flag
6. Don Pyke - short sample size, but taking over in the circumstances he did means hes done well
7. Chris Scott - took over probably the best list for a first year coach, had danger fall in his lap
8. Dimma - premiership probably boosts him half a dozen spots
9. Brad Scott - did well with an above average list, but didnt truly challange
10. Ken Hinkley - very mixed results so far
11. Adam Simpson - also very mixed results
12. Leon Cameron - hardest to judge. Two prelims, but took over a scarily good list
 
cecil said:
wow....

1. Clarko (then daylight) - one of few coaches to build a successful team
2. Longmire - inherited a good team, but has kept them up
3. Woosha - won a flag with a good team, but has taken a tough job at essendon
4. Beveridge - won a flag in his second year, first year very good too.
5. Ross Lyon - hasn't proven he can build a team yet, and no flag
6. Don Pyke - short sample size, but taking over in the circumstances he did means hes done well
7. Chris Scott - took over probably the best list for a first year coach, had danger fall in his lap
8. Dimma - premiership probably boosts him half a dozen spots
9. Brad Scott - did well with an above average list, but didnt truly challange
10. Ken Hinkley - very mixed results so far
11. Adam Simpson - also very mixed results
12. Leon Cameron - hardest to judge. Two prelims, but took over a scarily good list
Click to expand...
Adam simpson did bloody well to get us into a grand final with pretty much the worst midfield in the league and 2 kpb down for the season

Id rate him higher than 11th - thats tough
 
Cant rate Cameron. ..
Hasnt done anything in the way of team re structure. Bottoming out. Premierships and outlasting an aggressive board momentum shift.
 
Yeah anyone that doesn't have Clarkson first is a goose.
Then Longmire.
Then around a dozen pretenders, mimics and no-hopers.
Then B Scott, L Cameron, and A Richardson

*S Dew, not rated
 
kranky al said:
Adam simpson did bloody well to get us into a grand final with pretty much the worst midfield in the league and 2 kpb down for the season

Id rate him higher than 11th - thats tough
Click to expand...

Probably true. To be honest that 6-12 block could change so much just on this years results. If we can get you in the finals this year his stocks would definitely rise. Hinkley and Dimma are the two who could drop off quite a bit.
 
1. Clarkson (4 premierships, 62.3% win percentage)
2. Chris Scott (1 premiership, 70.7% win percentage)
3. John Longmire (1 premiership, 67.6% win percentage)
4. Luke Beveridge (1 premiership, 62% win percentage)
5. Damien Hardwick (1 premiership, 50.5% win percentage)
6. John Worsfold (1 premiership, 50.3% win percentage)
7. Don Pyke (69.4% win percentage)
8. Adam Simpson (61.7% win percentage)
9. Ross Lyon (59.2% win percentage)
10. Ken Hinkley (56% win percentage)
11. Leon Cameron (52.7% win percentage)
12. Simon Goodwin (52.2% win percentage)
13. Nathan Buckley (51.5% win percentage)
14. Brad Scott (50.8% win percentage)
15. Alan Richardson (37.5% win percentage)
16. Brendan Bolton (36.7% win percentage)
17. Chris Fagan (22.7% win percentage)
18. Stewart Dew (0% win percentage)

That was way too much effort for a shitpost, but if I was going to be accurate here I'd probably rotate the bottom half around a bit and the top half I'd say is pretty accurate.

I think the one thing I am absolutely certain about though is that Clarkson is by far the best coach of the 18. He is 1 premiership away from equalling every other coachs premiership cups won.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

1. Alastair Clarkson
2. John Longmire
3. Damien Hardwick
4. Chris Scott
5. Luke Beveridge
6. Ross Lyon
7. Don Pyke
8. Adam Simpson
9. John Worsfold
10. Ken Hinkley
11. Leon Cameron
12. Simon Goodwin
13. Brad Scott
14. Alan Richardson
15. Brendan Bolton
16. Nathan Buckley
17. Chris Fagan
18. Stuart Dew- too early to rate although early signs are promising.
 
As players (OK I am just looking for a survey we can win)
Bucks.
Daylight
Daylight ....... etc etc
Goodwin
Woosher
Chris Scott
Simpson
Hardwick
Longmire
Brad Scott
Cameron
Lyon
Richardson
Pyke
Clarkson
Beveridge
Fagan
Bolton
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Taper
  • Poll
Best place to coach from? Boundary line or coaches box?
Replies
10
Views
309
Howard Littlejohn
Howard Littlejohn
D
Coach How important are senior coaches?
Replies
2
Views
99
Cmarsh
Cmarsh
PowerfulPies2023
Top 10 coaches in the history of the game?
2 3
Replies
54
Views
2K
Mr.X
Mr.X
Lingsface
Rate the #1 picks
2
Replies
39
Views
1K
Saab NLAW
S
Taper
Coach Ken Hinkley - 250 games as Port coach
12 13 14 15 16
Replies
380
Views
9K
RonnieRaven
RonnieRaven
L
Concussion: Should Players Sue Opposition Coaches?
Replies
2
Views
253
jiphoc
jiphoc
Taper
  • Poll
Which current coach do you dislike the most?
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
462
Views
27K
Philth
Philth

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top