This, I'll take him umpiring Freo games anytime over most of the other bums and especially over the West Coast supporter Margetts that we get regularly.I reckon if you got a list of all the umpires in the AFL, he is easily in the top handful.
Sure he has a bit of a character, but at least he is known for that character and not being a rubbish umpire like some.
Sure he still makes mistakes but far less than a lot of the others, his weakness really is in being a bit of a attention seeker is that absolutely everyone even casual fans know him and therefore remembers very well when he does get it wrong.